Beneath the bravado, the Iranian regime is crumbling. The West must keep up the pressure - The Telegraph
Since 1979, the Middle East has been dominated by a revolutionary Iran Credit: AP/Vahid Salemi Simon Mayall Published 16 November 2026 2:09pm GMT Last weekend, the Kingdom of Bahrain once again played host to the International Institute for Strategic Studies’ “Manama Dialogue”, a leading regional security conference. This took place against the background of the Israeli general election, the continuing focus on Gaza, and the US midterms, which may prove to be an inflection point in the on-off conflict between America and Iran.
The subjects discussed in Bahrain included the Houthi threat to Saudi Arabia, new security arrangements in the region, means of countering the threat from ballistic missiles and drones, Hezbollah in Lebanon and the prospects for the new government in Syria, and, of course, the situation in the Strait of Hormuz. The global economic consequences of the disruption in that maritime choke-point are still unfolding.
Until Dr Anwar Gargash, the former UAE minister of state for foreign affairs, spoke towards the end of the event, Iran was only rarely mentioned by name. However, despite this coyness it was patently clear that most of the issues being discussed could be traced back to Iran.
The use of historical analogies can be useful, provided they are not taken too far. One might say that as the first 50 years of 20th century European history were dominated by the need to deal with an aggressive and aggrieved militaristic Germany, then the last half century in the Middle East, since 1979, has been dominated by a similarly aggressive, aggrieved and revolutionary Iran.
Dr Anwar Gargash, diplomatic adviser to the UAE president, was one of few to name Iran at the conference Credit: AFP/Fadel Senna Both countries are large political entities, with significant populations, occupying a dominant geographical position within a regional land mass. Both adopted aggressive and expansionist policies rooted in radical ideologies, and based on assumptions of civilisational and racial superiority. Both weaponised national or religious communities within neighbouring states, be it Germans in Polish Danzig or the Czech Sudetenland, or the Shia in Lebanon, Iraq and Yemen. Both conducted a foreign policy based on bluster, deceit, overt threats and unrealistic demands.
The issue of Germany ended among the ruins of the Reichstag and the division of the country until the fall of the Berlin Wall. The fate of Revolutionary Iran remains to be seen. Like Germany and Imperial Japan, Iran has proved to be remarkably resilient in the face of long-standing sanctions, a degree of diplomatic isolation, and military attacks.
With Russian and Chinese support, Iran has exercised a significant degree of control over the Strait of Hormuz, with economic disruption that is having a significant impact on domestic politics in the US and Western Europe. In addition, Iran has made its Arab Gulf neighbours pay a high economic price for hosting US military facilities.
Nevertheless, beneath the bravado, the Iranian Revolutionary regime has been severely weakened. It is possible, at this stage, that a change of Iranian policy and approach could be achieved. If that were to happen, over time it would be transformative for the whole region.
In some ways Iran has already experienced a degree of regime change. Although the messaging remains that of the Islamic Revolution, the ayatollahs have ceded power and influence to the hardliners of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC). They, in turn, have had to dial down some of the cultural restrictions on the Iranian people while drawing inspiration from Iran’s great pre-Islamic history to enhance societal solidarity. The nuclear programme has been severely degraded, as have the ballistic missile and drone programmes, although small numbers of both can continue to cause disproportionate damage and disruption.
Authority is now concentrated inside the IRGC Credit: NurPhoto/Morteza Nikoubazl The Iranian conventional forces are equally degraded. Of even greater significance is the collapse of the economy, where the rial has lost half its purchasing power against the dollar, and inflation is near 90 per cent. The effect of this is dire for the average Iranian, although the Iranian political and military leadership is no doubt protected. The weakened currency makes it harder for the regime to pay the IRGC and the Basij militia, and to support its parasitical proxies across the region.
Lastly, the societal, economic and cultural grievances that led to widespread unrest across Iran last January have not gone away, despite the violence of its suppression. This is the right time to sustain pressure on the regime, in a manner that offers Iran a bright future alongside its Arab and Turkish neighbours as an alternative to economic and political collapse.
At the Manama Dialogue, it was clear that the Gulf states, and others, feared the prospect of renewed military action against Iran and the consequences of Iranian retaliation. However, it was clear that they also feared the prospect of more decades of Iranian obduracy and interference, with its continued malign effect on the security, stability and prosperity of the whole region.
It was in this context that everyone present was nursing hopes for the various diplomatic missions going to and from Tehran, which were offering both incentives and warnings, backed by the credible threat of renewed large-scale hostilities. As with Germany and Japan in the last century, the transformation of Iran into a responsible state actor would be a huge boon to all the Middle East, and to the people of Iran as well.
Only time will tell whether this is a reasonable proposition, or whether the region is doomed to find all its economic and security plans having to be predicated on an assumption of Iranian hostility and confrontation.
