David Lammy is right - The Telegraph

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from The Telegraph (telegraph.co.uk). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
The former deputy prime minister has called for Britain to rejoin the European Union Credit: Ian West/PA Wire Robert Tombs Published 19 November 2026 6:00am GMT I do not, I admit, usually regard David Lammy’s pronouncements as trustworthy guides to public affairs. Since he accuse...

The former deputy prime minister has called for Britain to rejoin the European Union Credit: Ian West/PA Wire Robert Tombs Published 19 November 2026 6:00am GMT I do not, I admit, usually regard David Lammy’s pronouncements as trustworthy guides to public affairs. Since he accused the British of treating the bodies of Empire soldiers killed in the First World War with racist contempt – an accusation firmly contested by the redoubtable Prof Nigel Biggar – I have treated his views with a strong dose of scepticism.

Lammy’s spell at the Foreign Office, has, he claims in a revealing article in The Times, given him special insight into our international position. Most of the article is a credulous introduction to the cloud-cuckoo-land of Rejoiner fantasy. But occasionally he gets some of the basics right. He states that: “The customs union doesn’t deliver major growth on its own. The single market without EU membership gives Britain economic growth but with little influence over the rules we follow.”

Lammy’s elite-level experience has clearly taught him things that the rest of us have always known. Part of what he says is actually correct – the irrelevance of the customs union and the absence of influence over the rules. His claim that membership of the single market ensures growth flies in the face of the evidence, past and present.

However, he is quite right that the idea of a fudged half-way house between the EU and Brexit is nonsense. Perhaps his meetings with EU ministers drummed that into him. Moreover, he shows some principle – let us give him credit – for urging a second referendum rather than trying to creep in by the back door. Open debate and democratic choice: a bold strategy indeed!

David Lammy urged Andy Burnham to commit to full membership of the bloc Credit: Wiktor Szymanowicz/Future Publishing It is striking how the arguments for a Reset – let alone for actually rejoining the EU – are shrinking faster than a gambler’s bank balance. Once Remainers claimed they were standing fast against economic disaster. Now even this Remainer Government boasts of our superior performance to the major EU economies. The Prime Minister at the Mansion House could only express the vague hope that we can “do better”. Unfortunately for Britain, the Government has launched itself into policies that can only do worse. Increasingly, representatives of business – the City, technological industries, agriculture – are pointing out the dangers of losing the benefits of independence. As truth about the Reset begins to dawn, the best the Government can do is to delay actual decisions and hide what it has already agreed in a blizzard of waffle.

But we know that it has accepted a hugely expensive deal on agriculture and another hugely expensive re-attachment to the Erasmus scheme. In short, we are going to pay billions to let EU farmers export to us. More billions to let EU students come to study and take jobs in Britain – great news for our army of Neets. We can be absolutely sure that any agreement entered into by this Government will involve more billions of our money for no discernible benefit. Except perhaps short-term benefit to the Labour Party – in Lammy’s words, to “shore up our progressive base”.

It is striking how the arguments for a Reset are shrinking faster than a gambler’s bank balance Credit: iStockphoto Lammy, ace diplomat that he is, puts his finger on another significant consideration. Marine Le Pen looks like the next French president, and Lammy believes she can be persuaded to be on our side, unlike General de Gaulle. How? By paying billions to Brussels, which “would reduce France’s EU budget contributions”. Some less gullible observers might think this is the major consideration for all the EU’s net contributors, not only cash-strapped France. Is buying off Le Pen really what Burnham means by “doing better”? Has no one told them that a Le Pen presidency will trigger a French and European crisis that will not be amenable to what Lammy calls “the right diplomacy” – which for him equals non-stop concessions? The EU would love us to become a docile satellite.

Lammy lets another cat out of the bag. He states that EU membership is “the greatest growth accelerator the Government has available”. Leave aside for the sake of argument that the EU is economically stagnant and has never been a growth accelerator for Britain. Indeed, our growth fell as soon as we joined the EEC, bringing about the turbulence of the 1970s about which Burnham is so nostalgic. What Lammy is naively admitting is that all the Government’s other policies are powerless to accelerate growth: net zero, job taxes, increased regulation, bloated state spending, and all the rest. He clearly hopes – what an optimist the man is! – that rejoining a flailing EU will be better than anything Labour can do on its own. Or perhaps, more realistically, he hopes that Labour’s failures will be less glaring if we are in step with the other failures.

Underlying all this is an abject lack of ambition and confidence. Declinism took us into the EEC in the first place: we were the Titanic, said a government adviser, and Europe was the lifeboat. Far smaller countries like Singapore, Malaysia, New Zealand and Switzerland can flourish on their own. Hong Kong would love to have the chance. But poor old Britain can’t manage as an independent nation. Not anyway while the likes of Lammy and Burnham hold the reins.

Original Source
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11/19/david-lammy-is-right-labour-eu-brexit-membership-uk/
Visit The Telegraph ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Politics