BBM’s Supreme Court

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from The Philippine Star (philstar.com). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
President Marcos’ expected choice as the new chief justice has rekindled debates about the state of the Philippine judicial system.

President Marcos’ expected choice as the new chief justice has rekindled debates about the state of the Philippine judicial system.

Rumors that BBM had picked Rodil Zalameda as the next CJ swirled even as he was still being interviewed by the Judicial and Bar Council on Oct. 26. The Palace merely advised the marites crowd to wait for an official announcement.

Because of those rumors, there was early criticism of Zalameda’s possible promotion over five more senior SC justices – and not because of the seniority issue, which the appointing power has the prerogative to ignore.  

The bigger issue against Zalameda, raised notably by former hidden wealth hunter Ruben Carranza, was that he was the author or ponente of the SC First Division ruling this year that overturned the 2018 conviction of BBM’s mother Imelda on seven counts of graft related to the Marcoses’ Swiss bank deposits. By the time the ruling was made public, the period for filing a motion for reconsideration was long over.

The return of the Marcoses’ ill-gotten wealth to the Philippines was part of transitional justice following the people power revolt. What we have today, it seems, is transactional justice.

Other critics dredged up the other significant detail, that Zalameda also penned the landmark SC en banc ruling that junked the petitions seeking to disqualify BBM from the 2022 presidential race because of his conviction for tax evasion from 1982 to 1985. The SC unanimously ruled that the offense did not constitute moral turpitude.

In what was probably his last ponente before his promotion, Zalameda also penned the ruling allowing the nth postponement of the barangay and Sangguniang Kabataan elections by an amazing two years, giving the lucky incumbents a total three-year extension (so far) of their terms.

By 2028 when the BSKE rolls around, we can expect Congress, packed with members whose relatives and supporters are barangay officials, to again pass a law giving BSK officials a 10-year term, with another postponement of the BSKE tacked on.

BBM, a member of one of the fattest, most entrenched political dynasties, will gladly sign the law. And the SC under Zalameda can be expected to uphold such laws, ad infinitum.

Zalameda has not yet earned a reputation as the umbrella bearer of BBM, like CJ Enrique Fernando for Imeldific when she was first lady. But the betting at this point is that the SC under a grateful Zalameda will go along with anything Marcos wants for the remainder of his presidency.

Diplomats who have been in the country long enough have described our legal system as “malleable,” and one of the major hindrances to national development. Apart from snail-paced justice, foreign chambers have long complained about the wanton bending of laws, rules and regulations to suit whichever gang is in power.

Joseph Estrada, at the height of his popularity as vice president and then president, often railed against “hoodlums in robes” and “fix-cals.” Unfortunately, he lost the moral authority for that campaign.

Recently, Ombudsman Jesus Crispin Remulla said the judiciary should undergo “soul-searching” because of its “issues.” Remulla also lamented the grant of bail to former senator Bong Revilla by the Sandiganbayan’s Third Division, grousing, “mukhang natrabaho” – Pinoy slang for case fixing.

The Supreme Court found it necessary to respond, asking Remulla for specifics and urging him to file a complaint.

Perhaps Remulla should take on the challenge. The SC has the sole authority to investigate such cases and impose disciplinary sanctions on erring members of the judiciary, but the ombudsman can file complaints.

Presumably, adjudication is faster because such cases no longer have to go through the judicial mill before final judgment by the SC.

Over the years the SC has dismissed judges and justices for corruption. Several trial court judges have been sent to prison, but not higher court justices.

Gregory Ong was dismissed as Sandiganbayan associate justice by the SC in 2014 for dishonesty, gross misconduct and impropriety related to the pork barrel scam. He was barred from public office and lost his retirement benefits, but he was not sent to prison.

A case will still have to be put together, however, for the SC’s consideration. If ill-gotten or unexplained wealth is tough to prove for public officials under the jurisdiction of the ombudsman, it must be even more complicated when members of the judiciary are the ones suspected of receiving bribes or “gifts” a million times larger than what is allowed by law. The SC, not the ombudsman, is the repository of the official asset declarations of judges and justices.

Presidents have the prerogative to pick the CJ, and they can be expected to choose someone they trust. Presidents who expect to face lawsuits upon retirement also need insurance against conviction.

Gloria Macapagal Arroyo scraped up an excuse to appoint Renato Corona as chief justice, just weeks before her term ended.

Even after Corona was ousted following conviction in an impeachment trial and Noynoy Aquino had installed Ma. Lourdes Sereno as CJ, GMA had some insurance against conviction before any court. In January 2010 in the twilight of her presidency, she signed Republic Act 9946, giving judges and justices hefty retirement pensions, pegged at current salary rates, like those in the uniformed services.

The judiciary is supposed to be an independent and co-equal branch of government, but the executive can influence that independence through the exercise of the president’s appointing power.

That appointing power can’t be withdrawn. But legal minds should find ways of reducing presidential discretion and political influence in appointments and promotions in the judiciary. This has been done to a certain extent in the military.

It should also be possible to prohibit members of the Supreme Court, upon retirement, from accepting an appointment from the incumbent president to another post, including sinecures in government corporations. This will enhance the impartiality of SC members.

Also, the system of accountability and punishment of hoodlums in robes must be improved. Dismissal from the service is not enough; corrupt members of the judiciary must also be sent to prison and their ill-gotten assets seized.

Whether such reforms are possible with Zalameda as SC chief remains to be seen.

