Andy Burnham opens door to retreat on Rayner’s job reforms - The Telegraph
Andy Burnham has suggested he will consider making changes to Angela Rayner’s employment reforms.
The Prime Minister said there was “a balance to be struck” after Alan Milburn argued in his welfare review that looming restrictions on zero-hours contracts risked having “unintended consequences” for youth employment.
Asked about the criticism, Mr Burnham told BBC Breakfast: “There is a balance to be struck, and we need to consider all of these things carefully.
“But it is important to consider on the other side of this that the more you strengthen employment security, that can create more durable jobs that young people then are more likely to stay in. So there’s a balance to be struck here.
“But as I say, we’re going to consider all of this in the round.”
In his long-awaited review of youth worklessness, Mr Milburn criticised Labour’s workers’ rights reforms, warning that policies championed by Ms Rayner risk worsening youth unemployment.
The Government’s entire package of workers’ rights reforms “could have major implications at a time when the youth labour market is already weak”, he added.
Mr Milburn warned that more than a third of employers had already cut back on hiring plans because of the Employment Rights Act, which has been championed by Ms Rayner.
Andy Burnham said there was ‘a balance to be struck’ to strengthen employment security and create more jobs Credit: PA/Peter Nicholls Business leaders urged Mr Burnham to roll back the reforms, which were described as a “catastrophe” for job creation.
On Tuesday night, the Prime Minister expressed scepticism about any such proposal, telling The Times that “the more secure you make employment, the more likely it is that someone will stay in employment”.
Mr Burnham also left the door open to Mr Milburn’s suggestion that he raise the threshold at which firms pay National Insurance contributions for under-24s.
Asked if the last government was wrong to raise National Insurance, he told LBC: “I think it’s something you’ve got to consider very carefully going forward.
“I will want to look at all of the evidence in relation to it, but also the affordability of making any change to National Insurance.”
Bosses also backed Mr Milburn’s call to cut employer National Insurance contributions for young workers.
The recommendation formed part of a 278-page review that called for root-and-branch reform across benefits, education and business to move young people off welfare and into work.
Without action, the number of under-25s not in employment, education or training – also known as Neets – is on track to hit a record 1.27 million by 2031.
Elsewhere in his interview with BBC Breakfast, Mr Burnham said he wanted to see the number of Neets fall “as soon as possible”.
Mr Milburn called for the Government to introduce a new benefit system for young people and a legal requirement to provide them with a path into work, education or training within four months. Those who refuse to engage face having their benefits docked.
The package of reforms will cost billions of pounds, with savings promised only after a decade. However, the Government refused to disclose how much taxpayers would be expected to spend on employment programmes in the next 10 years.
Mr Milburn also appeared to suggest that Mr Burnham’s EU deal, which will allow tens of thousands of young people to move to the UK, could hamper the drive to reduce the number of Neets.
The Government’s youth unemployment tsar said young people from disadvantaged communities in the UK should be “the priority”.
On Friday, the Prime Minister is set to reach an agreement with Brussels allowing EU nationals under 30 to live, work and study in Britain, with young Britons allowed to do the same in the bloc. An estimated 80,000 people would be able to come to the UK for three years under the deal.
Alan Milburn, a former Labour health secretary, called for the Government to introduce a new benefit system for young people Credit: Paul Grover for The Telegraph On BBC Breakfast, the Prime Minister appeared to admit that Rachel Reeves’s increase to employers’ National Insurance had contributed to the worklessness crisis.
Mr Burnham said: “Employment or training came post-pandemic and under the last government, the rate of increase was higher.
“And it was partly because there was a major report then about the support young people needed after the pandemic, by somebody called Sir Kevin Collins, and it was ignored and that was the crucial moment and we saw a bigger rate of increase then.
“Now, I am not saying there hasn’t been an increase following the 2024 general election, but it is not as high.”
Asked directly whether Ms Reeves had made the problem worse, Mr Burnham replied: “Well, we have also put in place policies to support employers who are taking on young people who are long-term unemployed.”
Mr Milburn said he was confident that Labour MPs would support the reforms despite a rebellion against previous attempts to cut £5bn from Britain’s welfare bill.
However, unions rounded on the plans on Tuesday night, arguing that cutting benefits was “needless cruelty”. Some Labour backbenchers also warned that the reforms could end up “punishing” disabled people.
Mr Milburn said that the majority of those aged 16 to 24 should be stopped from claiming the main disability benefits as part of a “complete system reset”.
In addition, he called for lower employer National Insurance contributions for those hiring 21 to 24-year-olds, grants for employers hiring Neets and a defunding of private ADHD clinics, which he said were pushing young people towards a life on benefits.
Mr Burnham said he was uncomfortable with hundreds of thousands of young people not being in employment or training.
He told The Times he would also announce an “ambition” to offer a 45-day work placement for anyone aged 16 to 18 who wanted one.
He told the newspaper the first £500m of extra funding for employment support would come from reprioritising departmental budgets, and that he would like to apply the review’s “philosophy” to help older workers into jobs.
Mr Burnham pledged on Wednesday to guarantee a funded college place for every young person following calls from Mr Milburn to prevent a generation from “doomscrolling in their bedrooms”.
The Prime Minister said the amount of Neets was an “economic catastrophe and a moral failure” as he pledged support for colleges to offer more places.
Mr Milburn told reporters: “We should increase the number of college places ... What we can’t keep doing is what we’re doing at the moment, which is leave a whole generation of young people, sometimes doomscrolling in their bedrooms, out of society, out of participation, with no prospects for the future.”
