Bayesian yacht crew not to blame for disaster, investigators rule - The Telegraph
A photo of the superyacht issued by the Marine Accident Investigation Branch Credit: MAIB/Press Association Christopher Jasper Transport industry editor Published 19 November 2026 12:00am GMT The crew of the Bayesian superyacht cannot be blamed for its deadly capsizing off the coast of Sicily, British accident investigators have ruled.
The risk to the vessel in high winds was not made clear in a safety manual, while weather forecasts underestimated the ferocity of an approaching storm, the investigators said.
It came after Sicilian prosecutors blamed βincompetenceβ of crew as the chief factor in the disaster, rather than characteristics inherent to the yachtβs design.
However, the Marine Accident Investigation Branch (MAIB) said on Thursday that crew should not be held responsible because the risk of the Bayesian keeling over because the 236ft mast was not highlighted in safety information provided by the yachtβs manufacturer.
The 473-ton luxury yacht, registered in the UK and measuring 184ft long, was carrying 22 people when it went down half a mile off the north coast of Sicily in August 2024.
Seven people died: Mike Lynch, the tech entrepreneur who founded software giant Autonomy in 1996; his daughter Hannah Lynch, 18, who had secured a place at Oxford University; Recaldo Thomas, the shipβs Antiguan-Canadian chef; Jonathan Bloomer, the Morgan Stanley International bank chairman, and his wife Judy Bloomer, both British; and Chris Morvillo, the Clifford Chance lawyer, and his wife Neda Morvillo.
Mike Lynch had been acquitted of fraud charges relating to the sale of his company to Hewlett-Packard in 2011. The voyage with friends, family and business associates was a celebration of his acquittal in the US case.
In a 120-page report, the MAIB said that while the vesselβs retractable keel had been raised, adding to its vulnerability, that was normal when moored for the night in shallow water.
Rob Loder, the chief inspector of Marine Accidents, said: βOur investigation found that Bayesian had a vulnerability to high winds that was not recognised, because the yacht had never been assessed at anchor with its sails down.
βThe extreme winds that night were also not explicitly forecast, so the crew had no warning of the risk.β
Seas were light when the party retired for the night, the MAIB said. While James Cutfield, the skipper, was aware of the approaching storm, the weather remained benign until just 11 minutes before the yacht was knocked flat on the water.
Even as conditions deteriorated, and unaware of the risks of capsizing, crew were focused on preventing damage to the Bayesian as its anchor was dragged along the seabed, rather than prioritising emergency measures such as closing all hatches and doors.
Had they known to lower the keel this could have been done in two and a half minutes.
The MAIB said the Bayesian was then hit by a downburst of at least 68 knots from a thunderstorm, which tilted it sideways beyond 73 degrees from the vertical β the point beyond which it could never come upright again.
It keeled over flat in just 15 seconds, leading the ocean to pour in, and sank within 18 minutes in more than 160ft of water.
Survivors clambered into a life raft, which they had to launch after none deployed automatically, and were rescued by a nearby yacht that had survived the storm.
The remains of the Bayesian being lifted to the surface in June 2025 Credit: PA Media/Peter Byrne UK investigators were not initially granted access to the vessel by Italian authorities after it was raised from the seabed 10 months after it sank. When finally inspected, the interior had been cleared of debris, furniture and fittings, which were documented.
Neither was the MAIB provided with dive records identifying the precise locations of bodies within the wreck which might have helped identify why other guests failed to escape.
Italian experts are expected to submit a full report in the next few weeks. Prosecutors could then request that crew members be sent for trial.
Three are under investigation, according to the Italian press: Mr Cutfield, Tim Parker Eaton, the British head engineer, and Matthew Griffiths, a British deckhand who was on watch.
Charlotte Golunski, who escaped the sinking with her one year-old daughter, has accused the crew of 18 errors, including failing to sound the alarm or provide a safety briefing for the infant, and is suing for damages.
