Durban-born woman died after New Zealand hospital missed heart attack, watchdog finds - IOL

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from IOL News (iol.co.za). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
Michelle Pillay, 47, died from a heart attack which doctors failed to recognise.

Michelle Pillay, 47, died from a heart attack which doctors failed to recognise.

A South African-born woman spent almost 11 hours in a New Zealand hospital's emergency department before leaving in frustration, after doctors failed to recognise that she was having a heart attack. She died hours later.

Now, more than four years after her death, New Zealand's Health and Disability Commission has found Health New Zealand in breach of the Code of Health and Disability Services Consumers' Rights for failure to recognise and respond to a life-threatening cardiac event.

Michelle Pillay, 47, who had type 1 diabetes and lived with chronic pain, arrived at Tauranga Hospital by ambulance on September 27, 2022, with chest pain, vomiting and urinary incontinence.

Doctors initially suspected her unusual behaviour was linked to medication withdrawal or a possible mental health crisis. An ECG performed shortly after her arrival was discarded because it had not been labelled with her identification details.

Two subsequent ECGs, performed at 8.46pm and 9.34pm, showed abnormalities which an independent medical expert later identified as evidence of an acute heart attack. No emergency cardiac treatment was initiated.

Pillay left the hospital shortly after midnight with her partner, Roisin Connolly, after becoming increasingly frustrated by the lack of medical attention.

She died at 9.07am on September 28 after suffering a cardiac arrest at another hospital.

Connolly said Pillay was born in Durban and moved to Colorado in the United States before relocating to New Zealand. 

“She is survived by her parents and only sibling, her brother,” she said.

Pillay was a trained psychotherapist and had served as the founding treasurer of Indian Origin Pride NZ, an organisation formally launched at Parliament months before she died.

“Michelle and I met in Wellington. She was the most amazing woman I have ever met.

She was charming, smart and kind. As a child she studied ballet and as an adult she moved with the same grace and poise.  Her laugh was infectious and she lit up a room when she walked in. “Everyone who met her loved her and she loved people-especially young people. She was a teacher and taught in New Zealand and the Cooks Islands. Her students adored her for her love of music, dance and joy,” said Connolly.

She said the hardest part of losing Pillay was the manner of her death.

“I accept that she was on loan to us and God called her back to her home with him. However, she did not deserve to suffer like she did. Newspaper reports mention that she self-discharged which skews the narrative. Apart from the fact that she was enduring the pain of a heart attack, she was already in pain from her existing illness.”

“I asked numerous times but they did not give her pain relief nor did they let me give her the medication she owned which was prescribed for her pain. I had it in my pocket!”

She said Pillay spent most of the time in extreme pain.

“She had no food, no fluids, no insulin and no pain relief. She was told it was unlikely she would see a doctor until the morning shift, given the all-clear to leave and the hospital called for a taxi and paid for it. She wanted to live but knew with every hour she spent in Tauranga Hospital, she was dying. It was a slow death. It felt like torture,” said Connolly.

Connolly did not give up fighting to “honour her memory” by holding the hospital accountable.

“The truth is known. It has been a four-year struggle, convincing the HDC to investigate this matter and progress it. I have written countless letters and challenged inaccurate statements. I still have issues with several things in the report but at this stage have achieved enough to let these go. For me, having her story go public has been my justice for her. I feel my work is done. It is time for me to let go now. I think she would be proud of me. She would have done the same for me. “

Health New Zealand sent Connolly a letter of apology as ordered by the Health and Disability Commission.

Original Source
https://iol.co.za/thepost/news/2026-11-19-durban-born-woman-died-after-new-zealand-hospital-missed-heart-attack-watchdog-finds/
Visit IOL News ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Health