Avinash Ramkistan denied urgent bail bid after 20-year sentence - IOL

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from IOL News (iol.co.za). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
A DURBAN man convicted of threatening an acting high court judge, prosecutors and police officers has failed in his urgent bid to be released on bail pending the outcome of his appeal process last week.

A DURBAN man convicted of threatening an acting high court judge, prosecutors and police officers has failed in his urgent bid to be released on bail pending the outcome of his appeal process last week.

Avinash Ramkistan, 40, of Glen Ashley, brought an urgent application before the Durban High Court seeking bail while pursuing a petition for leave to appeal his conviction and 20-year prison sentence.

The respondent in the matter is the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) in KwaZulu-Natal (KZN). 

However, his application was struck off the roll last Thursday after the court found that it did not meet the requirements of urgency and that he had not exhausted other available avenues, including approaching the lower and trial courts. 

Ramkistan, a former insurance company owner, was arrested in March 2024 and charged with several counts of intimidation, crimen injuria, and contraventions of the National Prosecuting Authority Act and the Cybercrimes Act 19 of 2020.

The charges stemmed from threats he made against an acting high court judge, prosecutors and police officers, among others, through emails, voice recordings and Facebook posts.

During the trial, one of the State witnesses, an acting high court judge testified how she was left feeling insulted, embarrassed and fearful after Ramkistan accused her of being “fake”, took to social media to slander her and made threats to incite violence, after she dismissed two of his court applications. 

He elected to represent himself during the trial and pleaded not guilty. However, in May this year, the Durban Regional Court found him guilty on all counts. He was sentenced to an effective 20 years' imprisonment on July 20.

His sentence included 10 years for 11 counts of intimidation, five years for four counts of crimen injuria, eight years for four counts of contravening the Cybercrimes Act and three years for contravening the NPA Act. Some of the sentences were ordered to run concurrently.

In his bail application's founding affidavit, Ramkistan said he applied for leave to appeal his conviction and sentence on July 22. 

However, on September 2, he was informed that the trial court had refused his application on the basis that there were no reasonable prospects of success.

He subsequently pursued the petition procedure under Section 309C of the Criminal Procedure Act.

Ramkistan said he submitted his petition to the appeals clerk on September 22, addressed to the Judge President of the KwaZulu-Natal Division. He also notified the clerk of the lower court.

He said the appeals clerk confirmed that a petition file had been opened.

However, on October 13, he was informed that the trial record was still with the transcribers and that he would be notified once it was received.

He said the petition was also formally lodged with the high court and allocated a petition number.

 Ramkistan said he sought to be released on bail in the context of the appellate process and relied on legal principles. 

Among the legal principles he cited were S v Crossberg (2027) ZASCA 93, paragraph 14, which stated: “The Supreme Court of Appeal recognised a common-law power to release a would-be appellant on bail pending a petition.”  

Ramkistan further stated in his affidavit that, following his conviction and sentence, he also approached the trial court and sought bail pending the appellate process.

“The trial court declined to grant or entertain bail because leave to appeal had not been granted; the position communicated to me was that bail could be considered only if leave were granted.

“Leave was then refused on the stated basis that there was no reasonable prospects of success. I make this distinction clear: I did seek bail before the trial court, but I was not afforded a determination of that request on its substantive merits in the circumstances described,” he said.

 Ramkistan said that his continued deprivation of liberty was immediate and ongoing. 

“To the extent that delay in processing the petition is not attributable to me, that circumstance increases the prejudice I experience while awaiting determination of the appellate process.” 

Senior State advocate, Krishen Shah, opposed and argued the matter on behalf of the DPP. 

In an answering affidavit, Noxolo Tokwana, the deputy DPP in KZN, said Ramkistan had not made out a case of urgency or found jurisdiction for the court to entertain the matter. 

She said it was trite that Ramkistan was being “governed”  by the Criminal Procedure Act and now sought to redress via civil proceedings, shifting the provisions and mechanics of the Act. 

Tokwana said Ramkistan’s application for leave to appeal was dismissed on the ground that “there was no prospect of success”; consequently, his continued detention remained lawful. 

She said as a consequence of the refusal, he lodged his petition with the lower court clerk.

“Of significance is that the appeal record and petition seemingly have not been lodged with the registrar of the high court as there is no high court case number. It is thus submitted that there is technically no petition pending in the high court other than an expressed intent to do so.” 

Tokwana said that Ramkistan's failure to go back to the court a quo (lower or trial court) seeking leave to appeal pending the petition was not without consequence.

“It is further submitted that the applicant (Ramkistan) makes no submissions relating to his efforts in attempting to revisit the issue of bail pending the petition before the court a quo.” 

Tokwana added that the DPP was not unsympathetic to Ramkistan’s situation given that the right to liberty was constitutionally protected.

“However, his situation is markedly different in that his detention is judicially sanctioned in that bail has been refused prior to conviction and post-conviction.”

Original Source
https://iol.co.za/thepost/news/2026-11-18-avinash-ramkistan-denied-urgent-bail-bid-after-20-year-sentence/
Visit IOL News ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Crime