City of Joburg ordered to scrap nearly R215,000 water bill after court finds debt had lapsed - IOL

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from IOL News (iol.co.za). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
Joburg ordered to scrap R214,916 water bill after court finds debt had lapsed.

Joburg ordered to scrap R214,916 water bill after court finds debt had lapsed.

The South Gauteng High Court has ordered the City of Johannesburg to scrap a R214,916.48 water bill against a local property company, ruling that the municipality waited too long to legally pursue the debt and ordering it to pay punitive legal costs.

In a judgment delivered on 17 November 2026, Acting Judge S van Aswegen dismissed the City’s counter application against Skyprops 54 (Pty) Ltd, finding that water consumption charges dating from March 2017 to September 2019 had lapsed.

The court directed the municipality to immediately reverse the nearly R215,000 debit, along with any related ancillary charge from Skyprops’ municipal account.

The legal dispute stemmed from the City’s persistent efforts to hold Skyprops liable for water charges linked to a municipal account registered to a previous owner, Proudfoot Property Investment (Pty) Ltd.

Skyprops purchased the Prolecon property in December 2006 from an intermediary entity, Chelete Investments, and opened its own municipal account in June 2007. While Skyprops diligently paid all bills on its own account, the City continued billing water consumption to the old Proudfoot account.

Following an October 2021 court order instructing the City to investigate and reconcile the two accounts within 90 days, the municipality only responded in March 2022. It demanded R214,916.48 based on an estimated daily average consumption of 5.3 kilolitres for the 2017–2019 period.

In September 2022, the City unilaterally debited the amount onto Skyprops' account and later launched a formal counter application to recover the money in April 2023.

Under South Africa's Prescription Act, ordinary debts, including municipal water and electricity charges, lapse after three years from the date they become due.

Acting Judge Van Aswegen emphasised that a municipality cannot delay the start of this three-year clock simply by failing to issue timely invoices and later presenting a backdated bill.

Because the City was the water-service provider, it was deemed to have known about the consumption as it occurred. Even under the City’s own timeline, the latest charges prescribed by October or November 2022, making its April 2023 court claim five to six months too late.

During the May 2026 hearing, the City attempted to argue that Skyprops had failed to properly plead prescription as a defence. However, the court rejected this contention, noting that Skyprops had raised prescription across at least four separate affidavits and in its amended notice of motion. Furthermore, the judge pointed out that the City itself had invoked the Prescription Act in its own court papers.

The court also dismissed the City’s claim that a R84,032.87 payment made by Skyprops in March 2020 interrupted prescription by acting as a tacit acknowledgment of debt. Acting Judge Van Aswegen ruled that paying undisputed, current charges on one's own account does not constitute an acknowledgment of liability for a separate, disputed debt billed under another entity's name.

While the court declined to grant Skyprops a broad interdict against unspecified future prescribed claims, noting that prescription can only be applied to specific, identifiable debts, it firmly declared that Skyprops is not liable for the 2017–2019 Proudfoot account charges.

Expressing frustration at the municipality's conduct, Acting Judge Van Aswegen ordered the City to pay the legal costs of both the counter application and Part B of the main application on a punitive attorney-and-client scale.

The judge noted that the City knew, or ought to have known, that the debt had prescribed, yet persisted with its claim instead of meaningfully engaging with Skyprops to reconcile the accounts as previously ordered by the court.

Original Source
https://iol.co.za/news/crime-and-courts/2026-11-20-city-of-joburg-ordered-to-scrap-nearly-r215000-water-bill-after-court-finds-debt-had-lapsed/
Visit IOL News ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Technology