Bruce Arthur: Canada’s sports summit launched a national rebuild — but not everyone’s sure where they fit - Toronto Star
The country's sports system is pleased with the $755 million in funding increases over five years. But there is real anxiety, too.
Bruce Arthur is a columnist for the Star. Follow him on Twitter: @bruce_arthur.
OTTAWA—For as long as most people can remember, this has been Canada’s golden age of sport. We became a top-five medal winner at Winter Olympics at Nagano in 1998, and didn’t surrender that status until Milan 2026. Canada has been a top-15 Summer Games medallist in all but two Olympics — Sydney and Athens — since 1992. And the Vancouver Olympics in 2010 were, all in all, a generation-defining success.
Medals weren’t the only measure, whatever we told ourselves, and as the Future of Sport In Canada report earlier this year detailed, it eroded out from under our feet. But for Canadian sport, these have been the good times. And on Monday and Tuesday this week hundreds of Canada’s amateur sports leaders gathered for a sports summit in Ottawa and asked themselves, what’s next?
“It’s going to be a sensitive discussion, and not a simple one,” said Eric Myles, the chief sport officer of the Canadian Olympic Committee.
“It is exciting, because I think we can reimagine it,” said Suzanne Paulins, CEO of Swimming Canada.
“I really hope — I really hope — we shake s - - t up,” said Michael Bartlett, CEO of Canada Basketball.
Canada skip Cheryl Bernard waves to the crowd with her silver medal at the Vancouver 2010 Olympics.
It’s important to say this: the sports system is pleased. Core funding to national sports organizations had been frozen for 20 years, and because elite performance was the road to funding, safe sport and proper governance suffered. The Milan Olympics were the effective end of Canada’s generation of athletes who watched Vancouver 2010 as children, and were inspired. Canada relied on the echoes of 2010 for a long, long time.
So the $755 million in funding increases over five years, plus $118 million per year, plus over a billion in infrastructure money, are welcome. There is now a system-wide focus on participation and affordability, as difficult as that will be. Prime Minister Mark Carney and secretary of sport Adam van Koeverden have created a new era in Canadian sport, and nobody in the Canadian sports community says that is a bad thing.
But there is real anxiety, too. At the summit several smaller national sports organizations expressed nervousness about where they fit in the Canadian sports landscape. If this era of sport is about nation building, and a focus on increasing participation, what does that mean?
Adam van Koeverden speaks at the Canada Strong Through Sport: The Playground to Podium summit in Ottawa last week.
In addition to participation increases, the government is encouraging diversified funding sources — charity, corporate, you name it — but is also encouraging targeted amalgamation in some NSOs to save on shared services. But amalgamation means fewer CEOs and fewer jobs, and it’s far from clear it will actually save money or improve performance in any particular area. One theory of the amalgamation push is that with fewer but bigger NSOs, perhaps Canada can attract more capable executives and board members to handle a sports system that is so much more complex now: philanthropy, corporate fundraising, safe sport, diversity, inclusion, participation, and of course, performance. One NSO head who asked to remain nameless in order to speak more freely said increased funding is welcome, but it’s still not enough for many sports to both compete and accomplish everything required to ensure higher government funding.
But in the absence of amalgamation, the gap between big federations and small ones can be a chasm as they compete for money, athletes and prominence. With funding tied to participation increases, not every sport will remain a winner going forward, necessarily.
“I think there’s a self-preservation element, that change is scary,” said Bartlett. “We just came from a session where every sport in the room was talking about how to get more corporate funding, and my answer was some of you shouldn’t try. (But) you should probably focus on individual philanthropy.”
“I think the group of NSO CEOs, we are really well connected and really aligned in our thinking,” said Paulins. “And not everybody is at the same place, and that’s OK.”
Jesse Lumsden hugs Alexander Kopacz after Canada tied for gold in the two-man bobsleigh at the 2018 Pyeongchang Winter Olympics.
“It’s OK to say winning matters, and it matters a lot,” said Jesse Lumsden, the vice-president of Bobsleigh Canada Skeleton and former CFL and NFL running back. “If we are not building out a plan to win when it matters in Bobsleigh Canada Skeleton right now, it’s not a matter of if, but when you either get cut or fired from sport, because it’s a meritocracy.
“(So) what is a successful return on investment based off of this supplemental funding, these hundreds of millions of dollars going into the sports system? And it’s going to be different for everybody. Because we will never have the size of membership that Soccer Canada has, and that’s OK.
“But where do we fit in? And there are others like us as well.”
In theory, the relationship between boosting participation (and infrastructure) and better elite performance is simple: more kids playing sports in more places means more candidates to represent Canada one day on the international stage. The ambition of this sports era is truly found there: more participation, cheaper sports. It’s a great thing to try.
But the commercialization of youth sports is a behemoth, and van Koeverden’s office has not given concrete targets on participation. So whether the real impact is nibbling around the edges versus significant change, there aren’t currently targets that tell you which is which.
At the elite performance end, meanwhile, there remain questions about whether higher participation constitutes a strategy on its own, and how well NSOs are equipped to boost it. And medals remain a defining measuring stick, too. So without hard participation targets, with funding that evolves year by year, will Sport Canada pick winners and losers in a nation-building framework? How can it not?
“I kind of felt like we missed an opportunity to do the hard things, which is having a strategy and making decisions and not supporting everything and everybody,” said Dominick Gauthier, the co-founder and COO of B210, which has served as a fundraiser and elite sport engine for over two decades. “You make criteria, you look at strategies for high performance.
“We’re not supporting everybody. We just can’t. We’ll concentrate. We’ll support the sport that might not generate medals, but we know will contribute to physical literacy and people being more active. It’s going to look good because they’ll throw millions at making this and that accessible. Will it convert? I have my doubts on it.”
The $2.5 billion in funding over nine years is a moonshot, Bruce Arthur writes, and creates a new reality in Canadian sports.


