“$1 trillion in exports? That is someone else's story”…‘Sighs from the people of the Banwol Industrial Complex, the cradle of manufacturing’ - 경향신문

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from Kyunghyang Shinmun (khan.co.kr). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
“$1 trillion in exports? That is someone else's story”…‘Sighs from the people of the Banwol Industrial Complex, the cradle of manufacturing’  경향신문

This article was translated by an AI tool. Feedback Here.

At the bus stop in front of Ansan Station in Gyeonggi on the 17th, workers board Bus No. 2 bound for the Banwol Industrial Complex in Ansan. Son Woo-sung

At 7 a.m. on the morning of the 17th, before dusk had fully lifted. As Bus No. 2 pulled into the stop in front of Ansan Station in Gyeonggi, a dozen or so people hurried aboard. After the next stop, the bus was already packed. Bus No. 2 is the workers' ‘feet,’ circulating through the Banwol National Industrial Complex (Banwol Industrial Complex), which spans 14.64㎢ (4.43 million pyeong).

A (70), met on the bus, is in charge of more than 100 lunches at a Korean buffet inside the complex. Asked about the mood around the complex these days. “The economy is tough. How could it be good?”

Designated in September 1976 under the Park Chung-hee administration as a ‘new industrial city development candidate site,’ the Banwol Industrial Complex has supported domestic manufacturing for 47 years since the first factory there was completed in 1979. Many firms are in machinery, electronics, electrical equipment, textiles, and petrochemicals. Its heyday was the 1980s and 1990s. In 1995, when exports first reached $100 billion, Banwol workers regarded themselves as the ‘vanguard of industry’ and felt pride.

Thirty-one years later, on a visit ahead of surpassing $1 trillion in exports, the mood around the complex was subdued. We met B (63), smoking in front of a textile company. His company set up shop in Banwol in 1987 and has been running its factory for 39 years. B said there had been no time as difficult as this year.

B's company mainly exports cotton to the United States. By November, export volume was up about 20% from last year, but operating profit was down 20%. The factory receives the steam used to dye and dry fabric from a nearby combined heat and power plant. B said, “The price of steam has doubled per ton from last year.” It is because the price of liquefied natural gas (LNG), the plant's fuel, has surged. As production costs rose, the company fell further behind in price competition with cheap textile products from China and Vietnam. Wages have been frozen for years.

For B, the ‘$1 trillion export era’ is someone else's story. He gave a hollow laugh, saying, “Is it not only Samsung and SK that make semiconductors who are doing well? Manufacturing is dying.” Then he pointed with his hand to a nearby construction site.

“Do you know what they are building? A data center. A textile factory has turned into a data center. Is that not symbolic?”

A hyperscale data center under construction at the Banwol Industrial Complex in Ansan, Gyeonggi, on the 17th. Until two years ago, another textile company stood on this site. Son Woo-sung

At the spot B indicated, a 40㎿ hyperscale data center, two stories underground and nine above ground, is being built. He said that until just two years ago, another textile company occupied the site. Employees he had been close to have now disappeared to who knows where.

C (56), a colleague from the same company who was listening nearby, said, “Even so, our country's textile industry is still competitive,” adding, “In technology and facilities alike, we are at the world's top level.” Leaving the advice that “even in the $1 trillion export era achieved on the tailwind of a semiconductor boom, the government must not cut off attention and support for traditional manufacturing such as textiles,” the two headed back into the factory.

D (69), a truck driver who has delivered materials to Banwol companies since the 1990s, also sighed, saying, “Compared with the past, delivery volumes have fallen a lot.” Asked for his thoughts on the $1 trillion export era, he said, “There is nothing in it for me, is there.”

Some are leaving the complex because they cannot cope with soaring prices. E (68) set up a machine shop at the Banwol Industrial Complex in 1991 but recently moved his base to Hwaseong in Gyeonggi Province. Having lived with the pride of being a lifelong ‘machine man,’ he said, “Machinery is the starting point of all industries,” and, “It upsets me that everyone talks only about semiconductors.”

Inside a factory at the Banwol Industrial Complex in Ansan, Gyeonggi, on the 17th. Son Woo-sung

Banwol workers' sense that achieving $1 trillion in annual exports is ‘someone else's story’ was not off the mark. When the Kyunghyang Shinmun analyzed export-import trends from the Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy, exports in JanuaryOctober this year for seven traditional mainstay manufacturing itemsgeneral machinery, automobiles, auto parts, steel, petrochemicals, home appliances, and textilescame to $189.5 billion, about 5% less than the same period two years ago. Because exports of these items plunged by more than 6% last year, we compared with two years ago to strip away base effects. That is why legacy manufacturing categories that were once the backbone of Korea's exports cannot smile even amid celebratory fireworks for the ‘$1 trillion record.’

