Actually, Prime Minister, Brexit is going rather well - The Telegraph

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from The Telegraph (telegraph.co.uk). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
The initial shock of Brexit was painful, but now it is totally irrelevant Credit: Getty/Jenny Matthews Ambrose Evans-Pritchard World Economy Editor Show biography Ambrose Evans-Pritchard is the The Telegraph’s International Business Editor, writing comments and articles focusing ...

The initial shock of Brexit was painful, but now it is totally irrelevant Credit: Getty/Jenny Matthews Ambrose Evans-Pritchard World Economy Editor Show biography Ambrose Evans-Pritchard is the The Telegraph’s International Business Editor, writing comments and articles focusing on world politics and economics – with a specific eye on monetary policy, central banks and global financial stability.

Before his current role, he served as the Washington correspondent (including being the US Bureau Chief for The Sunday Telegraph in the 1990s) and the Europe correspondent (based in Brussels) for The Telegraph. He has also written for The Spectator and The Economist

Sign up here for more exclusive insight from Ambrose Evans-Pritchard in our Economic Intelligence newsletter, delivered direct to your inbox every Tuesday.

Andy Burnham is careening into an economic, constitutional and foreign policy debacle with a frivolity that beggars belief.

The Prime Minister’s foray into Europe this week embarks on a course that will lock this country into new arrangements with far-reaching consequences, for which he has no electoral mandate, with the added outrage of a penalty withdrawal clause that binds the next Parliament.

Dynamic alignment is a euphemism for letting a foreign power impose laws on this country without a veto, as imperialists did to 19th-century China under the “unequal treaties”. By accepting this EU demand, he is sacrificing the core principle of a self-governing democracy – answerable only to its own sovereign legislators and courts – in exchange for trade terms that subvert Britain’s emerging new role in the world economy and trivialise the reverse adjustment costs of jumping back into bed with Brussels.

It is time for merciless interrogation of claims – repeated mechanically – that there is an assured growth dividend from returning to the EU’s regulatory orbit, or joining the single market, or rejoining the bloc entirely, whichever it really is.

The UK has outgrown the trio of Germany, Italy and France – taken together – for most of the last five years. What began as tentative catch-up growth after the one-off exit cost of withdrawal has since turned into structural outperformance, with the gap widening through 2023, 2024 and 2025.

The last 12 months have seen astonishing divergence despite a tighter fiscal policy than G7 peers. The UK has racked up growth of 1.9pc, compared with minus 0.1pc in France. It is outgrowing Germany by a wide margin even though the latter has launched a blitz of deficit spending on rearmament and infrastructure. It is close to keeping pace with Donald Trump’s America, where the fiscal and monetary pedals are both pressed to the floor.

Burnham told the Lord Mayor’s banquet that Brexit had cost 4pc of GDP – I say 2pc – but that figure is out of date and likely to vanish entirely by the early 2030s now that the UK has turned around its supply chains, restructured and broadened its global horizons.

Andy Burnham told the Lord Mayor’s banquet that Brexit had cost 4pc of GDP  Credit: Getty/ Carl Court Frankly, to borrow Burnham’s diction, the UK’s resilience has been nothing short of a miracle given the strangulation of business by this Government. From my angle covering the world economy, there has been a marked shift in perceptions of Britain as the economic facts bulldoze their way through years of Brexit false narrative. This is belatedly penetrating the British internal debate, the last redoubt of cognitive resistance.

Burnham himself is in flagrant contradiction, talking up the UK’s economic recovery when it suits while talking it down whenever the subject is Brexit.

Who, exactly, in the economic sphere is clamouring for a deep reset that fundamentally reverses British independence?

“Businesses aren’t looking to relitigate the referendum. None of the business leaders I speak to want to reopen that debate,” said Rain Newton-Smith, the chief executive of the Confederation of British Industry

“Five years ago, businesses would have supported joining the customs union. But the reality is the world has changed ... alignment isn’t a silver bullet,” she told the Financial Times in June.

Yes, CBI wants better cooperation with the EU. We mostly all do. But that is entirely different from dynamic alignment.

TechUK does not want to reopen this can of worms but, more surprisingly, nor does the Chemical Industries Association. It wants the existing trade deal with the EU to be enforced sensibly by Brussels. So do its peers in the bloc itself.

One might assume that the National Farmers Union is shouting hurrahs over this week’s accord on food and farming. It is doing no such thing. “UK: EU reset deals spell danger warns NFU,” was the headline of a recent report by Farmers Weekly.

Whatever the NFU may have thought about Brexit in the first place, it has come to like doing things differently. It wants easier trade but on the basis of “equivalence” where each side respects the other’s rules, a legitimate demand given that UK standards are higher than what is actually enforced in much of Europe and given that farm trade is mostly one-way traffic in favour of the EU.

CropLife UK warns that signing up to EU rules – ill-adapted to our wet, northern, island climate – would cut farm income by up to £800m in the first year and render the UK “less self-sufficient in food” at exactly the moment when it should be growing more.

“It’s important we get this right, so British farmers aren’t unduly bound by rules which restrict our ambitions for food production,” said Tom Bradshaw, the NFU’s president.

He said whole areas should be “excluded entirely”. By that he means Britain’s flourishing industries of gene editing, precision breeding, ag-tech and cell-protein – huge global growth technologies of the 2030s. These could come to a juddering halt if the UK has to accept the EU novel foods directive under Burnham’s deal. A short-term stay of execution changes nothing.

