Coroner finds 'serious failure' in death in custody of mother of five - ABC News & Headlines – Australian Broadcasting Corporation
A photo of the now-deceased Tammy Shipley (approved by family to use). (Supplied: Aboriginal Legal Service NSW/ACT)
A coroner has found that the death of Aboriginal woman Tammy Shipley inside a cell at Silverwater Women's Correctional Centre in 2022 was preventable.
Ms Shipley died after drinking up to 20 litres of water in a single day.
Coroner Teresa O'Sullivan made 10 recommendations aimed at improving systems across NSW Police, Corrective Services NSW and Justice Health.
The NSW state coroner has found the death of 47-year-old Aboriginal woman Tammy Shipley in an "austere and depressing" prison unit was preventable.
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander readers are advised that this article contains the name and image of an Indigenous person who has died, used with the permission of family.
Coroner Teresa O'Sullivan has identified a series of failings by NSW Police and Corrective Services NSW in the lead-up to the death in custody of the much-loved mother of five.
Ms Shipley died in a cell of the Mum Shirl Unit at Silverwater Women's Correctional Centre on December 20, 2022, after drinking at least 20 litres of water in less than 12 hours.
Ms O'Sullivan found Ms Shipley died of hyponatremia with antecedent causes of polydipsia and complications of schizoaffective disorder.
"If observations had been carried out at the intervals required, it was likely that Tammy's excess consumption of water would have been identified, and she would have been prevented from continuing to consume water at the rate she did."
Ms Shipley was on remand after shoplifting at Target then Woolworths on December 9, 2022, after earlier presenting at Macquarie Fields Police Station and asking to be arrested.
It was at this point Ms O'Sullivan identified the first opportunity for intervention.
Police had previously exhibited "compassion and care" towards Ms Shipley and "appropriately diverted her to the mental health system", the coroner said, but her mental illness was not noted in her custody management record after her second arrest.
"Had police inquired of [internal system] COPS that day, they would have seen that just 13 days earlier, Tammy had been hallucinating and it may have caused real questions to be asked about where she was in her mental health journey," Ms O'Sullivan said.
"The opportunity might then have been available to divert Tammy away from the justice system, particularly in a case where the alleged offending was shoplifting for an amount just over $23."
The coroner found the judge overseeing the Woolworths charges on December 14 intended for Ms Shipley to be released from prison, but inaccurate records relating to her bail status on the Target charges meant she remained incarcerated.
After twice attempting self harm at Silverwater she was placed in the "austere and depressing" Mum Shirl Unit where she was meant to receive regular physical and CCTV checks.
The coroner found this did not happen, which she described as a "serious failure".
Ms Shipley started drinking water at 2:01am on December 18 and was still consistently drinking water by December 20, despite the observation requirements dictated in a plan by the prison's risk intervention team.
Ms Shipley was estimated to have consumed at least 67 cups of water between midnight and noon on the day of her death alone.
Ms O'Sullivan said Ms Shipley started vomiting at 10:04am on December 20, defecated on the floor about 30 minutes later and collapsed and started having seizures about 11:55am.
Corrective Services officers were observed walking past her cell "oblivious", in part because of a broken blind covering the cell window, Ms O'Sullivan said.
Ms O'Sullivan said staff "finally became aware of the situation" at 1:38pm and attempted CPR. Paramedics attended but were not able to revive her and she was declared dead at 2:25pm.
"I find that Tammy should have received medical care from the time that she had started vomiting and became incontinent from 10:04am," Ms O'Sullivan said.
"Had the required observations been conducted in accordance with the [risk intervention team] plan, medical intervention could have been expedited and a different outcome could have been achieved."
The coroner made 10 recommendations aimed at improving systems and procedures across NSW Police, Corrective Services NSW and Justice Health.
One of the recommendations was aimed at further training for a specific Corrective Services officer who, on the day of Ms Shipley's death, smelled faeces through the hatch of her cell door about 10:30am but "quickly closed the hatch and moved to the next cell".
The coroner had also found Ms Shipley had not seen a psychiatrist or mental health nurse for assessment by the time of her death.
She recommended where urgent psychiatrist visits were not possible, prisoners with mental illness should be seen by a psychiatric nurse.
"Although the recommendations in this inquest are firmly grounded in the evidence in Tammy's case, there should additionally be great impetus and urgency to implement them given the number of Aboriginal deaths in custody has never been higher," Ms O'Sullivan said.
Speaking outside the Coroner's Court, Ms Shipley's mother Vicki said she was hopeful all of the coroner's recommendations would be implemented.
Vicki Shipley, mother of Tammy Shipley. (ABC News: Floss Adams)
"I honestly thought that at this stage of our country's development that we had moved past how convicts were treated," Vicki Shipley said.
"Every system caused trauma to my daughter until eventually it killed her.
"If [the changes] are not made, there'll be some other family standing here doing exactly the same thing that I am, or in the worst case scenario just go away and cry."

