A staggered age of consent could infantilise Britain’s youth - The Telegraph
Russell Brand was convicted under existing law, suggesting the real issue is one of culture rather than legislation Credit: Getty Images/Leon Neal Charles Moore Show biography Charles Moore covers politics with the wisdom and insight that come from having edited The Daily Telegraph, The Sunday Telegraph and The Spectator.
You can see why the idea of “staggered” consent to sexual intercourse has appeal. Some victims of celebrities such as Russell Brand were exploited at the age of 16, when Brand was 30 or more. They feel the inequality in the relationship protected the exploiter. They call for a change in the law which would continue to allow sex between two young people but would criminalise it for older men (exact age to be discussed) with girls aged between 16 and 18. No mention has been made of extending this rule to boys as well.
This is aimed at restricting predatory men, but it should be admitted that it would also, in effect, be raising the age of consent for girls from 16 to 18 so far as relationships with older men are concerned. Has anyone considered that some 16 to 18-year-olds like being treated as adults and would prefer to be free to sleep with older men? Is it justified that such young women should be deprived of their existing rights? Or is it now the general view that 16 to 18-year-old girls are really children? If so, why does Labour want to give them the vote?
And what about equality between the sexes? Cases of considerably older women seducing schoolboys seem to have become more common in recent times and are widely agreed to be exploitative. Would this still be permitted, or would staggered consent apply there too?
If we do make this change, we will be going against the fashion for equality and permissiveness which has dominated since the 1960s. Homosexual acts were legalised in 1967, but only for men over the age of 21 (as opposed to 16 for women consenting to sex with men). This was a version of staggered consent.
The view then was that the difference was necessary because very young men were more likely to be exploited by homosexual predators. In the early 1990s, moves were made to reduce this difference. When I was editing The Sunday Telegraph at that time, we were, I think, the only newspaper to oppose this change, on the grounds that the threat of predation was real. But the counter-argument that homosexual rights should be identical to heterosexual ones won the day. The age of gay consent was reduced, first to 18 and later to 16, the Government using the Parliament Acts to push it through.
Now the idea of differential ages seems to be coming back as society becomes more conscious of exploitation and less committed to the idea of unrestricted sexual freedom. In a way, that recognition of reality was long overdue. For many years, social services and some GPs took almost no notice of the age of consent and lobbied to put girls under 16 on the pill. This produced a culture which exploited children and later helped “grooming gangs” hold sway.
On the other hand, do people realise what they would be doing to the doctrine of equality if they pursued staggered consent? Would they be prepared to countenance similar legislation for the homosexual equivalents of Russell Brand? If not, gays would suddenly, for the first time in history, have rights which were actually greater than those of straight men.
I tend to think that what is wrong here is not really a matter of law, but of culture. When the culture changes, and the licence accorded to celebrity is questioned, the law is there to do its work. Remember that Brand was, in the end, convicted under the existing law.
As Andy Burnham tries to make us climb back on the treadmill of Brexit negotiation, I am struck, just as I was 10 years ago, by the way the key argument is being avoided.
The discussion is presented, once again, in terms of economic benefit. And, once again, the clash is between those in favour of streamlining, and therefore going back in – and those in favour of free competition, and therefore of staying out.
Coming from a pro-Brexit point of view, but trying to be as objective as possible, I would say that the debate is bound to be inconclusive. Conformity to European regulations makes some markets more open to us, but Brexit freedoms give us much wider scope for innovation, if only our politicians would embrace them.
I think the much deeper argument is about whether the EU can ever become a “polity”, by which I mean a sovereign political entity whose institutions command the consent and allegiance of its members so that they would, for example, lay down their lives in its defence.
Unless it can become such a polity, “Europe” will not become the third force in the world which we often hear touted, standing between the United States on the one hand and China on the other. It cannot assert power, let alone force, in the way those two great countries can. It is, at root, a creation of bureaucracy and diplomacy, not of politics, nation or civilisation. In times of peace, we do not notice that weakness too much, but these are not times of peace.
By going back in, we would be rechaining ourselves to an entity whose dream of “ever-closer union” guarantees stagnation in a world which is moving much faster than it chooses to understand. There never has been and probably never will be an answer to the famous Kissinger Question: “If I want ‘Europe’, whom do I call?” European power would be greater if disaggregated, but its leaders absolutely refuse to consider this.
/file/attachments/3000/14450224_496932.jpg)
/file/attachments/orphans/Naledi-VoterTurnout-5Nov19_131323.jpg)