Democrats won the midterms; that won’t change much for American allies

Shortly after the Democratic Party won back the House and Senate in the US midterm elections, House Democratic Leader (and likely the next Speaker of the House) Hakeem Jeffries announced, “America is back.” After an election that saw the Democrats not only retake the two chambers of Congress by wide margins but also win in states long considered Republican strongholds – including Kansas, Texas and South Carolina – Jeffries can credibly declare that his party is back. But for the country’s allies, the question isn’t whether America is back. It’s back to what – and for how long?

I’ve written extensively about the rise of a G-Zero world, where the United States has stepped back from the international order it created, with no nation or group of nations willing and able to take its place. It‘s a dynamic that‘s also been fueled by Russia‘s behavior as a rogue state and China‘s refusal to liberalize its political and economic systems, as many in the West hoped it would after it was integrated into global markets. But the American retrenchment has been central to the breakdown in the international system, and accelerating it was a deliberate policy choice across Trump’s two terms.

The MAGA movement drew on increasing public skepticism of US involvement in foreign affairs. As key segments of the American population were left behind by the unequal tides of globalization and angered by failed wars in the Middle East, the bedrock political belief that the US should lead the international order was shaken. Yet the erosion of American leadership abroad has not only been a conscious political decision prompted by electoral dynamics but also a breakdown of policy consistency due to a period of dramatic political swings.

With the Democrats winning these midterms, 12 out of the 14 elections in the past 26 years have seen part of the legislative or executive branches of government flip parties – a marked difference from the seven out of 20 elections that did so in the previous 40 years. Paired with rising polarization between the parties and the unraveling of the historically bipartisan American approach to foreign policy, this has led to sharp reversals in policy, from the US‘s repeated joining and leaving of the Paris Climate Accords and UN Human Rights Council to President Trump’s decision to rip up President Obama’s Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action with Iran.

The consequence is whiplash for American allies, especially in Europe. President Biden encountered this dynamic as he worked to rebuild US relationships after the fraying of transatlantic ties during the first Trump term – repeatedly citing conversations in which he told world leaders, “America is back,” only for them to ask, “But for how long?”

With President Trump’s return to the White House after the 2024 election and subsequent questioning of the value of NATO, threatening to seize Greenland and dealmaking with Russian President Vladimir Putin, European countries saw the writing on the wall for their inconsistent American ally and hedged accordingly.

The goal was not to decouple from the United States, but instead to derisk. For European countries growing distrustful of American security guarantees, that meant reinvesting in defense, such as Germany changing its debt rules to rebuild its military. The same dynamic manifested in the Middle East as countries searched for security in the wake of the US’s destabilizing war in Iran, with Saudi Arabia, Turkey and Pakistan forming the Mecca Joint Defense Agreement. Economically, countries looked for new partners. Canada, under pressure from President Trump, worked to build a new relationship with the European Union and pursue deeper engagement with China. The EU, meanwhile, forged new deals with Mercosur and India.

Many American allies are now relieved to see the Democratic resurgence in the midterms since the Democratic Party is more committed to international institutions, despite isolationist tendencies in its far-left wing. The reinstatement of legislative checks on Trump’s power through Democratic leadership in the Senate foreign relations and House foreign affairs committees will be welcome news to many foreign observers, even if it will be unlikely to halt the administration’s hawkish policies toward Iran, Cuba and Venezuela. For American allies hoping for a more multilateral approach to policymaking, that change will have to wait until after 2028, if a less unilateral Republican or Democratic candidate wins the presidency.

But even if that happens, the US does not possess the political will or capacity to return to its role as the undisputed global leader, amid continued political division, rising fiscal constraints and the influence of an ascendant China. And whatever role it does play won’t be durable, as the immediate aftermath of the midterms has already shown. The day after the elections, Vice President JD Vance released a long X post in which he blamed the Iran war for his party’s losses, prompting speculation that the US could curtail future strikes in favor of negotiations. Decisions of war and diplomacy are being made at an increasingly rapid and unpredictable pace in the United States.