The Government pretends that the rules apply only to those exporting into the EU. Leaked drafts suggest that it applies to all UK legislation in these fields. It gives the EU deep reach into the UK’s internal affairs for an alleged gain – more likely a net loss – that does not move the macroeconomic needle.

Roman Kříž, the head of the Czech start-up BeneMeat, wrote an open letter to the Prime Minister in September entitled “Britain’s biotechnology lead should not be negotiated away”. He is freezing BeneMeat’s investment in the UK – to be Europe’s largest pilot facility for cultivated meat – until the matter is resolved.

“Companies need to know whether Britain intends to remain a place where emerging food biotechnologies can be developed and commercialised,” he wrote. “Without that clarity, investment, partnerships and expertise will move elsewhere.

“Uncertainty surrounding Britain’s future approach to biotechnology is already causing companies such as ours to put investment, partnerships and commercial plans on hold.”

This is the story of British tech across the board.

We know one large reason why Britain’s economy is rebounding. It is an AI pocket superpower, third in Capital Economics’ world ranking after the US and China, with rapid diffusion and more than 10,500 AI companies, including refugee start-ups from the EU’s calamitous AI act.

The Bank of England says AI and cloud computing have accounted for almost a fifth of GDP growth this year, triggering a near double-digit expansion of business spending. We can only guess how much of this is because of the UK’s bottom-up approach to AI – widely admired globally – but what we do know is that Europe’s leading companies are up in arms against the EU’s suffocating blanket of top-down, fear-led, digital laws.

In 2025, Europe’s 45 biggest technology and industrial companies called for a two-year “stop-clock” on the AI act before it did any more damage. Brussels made the right noises but has not, in fact, corrected the problem, just as it has not done much, beyond hand-wringing, about the Draghi Report on the causes of Europe’s vertiginous economic decline.

The tech barons have since tried again, in more alarming tones. “More than three years after the ‘ChatGPT moment’, Europe is still debating regulation, while others have long shifted focus to scaling AI in physical systems and robotics,” they wrote.

“Companies in Europe face stifling, unnecessarily complex and often overlapping rules that make it incredibly hard to keep pace with the speed of technological progress ... Europe is losing global competitiveness every day.”

Yup. Is this what Burnham wants to embrace? For whatever motive – a mixture of narrow and immediate Westminster calculation, failure to keep up with economic facts, or Labour’s dreamy romanticisation of a Europe that does not exist – he seems hellbent on sabotaging Britain’s efforts to reinvent itself as an open, global, cyber-savvy, 21st-century economy.

What angered me most about his speech on Monday night was his claim that Britain had become more “isolationist” since Brexit. It has done the exact opposite. It is Europe that has sunk further into paralysed provincialism.

He railed against a “needlessly hard Brexit”, but a soft Brexit is a facile illusion. You are either in the EU – de jure with voting rights, or de facto as a legal province – or you embark on a different course. The EU was not offering a soft option on tolerable terms in any case. It expressly refused to trade on the normal basis of mutual recognition that governs global commerce.

This reset deal risks breaching the spirit and commercial terms of the UK’s membership of the Pacific-Americas trade pact (CPTPP). The logic of travel is that the UK will have to resile from all its trade deals signed since Brexit – and how will it explain this to those countries, may I ask?

The absurdity of this is that the EU itself is now pursuing closer ties to the CPTPP. Germany wants to go further and faster, calling for a full EU-CPTPP free trade agreement with integrated supply chains.

The plan includes a joint protocol on “rules of origin” to cut trade friction. All Britain has to do is wait a bit longer and many of the post-Brexit barriers to trade in Europe will fall away via this mechanism – without having to become an EU legal satellite.

Burnham says the “Brexit we were given has not worked”. I have no idea what he is talking about. What is not working?

Britain is a self-governing liberal democracy with fully functioning institutions under its own laws and courts. It has low unemployment (4.6pc), solid growth, the second lowest debt-to-GDP ratio in the G7, under a Labour Government with a stonking majority able to conduct the sort of industrial policy it could not have done inside the EU. Why does Labour find this so irksome?

The initial shock of Brexit was painful, though less painful than I feared. But that is now irrelevant. Britain has shed the learned infantilism of subcontracting its trade policy and state functions to EU bodies. It has relearnt how to govern itself, clumsily at first, but getting better.

The question today is whether there is any conceivable value in again becoming enmeshed in a bloc that has proved incapable of reforming itself, is less than the sum of its parts, and is widely viewed around the world as a failing experiment, leaving aside the €1tn (£830bn) of EU liabilities accumulated by Brussels since Covid.

Burnham will discover what he is getting into once Brexiteers start to mobilise their arguments and the sharp-clawed campaign group Stay Out exposes his waffle. The soft polls in favour of Rejoin will collapse. “He will impale himself and his party,” said Boris Johnson.

It can end only badly if the Prime Minister persists, probably in a fresh divorce after further years of needless acrimony, because no democracy (except minnows under constraint) can accept the endless chafing of laws imposed by a foreign power without consent.

The emperor had no clothes, he told us. Well, indeed, my friend – but ask not for whom the clothes are made, for they are worn by thee.

Original Source
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2026/11/18/actually-prime-minister-brexit-is-going-rather-well/
Visit The Telegraph ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Politics