Crawford Umhlanga parents ask IEB to review matric Mathematics Paper 1 - IOL

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from IOL News (iol.co.za). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
Parents of matric learners at Crawford Umhlanga have asked the Independent Examinations Board to review the 2026 Mathematics Paper 1, citing its difficulty, time constraints and a possible examination irregularity.

Parents of matric learners at Crawford Umhlanga have asked the Independent Examinations Board to review the 2026 Mathematics Paper 1, citing its difficulty, time constraints and a possible examination irregularity.

Parents of matric learners at a top Durban private school are demanding that Mathematics Paper 1 be rewritten, amid concerns that the paper was too difficult and did not align with the prescribed assessment requirements.

The parents have written to the Independent Examinations Board (IEB), an umbrella body for private schools, demanding a review of the paper, which was written a few weeks ago.

In a letter signed anonymously by 12 parents, they highlighted the difficulties their children experienced during and after writing the paper. The letter is dated 26 October.

“We wish to lodge a formal complaint concerning the 2026 IEB Mathematics Paper 1, especially Section B, and request an urgent review of its difficulty, time demands and alignment with the prescribed assessment requirements.

“Our children attend Crawford Umhlanga, and they consistently achieve A and A-plus results in Mathematics. An A in Mathematics is critical for admission to many of our children’s chosen university courses. Some of our children’s responses after the examination were deeply concerning.

“One parent reported that they would normally take their son to a mall for lunch and give him an opportunity to relax after an examination. On this occasion, despite having two days free before the next paper, he simply asked to be taken home. He then locked himself in his room and cried. As a parent, it was distressing to see a normally capable, high-achieving learner so overwhelmed and fearful about his future.”

The letter added that other Crawford parents had reported similar concerns about their children’s distress.

“These accounts warrant serious consideration and a structured opportunity for parents, learners and Mathematics teachers to submit evidence,” it stated.

“We recognise that a demanding examination, or a learner’s distress, does not by itself establish that an assessment was unfair. However, the concerns being raised justify a transparent examination of whether this paper gave adequately prepared learners a reasonable opportunity to demonstrate their knowledge and ability within the allotted time,” the letter stated.

The parents requested an urgent academic review of the paper’s curriculum alignment, balance of cognitive demands, clarity of questions, mark allocations and realistic completion time.

They also requested an explanation of the setting and moderation processes applied to the paper, how the concerns would be assessed, and a clear timetable for the review and communication of its findings, given the potential implications for university admission.

“We also place on record that teachers at the school were highly critical of the Mathematics paper. There are also several social-media posts from pupils expressing their unhappiness.

“Further, it is of great concern that communication from the IEB dated 28 October 2026 refers to suspected irregularities. It was also brought to our attention that there was an error in the examination paper.

“Given all these factors, we urge that the paper be reset or that some form of reassessment be conducted."

Pupils, who also wrote the paper, have also taken to social media to express their concerns about the difficulty of the examination.

Another student said: “You know how I said I was terrified? I stayed up late studying and had been working through past papers, but none of it helped. I was right to be terrified. What was that paper? That was crazy.”

Confidence Dikgole, Chief Executive Officer of the Independent Examinations Board, said the IEB had been made aware of the complaint.

“The IEB has received correspondence pertaining to the perceived difficulty of Mathematics Paper 1 from three of the 266 IEB-registered schools that offer Mathematics.

“Because the IEB’s question papers are all approved by the quality assurer, Umalusi, all feedback regarding the perceived difficulty of Mathematics Paper 1 will be considered by the IEB Mathematics Examination Panel, in consultation with the Umalusi external moderator, during the standardisation of the marking guidelines. This happens a day before marking commences.

“Furthermore, the combined results of Mathematics Paper 1 and Mathematics Paper 2 will then be subject to Umalusi’s established standardisation processes,” she said.

Marike Becker, marketing manager for Crawford Schools, confirmed receiving the letter from the parents, adding that they are guided by the IEB and Umalusi’s prescribed processes to ensure fairness in these situations.

"The IEB is aware of the feedback and will deal with the complaint in line with process," Becker said.

The IEB has also raised concerns about the possible leaking of the paper in a letter to the principals.

“We have also received an allegation that the paper was accessed before the examination, as well as reports of messages offering examination papers for sale.

It said the circulation of a question paper or purported marking guidelines after an examination does not, in itself, establish that the paper was available beforehand.

Examinations body, Umalusi said it had not been made aware of the concerns. 

Original Source
https://iol.co.za/thepost/news/2026-11-18-crawford-umhlanga-parents-ask-ieb-to-review-matric-mathematics-paper-1/
Visit IOL News ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Education