Democrats scrape victory in Alaska race marred by ‘decoy candidate’ - The Telegraph
Mary Peltola is Alaska’s first Democratic senator since 2015 Credit: Charly Triballeau/AFP Chanel Zagon. Lily Shanagher Foreign Breaking News Reporter Published 18 November 2026 5:15am GMT A Democrat has won Alaska’s US Senate race, ousting the state’s Republican incumbent in a race marred by allegations involving a decoy candidate.
Mary Peltola took Dan Sullivan’s seat on Tuesday, giving her party its ninth Senate flip of the midterm elections and a commanding 56-44 majority in the upper house of Congress.
The 53-year-old’s victory secured the Democrats’ largest gain in the Senate since 1958 and made her Alaska’s first Democratic senator in more than a decade.
But the race was marred by controversy after Ms Peltola’s team was accused of helping recruit a retired teacher from a coastal town with the same name as the Republican candidate in an attempt to confuse voters and siphon votes, which she denied.
She has also been accused of mistreating and verbally abusing her staff over the years, which her campaign dismissed as exaggerated or false.
“I knew nothing about any other candidates on the ballot except for me and the incumbent,” Ms Peltola told supporters in Juneau days before the election.
Republicans argued for months that the party had plotted to help Ms Peltola win by splitting the Republican vote.
The teacher, a political unknown named Dan J Sullivan, also denied having any connection with Ms Peltola’s campaign or running on behalf of the party.
He ended up earning 4,760 votes, meaning Ms Peltola would have won anyway as she secured 144,302 votes to the Republican incumbent’s 131,844.
But Donald Trump still reacted angrily, calling for Ms Peltola to be prosecuted after The New York Times first reported the allegations less than a week before the Nov 3 election.
The outlet found that national Democrats and aides had worked to recruit other candidates including “Decoy Dan” on to the ballot, with a former campaign manager claiming Ms Peltola was aware of the efforts.
Mr Trump had called for another Republican candidate in the race, Gerald Heikes, to have his votes “immediately given” to Dan S. Sullivan, calling it the “fair solution”.
Mr Heikes won 6,105 votes in the race, but merging all the votes that Mr Trump wanted to combine would still not have been enough to beat Ms Peltola.
The US president’s justice department also sued before the election to try and invalidate the result.
Ms Peltola’s win, announced two weeks after the midterms, extends a blue wave that saw the party take control of both the Senate and the House of Representatives.
It was the final midterm election result to be called, delayed two weeks by the difficulty of counting votes in the remote state, and clinched an election that saw Republicans suffer heavy losses across the country.
The losses have largely been put down to the Trump administration’s failure to bring the cost of living under control in the wake of the president’s war against Iran that has seen the cost of fuel and inflation rise.
Affordability was a big part of Ms Peltola’s election campaign, as goods in the state are extremely expensive and fuel prices surpassed $8 (£6) a gallon in rural areas.
Having made a living in the commercial fishing industry before entering politics, she took pains to avoid ties with the national Democratic Party, focusing on her slogan “Fish, family, freedom”.
She said she had spoken to “elders in tears about empty fish racks” and blamed the Iran war for “hurting Alaskans with no end in sight”.
Ms Peltola previously held the state’s sole House seat, which made her the first Alaska native to serve in Congress.
She lost her attempt to win re-election to Nick Begich, a Republican, in 2024, before becoming a central figure in the Democrats’ campaign to retake the Senate.
Dan Sullivan, a two-term incumbent, has been unseated with Ms Peltola winning the reliably conservative state Credit: AP/Mark Thiessen In the wake of her victory, she said there was “no greater honour” than having the support of Alaskans, adding that she would fight to tackle corporate greed, lower costs and put the state first. “It’s clear that the status quo in DC cannot go on any longer,” she said.
“Alaskans have voted for change and I’m so honoured to be your next US senator. Together we are going to put an end to the era of self-serving politicians lining their own pockets at your expense and together we are going to put Alaska first.”
The scale of the Democrats’ gains exceeded the party’s own expectations, with Chuck Schumer, the Senate Democratic leader, describing the result as historic.
The party also made gains in traditionally conservative states including South Carolina, Texas, Kansas and Mississippi.
Mr Schumer said: “Fifty six seats was an unimaginable result even just a few months ago. Most people didn’t think 51 Democratic Senate seats was a possibility at the beginning of this cycle.”
With Democrats also firmly in control of the House of Representatives, the party has the power to block legislation, launch investigations into Mr Trump’s administration and thwart his judicial and senior government appointments.
