Australia cartel will not survive this Bancroft bombshell - The Telegraph
Pat Cummins and Mitchell Starc were part of Australia’s bowling cartel that denied having any knowledge of Australia’s usage of sandpaper in Cape Town Credit: Getty Images/Gareth Copley Nick Hoult Chief Cricket Correspondent Show biography Nick started covering cricket for his local paper in 1997 and joined the Telegraph in 2006. He is a three-time winner of the Sports Journalists’ Association Cricket Journalist of the Year award and has covered the England team all over the world. He can be contacted on nick.hoult@telegraph.co.uk or @NHoultCricket.
Cameron Bancroft, the sandpaper perpetrator-turned-whistleblower, has released a 4,500-word statement that could break apart the Australian team, including Pat Cummins and the bowling attack that has dominated world cricket.
Telegraph Sport looks at those who could be swallowed up by the fallout.
His fate lies in the hands of Australia’s court of public opinion and the verdict will surely cost him his job. His credibility has been shattered by Bancroft’s surgical filleting of the nonsense that the sandpaper scandal was confined to three men. Cummins brought this on himself with his incendiary press conference that left him with nowhere to go if contradicted by Bancroft in particular.
Pat Cummins’ 68-minute rebuttal of Usman Khawaja’s sandpapergate claims has been thrown into doubt by Cameron Bancroft’s latest tell-all statement Credit: Shutterstock/Robbie Stephenson Bancroft detailed team meetings and chats on the field when it was discussed. “I remember my ball tampering with the sandpaper the evening before being discussed and my role being acknowledged in front of the group,” he said. Even the team press officer knew about sandpaper (and to her great credit she opposed it and spoke up), so for Cummins, who bowled 81 overs in Port Elizabeth and Cape Town, to be unaware will not hold.
The office of Australian captain holds great weight and authority. He was the good-looking, clean-cut eco-warrior and outstanding bowler who fitted the image for Cricket Australia (CA). But now what happens if the team is caught up in another scandal? Cummins has lost the credibility externally and internally: how can his team-mates ever believe that he will have their backs?
What may save him is a lack of alternatives. None of the bowlers can be trusted with the job for obvious reasons. Steve Smith returning full time would be laughable after all this. Travis Head and Alex Carey are the only players sure of their places in the side and have led the team in white-ball cricket. At least they were not there in Cape Town. They are not tainted. It could be one of those two tossing up with Joe Root at Trent Bridge next summer for the start of the Ashes.
It is the nickname for the four great bowlers in Australia: Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon. All are ageing but remain first choices when fit. Three of the four – Cummins is the youngest – were probably looking at next summer’s Ashes as their swansong. Starc has stuck to his guns. He knew nothing, apparently. Hazlewood has stayed silent. Quite why Lyon signed the statement in 2021 hitting back when Bancroft first suggested they were all in on it, is intriguing. As a spinner he would have had nothing to do with reverse swing.
All four members of Australia’s bowling cartel signed a letter in 2021 dismissing Bancroft’s claim that they had been aware of the ball-tampering operation in Cape Town Credit: Getty Images/William West That statement set this all in motion, and was why Cummins went hard at Usman Khawaja. “It was not just the three of us – Steve Smith, David Warner and I – who knew about me using sandpaper on the ball in South Africa. It was the whole team. I recall people in the room agreeing with the proposal,” Bancroft wrote. Starc, Hazlewood and Cummins remain integral to Australia’s attack. Scott Boland is a good reserve but many of the next generation struggle to stay fit. The cartel is close to being shattered.
He has said nothing since Bancroft and Khawaja essentially backed up his story: he knew about sandpapergate but did nothing to stop it, summing up the moral bankruptcy of that team. He was also the captain who oversaw the creation of a win-at-all-costs culture that allowed this to happen, which makes it staggering that Australia have used him as a stand-in for Cummins, such as during the last Ashes. Surely that is over now.
Steve Smith becomes emotional during his press conference after the ball-tampering incident in Cape Town Credit: AP/Brendan Esposito The problem is Cummins is no tactical genius, Smith has all the ideas. Smith may well retire at the end of the Australian summer anyway. He is 37 and not the player he was.
Bancroft was damning about Lehmann’s involvement as head coach. He resigned after seeing Smith and Warner hounded when they arrived back in Australia, but his story that he did not know had largely been accepted. Bancroft blew that open. TV cameras picked up Lehmann reacting to the sandpaper at the time, and it was thought he messaged the 12th man to ask him what was going on. Bancroft said Lehmann shouted over his walkie talkie: “Get the f------ sandpaper off Bangers now.”
Darren Lehmann resigns as Australia head coach days after the sandpapergate furore erupted Credit: Getty Images/Wikus de Wet Lehmann says he has nothing to hide and he is no longer involved with Australia. He is a commentator and coach of Northants in the County Championship. But his legacy will be this, not winning Ashes and World Cups.
He was the Australia bowling coach that Bancroft said told him to do more with sandpaper to get the ball moving in Cape Town. Saker has worked with England on and off for the last 15 years, most recently in Pakistan in October as part of the white-ball coaching staff. That will surely end now.
David Saker (left) was part of Brendon McCullum’s England coaching set-up during the 2025-26 Ashes series in Australia Credit: Getty Images/Gareth Copley Cricket AustraliaIts “truth and reconciliation forum” is dead before it even begins. Bancroft ensured that within hours of its announcement. Officials at CA thought they had put it to bed when Cummins came out fighting. But what he did was drive a wedge between those involved and open the opportunity for Bancroft to play whistleblower. Now it needs to reopen the investigation and accept that new evidence has come forward and its initial probe was a sham.
Ball tampering started before Cape Town and was widely discussed. It is enough to restart the whole thing, look again at its disciplinary procedures and maybe even learn from England. The England and Wales Cricket Board (ECB) has an independent cricket regulator. It gives that arm’s length needed in this type of crisis.
CA also needs to ask why people have stayed silent for so long? It is because they feared board recriminations, a scissoring of their career. It is all about brand protection for boards. But the brand is in tatters now.
He is revelling in this, but as Bancroft pointed out, sandpaper was his idea in the first place and CA was right to ban him from leadership positions. Ball tampering was embedded in that team, it was widely suspected by England in 2017-18 when Bancroft said he was first introduced to it. Because the cameras were on Warner and the heavy strapping on his hands was suspected as the source of changing the ball’s condition, it forced Australia to take risks and use an unfamiliar tactic with sandpaper that they could not conceal as easily.
It was on Warner, Smith and other senior players that they allowed a naive and impressionable Bancroft to jump at his chance to fit in. Warner is to write his own book, although it will not come out in the short term, and will reveal more. This is not over.


