Dealership slapped with R500,000 fine over faulty used Mercedes-Benz - IOL

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from IOL News (iol.co.za). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
A dealer has been fined R500 000 after the National Consumer Tribunal found that it misled a buyer over a second-hand Mercedes-Benz and included unlawful clauses in its sales agreement.

A dealer has been fined R500 000 after the National Consumer Tribunal found that it misled a buyer over a second-hand Mercedes-Benz and included unlawful clauses in its sales agreement.

A car dealership has been ordered to pay a R500,000 fine R500 000 after the National Consumer Tribunal found that it misled a customer who bought a second-hand Mercedes-Benz and used unlawful contract terms that sought to exclude its responsibility for vehicle defects.

Bryanston Executive Cars CC sold Sunil Jugathpaul a 2012 Mercedes-Benz C350 for R228,935 in August 2024.

Jugathpaul travelled from Durban to collect the vehicle but soon complained about several problems, including faulty headlights, steering issues, a leaking sunroof and a radiator that needed replacement.

He also claimed that the vehicle did not have a navigation system, despite being advertised with the feature.

The dealership argued that the vehicle had passed a roadworthy test two days before delivery and that Jugathpaul had inspected and test-driven it before buying it.

It said he had been informed about certain conditions, including previous spray work, dents and scratches. It also argued that he had taken the vehicle for repairs without giving the dealership an opportunity to inspect and fix the alleged faults.

The dealership admitted that some clauses in its sale agreement were unlawful but said it had never enforced them and had since updated its terms and conditions.

However, the Tribunal found that the dealership had misled the consumer through its advertising and failed to correct his impression about the vehicle's condition.

The judgment revealed that Jugathpaul spent R10 235 repairing the leaking sunroof and a further R14 180 replacing the radiator.

The Tribunal also found that the dealership's agreement contained unlawful clauses, including one stating “No 6-month warranty is given or implied.”

“The first respondent's terms and conditions contain several clauses directly intended to defeat the purposes of the CPA,” the Tribunal said.

However, it did not order the dealership to refund the purchase price or reimburse the repair costs. It found that the consumer had not proved that the sunroof and radiator defects existed when the vehicle was sold or given the dealership an opportunity to address them.

The Tribunal also noted that the dealership had previously been fined R100 000 in June 2024 for contravening the Consumer Protection Act. It said the repeated conduct demonstrated a disregard for consumer rights.

"The first respondent must, within 30 business days of this judgment being issued, pay an administrative fine of R500 000.00 (five hundred thousand rand) into the National Revenue Fund referred to in section 213 of the Constitution."

Original Source
https://iol.co.za/business/2026-11-19-dealership-slapped-with-r500000-fine-over-faulty-used-mercedes-benz/
Visit IOL News ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Travel