Brazil faces R$379bn rise in pension costs without reform - Valor International
Without another pension reform, annual spending on benefits under Brazil’s General Social Security Regime (RGPS) is projected to rise from R$1.08 trillion in 2026 (8.3% of GDP) to R$1.46 trillion in 2036 (8.5% of GDP), adjusted for inflation, federal government projections show. The R$379 billion increase is likely to further squeeze public investment and limit the expansion of social programs and public policies.
The additional expenditure is more than twice the R$159.5 billion allocated to the Bolsa Família cash-transfer program in the 2026 budget. It is also more than 30 times the R$11.5 billion earmarked this year for Pé-de-Meia, a financial incentive program for students, and more than five times the federal government’s R$70 billion contribution to Fundeb, Brazil’s basic education funding program.
The situation is even more alarming when retirement and survivor benefits for federal civil servants and military personnel are taken into account, as these expenditures have also been trending upward. However, they were excluded from the calculation. This article is part of the “False Dilemma” series, which explores how to reconcile fiscal stability with efforts to reduce inequality.
Following the reelection of President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, and with his economic team under pressure to demonstrate fiscal commitment, pension experts are calling for further changes to eligibility rules across the general, civil service, and military pension systems. To ensure long-term sustainability amid an aging population, they also advocate a gradual shift toward a funded model that builds reserves to cover future benefits. However, they do not expect the current administration to undertake structural reform.
Containing pension expenditure growth is considered essential to freeing up resources for investment, a key driver of medium- and long-term economic growth, particularly given Brazil’s already high tax burden of 34% of GDP.
“We have substantially increased pension spending over time and offset that by raising taxes. For 40 years, this expenditure has been growing much faster than GDP. That is unsustainable,” said Rogério Nagamine Costanzi, a researcher at the Institute for Applied Economic Research (Ipea) and a pension expert.
Slower expenditure growth would also ease market concerns about the sustainability of public finances, helping strengthen the real, lift stock prices, and bring down interest rates. Economists also favor reducing tax expenditures and reviewing social programs.
National Treasury data show that between 2014 and 2025, federal public investment plunged from R$150 billion to R$87 billion, while the RGPS deficit widened from R$109 billion to R$332 billion, in August 2026 prices. Although the data capture both trends over the period, they do not establish how much of the decline in investment can be attributed to the growing pension deficit.
Leonardo Rolim, a consultant to the Lower House and former social security secretary, said investment is among the first areas to face budget constraints because the government can more easily postpone projects. “That is what has been happening for quite some time.” If pension spending continues to put pressure on the budget, he added, there will also be less room for social policies.
“The lack of comprehensive reform of Brazil’s pension system affects economic growth not only because it limits public investment but also because fiscal imbalances drive up interest rates and discourage private investment,” said Bernardo Schettini, an economist and legislative consultant to the Federal Senate.
For Schettini, reform is also about ensuring the system can pay benefits to younger workers. Those who have yet to meet retirement eligibility requirements have an expectation of future entitlement.
“In other words, maintaining the current model threatens the very existence of the public pension system, which must be restructured to ensure protection for younger workers and future generations,” he said.
If current rules remain unchanged, annual RGPS benefit expenditure could reach 9% of GDP by 2041, under projections included in the 2027 Budget Guidelines Bill (PLDO). In that scenario, spending would be R$586 billion higher than in 2026, after adjusting for inflation.
In their own simulations, pension experts Paulo Tafner, Bernardo Schettini, Leonardo Rolim, Rogério Nagamine, and Sergio Guimarães estimate that their proposed reform would reduce annual RGPS expenditure by R$36.1 billion in 2030, R$112.3 billion in 2035, and R$193.3 billion in 2040, compared with a no-reform scenario and measured in 2025 prices.
By 2040, spending would stand at 6.8% of GDP under the proposed reform, compared with 8% in the authors’ no-reform scenario. The study uses a narrower expenditure base than the government’s projections, covering only pension benefits, while official calculations also include items such as financial compensation between pension systems.
The proposal would gradually raise the minimum retirement age to 67, establishing uniform requirements for men and women and for urban and rural workers. The current minimum age is 62 for women and 65 for men. The retirement age would subsequently rise in line with life expectancy, and special retirement provisions would also be reviewed.
For military personnel, the proposal establishes a minimum age of 55 for transfer to the reserve. Current rules require 35 years of service but impose no minimum age.
Beyond changes to eligibility requirements, the economists propose a hybrid pension system. One component would retain the pay-as-you-go model, in which contributions from active workers finance current benefits, while another would operate on a funded basis, accumulating reserves to cover future payments. The plan also provides for a defined-contribution model, under which benefits depend on accumulated contributions.
“Simply changing the system’s parameters is not enough. We need to partially overhaul the funding model and introduce a funded component. That would make it possible to build the resources needed to pay future pension benefits,” Rolim said.
He explained that the funded component would need to be introduced gradually to preserve the resources used to finance current retirement benefits. However, delaying the transition would leave less time to accumulate reserves as the population ages.
“The longer we wait to implement reform, the higher the transition cost,” he said.
Tafner, CEO of the Institute for Mobility and Social Development (Imds), considers the introduction of a funded pension system the most important step Brazil could take to ensure long-term sustainability, given its aging population, declining birth rate, and recent labor market changes.
“Demographics are working against the pay-as-you-go system. This model works well when the population is growing,” he said. Under a pay-as-you-go system, active workers finance the benefits of retirees.
“We have put forward a structural reform proposal, but nothing will be done along these lines. Workers’ Party [PT] governments have always been radically opposed to reforms. They might make a few piecemeal changes,” Tafner said.
The economist said the government could still seek to curb the granting of benefits through the courts, including the Continuous Cash Benefit (BPC), a welfare program for low-income elderly people and people with disabilities, and rural retirement benefits.
He noted that one-third of BPC claims and 20% of rural retirement benefits are granted through court rulings. Other ways to contain expenditure would include revising eligibility rules for the wage bonus program to better target beneficiaries and reducing tax expenditures.
Nagamine agrees that funded pension systems are better suited to a gradually aging population. He also advocates discussing a notional defined-contribution system, which combines features of pay-as-you-go financing with the individual account structure characteristic of funded pension schemes.
Nagamine believes expenditure reductions also require changes to military retirement provisions. He advocates setting a minimum age of 55 for transfer to the reserve, gradually increasing it to at least 60.
He also argues that pension contributions should be introduced for reservists and retired military personnel. The average age at which military personnel leave active service is currently 48.9.
The 2027 draft budget (PLOA) projects a military pension deficit of R$56.6 billion, equivalent to 0.4% of GDP.
This article was translated from Valor Econômico using an artificial intelligence tool under the supervision of the Valor International editorial team to ensure accuracy, clarity, and adherence to our editorial standards. Read our Editorial Principles.
