ANC wants purse strings, Speakers, as price for backing ActionSA mayors - TimesLIVE
The ANC is prepared to hand ActionSA the mayoral chains in Johannesburg and Tshwane — but wants to retain control of the money, the council chambers and key oversight positions.
In a significant development in Gauteng’s coalition negotiations, ANC secretary-general Fikile Mbalula has formally accepted ActionSA’s proposal to take the executive mayoralties in the country’s two biggest metros, while demanding that his party control the finance portfolios and speakers’ offices in both municipalities.
In a letter to ActionSA national chairperson Michael Beaumont dated November 18, Mbalula set out the ANC’s proposed division of political power across Johannesburg, Tshwane and Ekurhuleni, making it clear that the party would not surrender its influence in any administration formed with ActionSA.
“Wherever the ANC enters a government alongside ActionSA, whether or not it holds the chain of office, the ANC takes the speaker’s chair and the finance portfolio,” he said.
The proposal gives ActionSA the executive mayoralties in Johannesburg and Tshwane, but leaves the ANC with significant control over municipal finances, council oversight and several key service-delivery portfolios.
In Johannesburg, ActionSA would take the mayoralty and control public safety, infrastructure and services, group corporate and shared services, and economic and development planning.
A council of this size, carried on a margin of nine, cannot be run with the mayoralty in one party and both the deputy mayoralty and the chair of the house in another. The executive would be unable to act whenever the mayor is out of the metro
The ANC wants the deputy mayor’s office, the speaker’s chair and finance portfolio, as well as control of water and environment, infrastructure and services, roads and transport, and human settlements.
It is also seeking the chair of the Municipal Public Accounts Committee (MPAC), which scrutinises municipal expenditure and performance.
In Tshwane, the proposed arrangement is similar. ActionSA would take the mayoralty, utilities, public safety, corporate and shared services, and economic development and spatial planning.
The ANC would control the deputy mayor’s office, which would carry the finance portfolio, the speaker’s chair, roads and transport, and human settlements.
The ANC has also agreed in principle that the EFF should receive the health, environment and agriculture portfolios, subject to an agreement with the party.
As it pertains to Ekurhuleni, Mbalula wants the ANC to hold the mayoralty, the speaker’s chair, finance portfolio and a newly created deputy mayor’s office, arguing that the municipality’s narrow nine-seat majority makes it too risky to divide the top executive positions between parties.
“A council of this size, carried on a margin of nine, cannot be run with the mayoralty in one party and both the deputy mayoralty and the chair of the house in another,” he said. “The executive would be unable to act whenever the mayor is out of the metro.”
The ANC has indicated that it is prepared to negotiate a substantial allocation of mayoral committee portfolios and section 79 committee chairpersonships for ActionSA, with the details to be worked out by the parties’ Gauteng negotiating teams.
Mbalula also accepted ActionSA’s proposal that section 79 committee chairpersons should, as a general principle, come from a different party from the member of the mayoral committee responsible for the corresponding portfolio. He described the arrangement as “a sound check”, saying the ANC had incorporated it as a general principle.
The ANC is also seeking the MPAC chairpersonship in both Johannesburg and Tshwane. However, the proposed distribution of positions is likely to face resistance from other parties whose support will be critical to the formation of stable administrations.
An ANC insider said the party anticipated that the EFF and MK Party would push for senior positions in the mayoral committees, particularly in Johannesburg.
“This is part of the talks. We are obviously going to ask for the lion’s share when it comes to positions. However, there is still room to negotiate. There are other parties involved. We expect that they will have a say in the matter. It’s still a long way to go and this must be canvassed with the national executive committee as well. We will then come out of Friday’s meeting with the NEC with a clear path,” the insider said.
The negotiations follow the ANC’s first multilateral meeting with ActionSA, the EFF and MK Party in Sandton on Wednesday.
Together, the four parties command 138 seats in Johannesburg’s 270-seat council, two more than the 136 required for a majority. The ANC has 64 seats, ActionSA 42, the EFF 17 and MK Party 15.
The numbers give the parties a potential route to power, but the distribution of executive positions could prove a major obstacle as each seeks to maximise its influence in the new administration.
Mbalula said the ANC agreed with ActionSA that governing majorities with margins of five and nine seats in the metros were uncomfortably narrow. Whether to widen the coalitions in Johannesburg and Tshwane would be discussed by the party’s national executive committee (NEC).
He also acknowledged ActionSA’s offer to vacate one proportional representation seat in each of Gauteng’s three metros to accommodate ANC candidates.
“The ANC notes with appreciation ActionSA’s willingness to vacate one seat in each of the three Gauteng metros. It is a matter for the ANC’s National Officials and the Secretary-General will revert on it directly,” he said.
The Sunday Times previously reported that ActionSA had proposed giving up one PR seat in each metro to make way for ANC councillors who would take up deputy mayoral positions.
The Sunday Times understands that the proposal followed lobbying by the Gauteng ANC, which wants Loyiso Masuku to deputise ActionSA leader Herman Mashaba in Johannesburg. But while the ANC has accepted much of ActionSA’s proposed coalition framework, Mbalula identified three areas of disagreement.
The first concerns the appointment of a joint caucus chairperson. ActionSA’s proposal would prevent the party with the largest number of councillors in a coalition from holding the position. The ANC argued that this would unfairly exclude it in Johannesburg and Ekurhuleni.
Mbalula said the ANC accepted the principle that the party holding the mayoralty should not also control the caucus responsible for holding the mayor accountable, but proposed an alternative formulation that would not automatically exclude the largest party.
The second disagreement relates to a proposal that reports be withdrawn from council whenever a dispute concerning them is raised. Mbalula warned that in a multi-party council this could effectively give coalition partners a veto over the budget, which he said was incompatible with the Municipal Finance Management Act.
The ANC also rejected a proposal requiring unanimous agreement from all coalition partners before motions could be tabled, arguing that it would prevent ward councillors from raising local concerns. It proposed limiting the restriction to motions that cut across the coalition accord.
The most significant policy disagreement, however, concerns ActionSA’s proposal for specialised illegal immigration units within metro police departments.
Mbalula rejected the proposal, arguing that immigration enforcement is a national government responsibility and not a municipal police function.
“Finally, and with respect, the ANC declines the proposal for specialised illegal immigration units in the metro police. A municipal police service is established under section 64 of the South African Police Service Act for traffic policing, the policing of by-laws and crime prevention. Immigration enforcement is a national competence under the Immigration Act and rests with the department of home affairs and the South African Police Service.”
He said the ANC would instead support stronger by-law enforcement and inspection capacity, as well as cooperation with the police and home affairs.
“The ANC will not write a municipal immigration unit into a coalition instrument. It offers in its place a strengthened by-law compliance and inspection capacity, and co-operation with the police service and home affairs through the structures that exist for it. On the metro police otherwise the ANC agrees with you, including the specialised narcotics and cable-theft units, within the powers that section 64 confers,” Mbalula said.