Lucy Powell, the Education Secretary, has promised to overhaul college funding and reform teaching to address the 150,000 16 to 18-year-old Neets.
Colleges are in line to receive a funding windfall “well ahead of the academic year” to offer more places for the 2027/28 academic year.
The Department for Education will offer new flexibilities on hours of English and maths study for previously disengaged young people returning to learning, as well as allow students to resit exams “when they are ready”.
While Mr Milburn stopped short of calling for Labour’s workers’ rights reforms to be abandoned or reversed, he said he had heard a “powerful argument that too much regulation will deter employers from employing more young people”.
A “very high bar” must be set for introducing fresh red tape, and the Government should introduce a test to ensure new rules do not harm young people’s job prospects, he said.
At an event unveiling his report, Mr Milburn said: “The explicit aim should be to prevent the youth labour market being flooded with more new regulation and to reduce existing regulatory burdens.
“You cannot call youth employment a national priority while making young people harder or more expensive to hire.”
The Employment Rights Act, which received Royal Assent in December last year, grants workers day-one sick pay, gives zero-hours workers a right to guaranteed hours and scraps the cap on unfair dismissal compensation.
Some reforms are already in effect. However, others are out for consultation or are set to kick in from next year. A public consultation on zero-hours contracts closed in the summer and a shorter qualifying period for unfair dismissal rights will take effect from next year.
Allen Simpson, the chief executive of UKHospitality, a lobby group, called for the Government to “immediately reconsider how the Employment Rights Act affects young people”, adding that there was “nothing moral about putting up regulatory barriers to our young people getting jobs”.
Andrew Griffith, the shadow chancellor, said: “Milburn does not shy away from the fact that Angela Rayner’s Unemployment Rights Act is making the youth jobs crisis worse.
“The unpalatable truth is that trade union-funded Labour MPs are preventing the creation of the very jobs that Neets so badly need. Any idea of banning flexible working should be shelved immediately before even more damage is done.”
Robert Jenrick, of Reform, said Labour’s workers’ rights reforms had “acted like an Exocet missile strike on new jobs” and said his party would axe the law if elected.
Pat McFadden, the Work and Pensions Secretary, declined to say whether he agreed that certain elements of the Employment Rights Act should be deferred.
Asked in the Commons by Sir Desmond Swayne, a Tory MP, whether there were any elements he was prepared to review, he said: “We believe that young people should have rights, we believe that they should have pay and we believe they should have opportunities.
“If the idea of the party opposite is to take away those things and think that is the answer to the problem, I’m afraid I disagree.”
Under the reforms proposed by Mr Milburn, jobless adults aged 16 to 24 would no longer be able to claim Personal Independence Payment or the health element of Universal Credit. Instead, they would move to a new “youth allowance” paying the same as the standard rate of Universal Credit.
Unison, Britain’s biggest trade union, and other Labour-affiliated unions condemned the proposals.
Andrea Egan, the general secretary of Unison, said: “However they’re rebranded, these are still welfare cuts. Ministers may no longer be demonising claimants but that’s cold comfort to the young people singled out in this review.
“Many of them are neurodivergent or living with mental health conditions. What they need most is support and treatment.”
Some Labour backbenchers also criticised the proposals.
Emma Lewell, the MP for South Shields, told The Telegraph: “Things are tough in my patch, and I don’t really see how punishing people financially when there are no jobs is the right thing to do.”
She added: “I’ve got constituents who contacted me over the last week and over the weekend who are young and are really scared. So I wanted some assurance for them, but that’s obviously something we’re not going to get today.”
Imran Hussain, another Labour backbencher, said: “I opposed the previous disability benefit cuts and would be concerned by any proposals that could leave young disabled people worse off.”
While Mr Milburn called for an overhaul of benefits, he admitted that his reforms would not save money for a decade.
Mr Milburn said he wanted a £500m “down-payment” next year funded by spending cuts in other departments, with annual spending rising to £5.8bn by 2036.
On Tuesday evening, the Government refused to disclose how much taxpayers would be expected to spend on employment programmes in the next decade.
The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) declined to give a total figure, claiming the investment would be funded by welfare savings and extra tax revenues as more young people found work.
Economists questioned the assumptions underpinning claims that Mr Milburn’s reforms could cut £13.7bn from the welfare bill in the next decade.
The DWP assumes that changes to sickness benefits, including reforms affecting under-25s signed off from work indefinitely, will raise employment in this group by 9pc.
However, detailed analysis by the Office for Budget Responsibility has found that previous employment support programmes have not made a “significant contribution” to getting people off benefits.
Deven Ghelani, the director of Policy in Practice, said: “Employment support alone isn’t a magic bullet. Jobs need to be available – or young people need the ability to get to where the jobs are,” he said.
Speaking to Sky News, Mr Burnham declined to back Mr Milburn’s calls for a targeted National Insurance cut for employers of 21 to 24-year-olds in the retail and hospitality sectors.
He said: “We’re going to look at the whole of the report in the round. I mean, some of the implications of those proposals are for the Budget, and they’ll have to be considered as part of that.
“But we’re not ruling anything out at this point in time. We’ll look at everything in the round.”
A government spokesman said: “We are committed to tackling the one-sided flexibility that can result from zero hours and similar contracts, when workers bear all the financial risk of uncertain hours, shifts and earnings.
“We’re grateful for the many responses we received to our consultation.
“We are taking them into account and working to get the detail right so that the new rights work in the real world, including for young workers and the employers looking to hire them.”
