Conflicting court orders: A threat to Nigeria’s democracy - The Guardian Nigeria News
The warning by the Chief Justice of Nigeria (CJN), Justice Kudirat Kekere-Ekun, against the growing abuse of judicial processes ahead of the 2027 general elections is timely. It deserves the support of all well-meaning Nigerians. Speaking at the 2026 Roundtable for Heads of Courts, organised by the National Judicial Institute (NJI) in Abuja, the CJN identified forum shopping, concealment of related proceedings, and attempts to obtain conflicting orders from courts of coordinate jurisdiction as dangerous practices that can compromise justice and undermine the integrity of the judiciary.
The CJN particularly cautioned judges against allowing urgent applications and ex parte orders to compromise justice or become instruments for securing improper advantages in politically sensitive disputes.
The CJN’s warning could not have come at a more auspicious time, especially as Nigeria inches towards another election year amid a deepening crisis of confidence in the administration of justice. Justice Kekere-Ekun’s concern stems from several reports of conflicting court orders, embarrassing judicial controversies, and legal contradictions. From the Federal High Court to State High Courts, and among courts of coordinate jurisdiction, the country has witnessed an avalanche of judicial pronouncements that sometimes pull in opposite directions. This disturbing development is not merely an embarrassment to the legal profession; it is a grave threat to the rule of law and public confidence in the administration of justice.
The controversies surrounding the Kano Emirship crisis, the Rivers State political disputes and the Peoples Democratic Party’s leadership and national convention crises are particularly instructive. In these disputes, different courts issued orders that appeared to contradict, overlap with or undermine one another. In the PDP convention controversy, for instance, orders emanating from the Federal High Court in Abuja and the Oyo State High Court created considerable uncertainty over whether the party could proceed with its national convention.
Similarly, the Kano Emirship crisis exposed the dangers of competing judicial interventions in a politically sensitive traditional institution. The Rivers State political crisis also demonstrated how rival political factions could approach different courts and brandish competing judicial orders to justify their respective positions.
The spectacle is increasingly becoming disgraceful, particularly for lawyers who canvass such reliefs, knowing fully that they constitute abuse of process. It gives the impression that litigants can shop around for sympathetic judges until they obtain an order that serves their political or personal interests. The danger is that the court, which should be the sanctuary of justice, begins to look like a marketplace where judicial orders are available to the highest bidder or the most influential litigant. While lawyers are often to blame for this issue, especially when they conceal relevant facts from the courts, the judiciary must also confront its internal weaknesses. No institution can preserve its independence and integrity if its members become willing instruments of its own destruction.
The increasing abuse of ex parte and interim injunctions is particularly disturbing. These remedies are exceptional judicial interventions, designed to preserve the subject matter of litigation and prevent irreparable harm in circumstances where giving prior notice may defeat the purpose of the application. They are not weapons for ambushing political opponents, frustrating public institutions or securing an advantage before the opposing party has an opportunity to be heard. Yet, in recent times, Nigerians have witnessed a disturbing succession of ex parte orders and counter-orders in politically charged disputes. Some of these orders have created confusion, provoked public controversy and exposed the judiciary to avoidable ridicule. The question Nigerians are entitled to ask is: how did the judicial process descend to this level?
Certainly, the problem is not that different courts sometimes reach different conclusions. Judicial independence permits judges to form different opinions on questions of law. The real problem arises when courts of coordinate jurisdiction issue contradictory orders in proceedings involving substantially the same parties, subject matter and issues. It is equally troubling when litigants deliberately conceal pending proceedings or approach multiple courts in search of favourable injunctions. Such conduct constitutes a grave abuse of judicial process and must attract appropriate consequences.
Under the 1999 Constitution, as amended, the Federal High Court and State High Courts have distinct and constitutionally defined jurisdictions. Section 251 provides for the jurisdiction of the Federal High Court, while Section 272 principally governs the jurisdiction of State High Courts. These constitutional boundaries must be respected. No court should permit itself to become an instrument for circumventing existing judicial proceedings or undermining the authority of another court of competent jurisdiction. Equally, litigants and their lawyers must understand that the proper response to an unfavourable judicial decision is to pursue the appropriate appellate remedy, not to embark on a shopping expedition for a more convenient court.
The Nigerian Bar Association (NBA) has, on several occasions, warned judges, heads of courts and legal practitioners against conduct capable of compromising the administration of justice and bringing the legal profession into disrepute. The Association has rightly expressed concern that the damage caused by the indiscriminate issuance of conflicting orders could take the profession a long time to repair. This concern is real. The legal profession cannot afford to remain indifferent while public confidence in the courts erodes. Lawyers who facilitate forum shopping, conceal material proceedings or procure questionable injunctions constitute much of the problem, as do judges who grant such orders without exercising the requisite judicial restraint.
Therefore, the National Judicial Council (NJC) must rise to the occasion. It should investigate credible complaints of judicial misconduct arising from the reckless issuance of conflicting orders and impose appropriate disciplinary sanctions where misconduct is established.
Heads of courts must provide firm administrative leadership, strengthen mechanisms for identifying related proceedings and ensure that applications involving substantially similar disputes are scrutinised with the seriousness they deserve. Judges should insist on full and frank disclosure of material facts and pending proceedings before granting urgent reliefs. The judiciary must demonstrate that judicial independence is not a licence for judicial recklessness.
More importantly, as the 2027 general elections approach, judges must resist political pressure, external interference and personal considerations. Election-related disputes are often emotionally charged and attract enormous public attention. But political sensitivity, public sentiment or the urgency with which an application is presented must never displace the Constitution, the Electoral Act or the applicable rules of court. The CJN is therefore right to remind heads of courts of their responsibility to ensure that election-related cases are handled competently, expeditiously and impartially. The judiciary must not become an instrument in the hands of desperate politicians seeking to circumvent the democratic will of the people.
The judiciary is not just another arm of government. It is the ultimate safeguard of constitutional democracy and the institution to which citizens turn when their rights are violated and other avenues of redress have failed. It interprets the Constitution, protects fundamental rights and holds the other arms of government accountable. Justice is the vital thread that binds society together. Without it, the social contract becomes meaningless, democratic institutions lose their legitimacy and the door is opened to arbitrariness and anarchy.
Democracy cannot flourish where judicial pronouncements generate confusion rather than certainty, or where the authority of one court is casually undermined by another. The authority of the judiciary rests not merely on its constitutional power to issue orders but on the confidence of the people that those orders are made impartially, competently and in accordance with the law.
The CJN has sounded the warning. The NJC, heads of courts, the NBA and individual judicial officers must now translate that warning into concrete action. Nigeria cannot afford another election season in which political gladiators turn courtrooms into battlefields and judicial orders into political ammunition. The credibility of the 2027 elections will depend, in no small measure, on the courage, independence and integrity of the judiciary.