It’s just his first week as CJ. He has time to dispel perceptions that this won’t be the Zalameda Supreme Court, but the Marcos Supreme Court.   

abtestabtest BBM much like olds: Imeldific, fascistic By GOTCHA | By Jarius Bondoc | 18 hours ago Is President Bongbong Marcos turning out to be like his parents: Imeldific and fascistic? Or Filipinos just don’t change? Opinion Tax deadline for BBM By SKETCHES | By Ana Marie Pamintuan | 18 hours ago Tax evasion didn’t stop Ferdinand Marcos Jr. from running for president, and winning the post by the largest margin ever (thanks to technology, according to critics). Opinion On ‘disdain’ and decorum By QWERTYMAN | By Jose Dalisay | 4 days ago For over 30 years now, I’ve been teaching a course in UP – Creative Writing 198, Special Topics: Professional Writing – which I myself designed to give undergraduates a foretaste of what it’s... Opinion Why are our kids vacationing next door? A mother’s plea to fix Philippine tourism By ROSES AND THORNS | By Pia Roces Morato | 18 hours ago Ask any travel creator in Southeast Asia about the Philippines, and the praise is uniform: world-class beaches, unmatched biodiversity, and the warmest people on the planet. Yet when those same creators plan their... Opinion Clock is ticking By COMMONSENSE | By Marichu A. Villanueva | 18 hours ago Two maverick lawmakers in the 20th Congress have joined forces in continuing their push to ensure the next budget bill they will pass into law must be compliant with the country’s Constitution. Opinion Latest More in Opinion EDITORIAL - Where’s the red notice for Co? Irresistible EDITORIAL - Ready for free trade? Growth coalition abtest Inside Semirara Island: Floods and a future in peril By EYES WIDE OPEN | By Iris Gonzales | 1 day ago I braved a one-and-a-half-hour flight aboard a seven-seater Cessna to reach Semirara Island in Antique. Opinion Pope Leo XIV talks AI By BREAKTHROUGH | By Elfren S. Cruz | 1 day ago Just five or six decades ago, the topic of artificial intelligence was merely the offshoot of science fiction. Science fiction movies have adopted AI in several movies and most of the time, portrayed as a threat... Opinion The Schuman Security and Defense Forum 2026 By DIPLOMATIC POUCH | By Massimo Santoro | 1 day ago In today’s interconnected world, mutually beneficial and reliable peace, security and defense partnerships are more needed than ever. Opinion BBM’s three ASEAN successes By VIRTUAL REALITY | By Tony Lopez | 1 day ago Donald J. Trump took an 18-hour grueling flight to Manila in a two-country swing of Asia designed to project that the United States is a Pacific power with arms, trade deals, loans and investments to dish out to... Opinion EDITORIAL - ‘Confiscatory’ 2 days ago If the Marcos administration is trying to attract investments, it may want to study the planned auction of the country’s largest coal mine on Semirara Island in Antique, and the impact of new rules on business... Opinion Recommended Palace, House deny VP camp’s ‘no-el’ scenario November 20, 2026 - 12:00am Malacañang yesterday likened Vice President Sara Duterte to famous storyteller Lola Basyang after her camp claimed that the House of Representatives, a chamber dominated by allies of President Marcos, is...r OpinionHOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Persecution? VP defense shows Corona trial videos November 20, 2026 - 12:00am  The defense panel tried to raise the issue of political persecution against Vice President Sara Duterte as her Senate impeachment trial resumed yesterday. OpinionSARA DUTERTE Trial by fire: Senate bureau apologizes for video glitch November 20, 2026 - 12:00am A glitch in the livestream literally turned the Senate impeachment court proceedings into a trial by fire. OpinionLIVESTREAM VP’s ex-staff never held captive – lawyer November 20, 2026 - 12:00am A lawyer representing the businessman who employed Vice President Sara Duterte’s former household staff maintained that they were neither held captive nor forced to sign affidavits intended to malign Dute...r OpinionSARA DUTERTE BBM much like olds: Imeldific, fascistic November 20, 2026 - 12:00am Is President Bongbong Marcos turning out to be like his parents: Imeldific and fascistic? Or Filipinos just don’t change? OpinionBONGBONG MARCOS next Recommended Palace, House deny VP camp’s ‘no-el’ scenario Malacañang yesterday likened Vice President Sara Duterte to famous storyteller Lola Basyang after her camp claimed that the House of Representatives, a chamber dominated by allies of President Marcos, is hatching a no-election (no-el) scenario in 2028. 18 hours ago HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Persecution? VP defense shows Corona trial videos  The defense panel tried to raise the issue of political persecution against Vice President Sara Duterte as her Senate impeachment trial resumed yesterday. 18 hours ago SARA DUTERTE Trial by fire: Senate bureau apologizes for video glitch A glitch in the livestream literally turned the Senate impeachment court proceedings into a trial by fire. 18 hours ago LIVESTREAM VP’s ex-staff never held captive – lawyer A lawyer representing the businessman who employed Vice President Sara Duterte’s former household staff maintained that they were neither held captive nor forced to sign affidavits intended to malign Duterte. 18 hours ago SARA DUTERTE BBM much like olds: Imeldific, fascistic Is President Bongbong Marcos turning out to be like his parents: Imeldific and fascistic? Or Filipinos just don’t change? 18 hours ago BONGBONG MARCOS OK Are you sure you want to log out? Yes No X Login Philstar.com is one of the most vibrant, opinionated, discerning communities of readers on cyberspace. With your meaningful insights, help shape the stories that can shape the country. Sign up now!

Original Source
https://qa.philstar.com/opinion/2026/11/09/2568810/bbms-supreme-court
Visit The Philippine Star ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Politics