Appeals court grants tax exemption to soccer player transfers abroad - Valor International
The São Paulo State Court of Appeals (TJSP) has ruled that the brokering of Brazilian athletes to clubs abroad is not subject to the Services Tax (ISS). The decision sets an important judicial precedent for the soccer market and could influence other sectors, such as consulting. It is also notable for being in line with the tax reform. The São Paulo city government has appealed to the higher courts.
The ISS will be replaced by the Goods and Services Tax (IBS). The new levy, which replaces the ISS and the state-level ICMS, will be charged next year at a rate of 0.1% and in full from 2033. Under Constitutional Amendment 132 of 2023, which established the tax reform, the IBS will be levied on the same criterion the TJSP applied: the place of consumption. If consumption takes place abroad, the transaction is treated as an export and is not taxed.
In the case at hand, the TJSP’s 18th Public Law Chamber ruled that ISS does not apply to the services Elenko Sports provided in brokering deals with clubs abroad. The company sued the city of São Paulo after being fined.
The agency brokered the transfers of athletes to soccer clubs including Roma (Italy), Moreirense Futebol Clube (Portugal), GNK Dinamo (Croatia), Bordeaux (France), Daegu Football Club (South Korea), Al-Wehda Club (Saudi Arabia), Sporting Clube de Braga (Portugal), Gaziantep Futbol Kulubu (Turkey), and Gamba Osaka (Japan), among others.
According to lawyers Raphael Caropreso and Filipe Richter, tax partners at Veirano Advogados, who represent the agency in the case, the São Paulo tax authority has been fining athlete brokers on the argument that the service is performed in Brazilian territory. Because case law on the concept of “result” for ISS purposes remains inconsistent, they say, the new ruling is a “watershed” that could reduce litigation in the sector.
“Complementary Law 116 of 2003, which governs the ISS, adopted the destination principle of taxation, but its wording leaves room for a series of disputes,” Richter says. He notes that the Superior Court of Justice (STJ) treated the service as an export in the case of an engineering firm that designed a plant to be built in France (AREsp 587403/RS). “In another case, involving an airline maintaining a foreign aircraft on Brazilian soil, the court ruled that there was no export” (REsp 831124/RJ).
The fees from athlete brokering, which form the ISS tax base, are substantial because the foreign clubs convert the currency and pay the companies in dollars. But if the athlete leaves Brazil to play for teams in other countries, the lawyers argue, it is an export, a transaction that is exempt from taxation by law.
“We take that view because the result, which is the player’s performance, is abroad,” Caropreso says. “We filed an annulment action against eight tax assessments issued against Elenko. Because the Municipal Tax Council [the administrative body] found that it was not an export, we were forced to go to court.”
At the TJSP, the judges of the 18th Public Law Chamber ruled that it is necessary to consider where the useful result is actually enjoyed (consumed), based on the “enjoyment” theory. “The conclusion of the athlete’s employment contract requires steps taken abroad, such as medical exams and signing the agreement, showing unequivocally that the service is not completed in Brazilian territory. In other words, the service is enjoyed abroad because that is where the client receives the actual result (benefit),” Judge Marcelo L. Theodósio wrote in his opinion as rapporteur.
The city initially filed appeals against the ruling at the TJSP itself, but the 18th Chamber unanimously rejected them. The judges found no flaw in the decision and upheld the outcome in Elenko’s favor (civil appeal No. 1013750-53.2024.8.26.0053).
The city’s Attorney General’s Office, however, maintains that collecting the ISS is lawful and consistent with current legislation. In a statement to Valor, it said it has already filed appeals with the STJ and the Supreme Court seeking review of the TJSP decision.
Caropreso argues, however, that the city will not be able to reopen the facts and evidence of the case at the STJ or Supreme Court. “In practice, this significantly narrows the scope of the appeals and strengthens the chances that the favorable decision we obtained at the TJSP will stand,” he says.
Tax lawyer Ricardo Maito of the firm TozziniFreire notes that the debate over service exports varies “case by case.” “The discussion is about the concept of result, under the criterion chosen by Complementary Law 116,” he says. “But in the context of the tax reform, it seems to me we will settle this question. If today we debate this with respect to PIS, Cofins, ISS, and ICMS, we will no longer debate it with respect to IBS and CBS [Contribution on Goods and Services],” he adds.
Under the reform, Maito says, the criterion becomes the place of consumption, which is aligned with the destination principle. “Complementary Law 214, which regulates the tax reform, lists situations in which consumption is presumed to occur outside Brazil, such as services provided on real estate abroad, which will be treated as an export and therefore exempt from IBS and CBS,” the tax lawyer says. “That is fantastic, because it will allow a range of services, such as business brokering and consulting, to be covered by that presumption.”
This article was translated from Valor Econômico using an artificial intelligence tool under the supervision of the Valor International editorial team to ensure accuracy, clarity, and adherence to our editorial standards. Read our Editorial Principles.