Setting the JanuaryOctober export value from two years ago at 100, none of the seven items exceeded 100 this year. Machinery, the field with the most tenants in Banwol, stands at 91. In dollar terms, the drop is about $3.8 billion, the largest decline among the seven. Auto parts are at 90, and home appliances in the electronics field are at 82. Textiles, another Banwol mainstay, are around 94, and petrochemicals, despite a higher oil price boosting nominal export value this year, are only at 96. Steel is around 94, automobiles 99. Displays (95) also fell short of the level two years ago.

A view of the Banwol Industrial Complex in Ansan in 2014. Modern and Contemporary History Archive, National Museum of Korean Contemporary History

The biggest cause is China's low-price offensive, which B's factory is also experiencing. China, which used to buy Korean-made goods, now makes them itself and sells the surplus cheaply to other countries. According to data from the Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy, exports of general machinery to China have fallen 34% from the same period five years ago. The Korea Institute for Industrial Economics & Trade dubbed the phenomenon of Chinese products, pushed out of the U.S. market, flooding into emerging economies and Europe the ‘China Red Wave’ and issued a warning last October that “there is no more room to retreat.” According to the report, among the machinery Indonesia imports, the Chinese share is 60%, while the Korean share is 2.2%. Higher trade barriers have also played a role. U.S. tariffs have increased local production by automakers, cutting domestic parts exports. The European Union is also raising barriers through steel tariff-rate quotas (TRQ) and the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM).

It is natural for industrial structures to change as the economy grows. In the case of cheap, commoditized products, we may have to accept being outcompeted by China. The problem is that semiconductors, which filled that void, are not only cyclical but also do not create many jobs and have limited forward and backward linkages. According to the Bank of Korea's inputoutput table (2024), the number of jobs created per 1 billion won of final demand is 7.8 across all industries, whereas for computers, electronics, and optical equipment, which include semiconductors, it is 2.9. The production inducement coefficient, which shows how much a sector pulls along production in other industries, is also 1.614 in this field, below the all-industry average (1.808).

Lee Joon, head of the Strategic Industries Research Center at the Korea Institute for Industrial Economics & Trade, said, “Machinery industries, including automobiles, have far greater linkage effects than semiconductors,” adding, “The crisis facing industrial complexes in the southeastern region, where machinery industries are central, is leading to a crisis in regional employment and local areas.” He said, “We must find an answer no matter what. We cannot leave it behind.”

Behind a factory spewing smoke at the Banwol Industrial Complex in Ansan, Gyeonggi, on the 17th, a hyperscale data center construction site is visible. Son Woo-sung

Experts agree there is not much time, but they diverge on solutions. Lee said, “We should focus on finding ways to maintain production volumes while preserving our technological gap with China and securing cost competitiveness.” Producing more lowers unit costs, and keeping factories running sustains employment at suppliers and in the community. He argued for lowering costs through a range of measures, including electricity rate cuts and tax support. That is also the problem faced by B's factory, where the price of steam doubled and profits fell.

Others say the structure should be changed rather than piling on more support. Park Sang-in, a professor at Seoul National University's Graduate School of Public Administration, diagnosed the problem as “a break in the evolution of industry since the 2000s” in manufacturing. In the 1980s and 1990s, Japan and Germany, which ceded ground to Korea, moved into high value-added areas centered on materials, parts, and equipment, but Korea has not done so for 20 years. Park said, “Because restructuring after the foreign exchange crisis kept funneling advantages to large corporations, suppliers were bound by unit-price squeezing and technology expropriation and could not move up into high value-added areas,” adding, “the industrial structure needs to become more competitive.” He said, “Semiconductors are a blessing and a curse. Booms offer a chance to change the economy's fundamentals, but the illusion causes us to miss the timing.”

There is also the view that support should be provided, but selectively. Yang Jun-seok, a professor of economics at the Catholic University of Korea, said, “It is right to spend the money being earned in semiconductors on manufacturing,” but added, “If we keep supporting industries with no prospects, it is like pouring water into a bottomless jar.” He said machinery offers hope because it is not easy for competitor countries to catch up, and that textiles should focus on high value-added products such as specialty fibers.

“Manufacturing is dying.” “There is nothing in it for me, is there.” As such words were heard around the Banwol Industrial Complex just as the $1 trillion export mark was being reached, when will the Korean economy be able to offer an answer?

Original Source
https://www.khan.co.kr/en/article/202611191620017/?utm_source\u003dkhan_rss\u0026utm_medium\u003drss\u0026utm_campaign\u003denglish_news
Visit Kyunghyang Shinmun ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Culture