That is why even if the Democrats’ victories in these elections mark the beginning of the end of the Trump administration’s America-First approach to foreign affairs, they do not mark the return of a consistent, reliable US foreign policy. That’s a problem for American allies, and a key reason why – for now at least – the G-Zero world is here to stay.

abtestabtest The quitting option By SKETCHES | By Ana Marie Pamintuan | 1 day ago As rumors intensify of her looming conviction and ouster by the Senate impeachment court, some quarters are speculating that Vice President Sara Duterte may opt to resign before the verdict. Opinion Alarming By FIRST PERSON | By Alex Magno | 14 hours ago We should be alarmed that our government is not alarmed by the disastrous path our economy has taken. Opinion Sickest man of Asia By EYES WIDE OPEN | By Iris Gonzales | 14 hours ago Sickest man of Asia And there it goes – the Philippines under Marcos 2.0 is again facing one of its most challenging periods, just a few nightmares away from the crisis that hounded the first Marcos regime... Opinion The economy: BBM’s record vs. past presidents By VIRTUAL REALITY | By Tony Lopez | 14 hours ago The Philippine economy grew 2.1 percent in the third quarter of 2026, the slowest quarterly growth in output of goods and services (what you call the Gross Domestic Product) in 16 years. The 2.1 percent third quarter... Opinion Latest More in Opinion Struggle between Heartland and Rimland Condospital or hospitel? BBM’s dismissive assurances amid a deteriorating economy 7 months between hearings: that’s ‘speedy trial’ in Phl abtest Jaycee senators By COMMONSENSE | By Marichu A. Villanueva | 1 day ago A head of the Leaders’ Summit of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations slated next week to be held in the Philippines is another international event taking place in our country starting today. Opinion Iran calls on US to meet its demands to end war By WORLD VIEW | 1 day ago Iran on Tuesday urged the United States to meet its demands in a plan to reopen the Strait of Hormuz, after President Donald Trump spoke of “positive momentum” to end their eight-month war. Opinion Chronic By FIRST PERSON | By Alex Magno | 2 days ago For the remaining weeks of this year, two things will dominate our public deliberations: the impeachment drama and the effort to straighten out the mangled 2027 General Appropriations Bill that came out of the... Opinion Businesses want BI to review immigration fee By EYES WIDE OPEN | By Iris Gonzales | 2 days ago Even the business sector is worried over the proposed new immigration fee of P480 per passenger. Opinion Body repair By SINGKIT | By Doreen G. Yu | 2 days ago This is not about auto mechanics or my suki talyer which can fix any bangga and make the car look like new. Opinion Recommended Periko sa China November 10, 2026 - 12:00am Tagsa ra si Bise Presidente Sara Duterte nga mosugyot og sulbad sa mga problema sa nasud. OpinionTRENDING Immigration and a divided Washington November 8, 2026 - 12:00am Imagine waking up after the 2026 midterms to a brand-new political reality: Democrats have flipped both the Senate and the House. President Donald Trump is still in the White House finishing out his second term,...r OpinionTRENDING Wa nay kapilian November 7, 2026 - 12:00am Sa kataposan, sa gusto niya o sa dili, bisan sa ka-feeling hawod, kay kumbinsido nga ang kapin sa 32 milyones ka boto nga nakuha niya niadtong 2022 maoy kinakusgang panagang sa bisan unsang pagsuway pagpalagpot niya...r OpinionSALNS next Recommended Periko sa China Tagsa ra si Bise Presidente Sara Duterte nga mosugyot og sulbad sa mga problema sa nasud. 2 days ago TRENDING Immigration and a divided Washington Imagine waking up after the 2026 midterms to a brand-new political reality: Democrats have flipped both the Senate and the House. President Donald Trump is still in the White House finishing out his second term, but the dynamic in Washington just completely transformed overnight. If there is one issue where you will feel this political tectonic shift instantly, it is U.S. immigration policy. 4 days ago TRENDING Wa nay kapilian Sa kataposan, sa gusto niya o sa dili, bisan sa ka-feeling hawod, kay kumbinsido nga ang kapin sa 32 milyones ka boto nga nakuha niya niadtong 2022 maoy kinakusgang panagang sa bisan unsang pagsuway pagpalagpot niya sa puwesto, mapugos na si Bise Presidente Sara Duterte pagtubag sa mga pasangil batok niya. 5 days ago SALNS OK Are you sure you want to log out? Yes No X Login Philstar.com is one of the most vibrant, opinionated, discerning communities of readers on cyberspace. With your meaningful insights, help shape the stories that can shape the country. Sign up now!