Ebenezer review: Johnny Depp's film is a reasonably engaging Christmas film
How many times can you revisit A Christmas Carol? Charles Dickens’ 1843 novella has been adapted countless times, with each version finding its own way of presenting Ebenezer Scrooge’s journey from miserly businessman to a man capable of kindness. With Ebenezer, director Ti West attempts to give the familiar tale a darker, more gothic treatment. There is an interesting film in that idea, and West certainly knows how to create an unsettling atmosphere. But a darker Scrooge does not necessarily make for a more compelling story.
Johnny Depp plays Ebenezer Scrooge, a wealthy businessman whose obsession with money has left him isolated and deeply unpleasant. When his former business partner Jacob Marley (Ian McKellen) appears after death, weighed down by the consequences of his greed, Scrooge is warned that he is heading towards a similar fate. Three spirits then take him through his past, present and future, forcing him to confront the choices that have defined his life and the possibility of changing what lies ahead.
The premise is familiar, and the film does not attempt to radically alter Dickens’ central message. Instead, West changes the texture of the story. His Victorian London is shadowy, grimy and steeped in an almost constant sense of foreboding. The supernatural encounters are considerably more unsettling than what audiences might expect from a traditional festive adaptation. There are grotesque apparitions, disturbing visions and moments that lean firmly into horror. It is an interesting way to approach a story that has often been softened by its association with Christmas viewing.West’s horror sensibilities are evident in the way he builds these sequences. The production design, cinematography and creature effects give the film a tactile quality, while the visual treatment lends it the feel of an old-fashioned gothic production. The ghosts, in particular, are conceived with enough imagination to make their appearances memorable. The Ghost of Christmas Present (Tramell Tillman) is an imposing presence, while Andrea Riseborough brings an eerie quality to the Ghost of Christmas Past. The film is at its most effective when it allows the supernatural to become genuinely frightening rather than simply decorative. At PG 13, it could be an interesting watch for kids looking for some Christmas cheer with a twist of horror.
Depp, however, is a more complicated proposition. He plays Scrooge with exaggerated expressions, theatrical mannerisms and a deliberately unpleasant demeanour. There is no shortage of commitment, but the performance sometimes feels more interested in the eccentricity of the character than the loneliness beneath it. Scrooge is supposed to be difficult company; what makes his journey meaningful is understanding how he arrived at that state and what it takes for him to change. Depp gives us a recognisable miser, but the emotional transition does not always land with the force it needs.
Ian McKellen makes for an engaging Marley, bringing a welcome mix of authority and mischief to the role. Rupert Grint’s Bob Cratchit provides a more grounded emotional counterpoint, while Sam Claflin and Daisy Ridley bring warmth to the story as Fred and Clara. The supporting cast is capable, but several characters remain underexplored. The film is so preoccupied with Scrooge’s supernatural reckoning that the people affected by his behaviour occasionally feel like supporting figures in his personal redemption exercise.
And this is where Ebenezer misses an opportunity. Dickens’ story has endured for nearly two centuries not simply because it is about a miser learning to be generous. It is also a sharp observation about wealth, social indifference and the ease with which people become insulated from the suffering around them. Scrooge’s transformation matters because he finally recognises that his comfort exists alongside the hardship of others. The film retains this moral foundation, but its fascination with the gothic and supernatural sometimes takes precedence over the social commentary that gives the original its bite.
At 116 minutes, the film also takes a little time to find its rhythm. The atmosphere is carefully maintained, but the narrative occasionally feels ponderous. After spending so much time establishing his bitterness and isolation, the film could have allowed more room for the emotional consequences of his revelations. Redemption is the point of the story, after all.
There is plenty to admire in West’s visual reinvention, and the film is an interesting departure from the more sentimental versions of A Christmas Carol. But its gothic treatment cannot entirely compensate for an emotional arc that feels less affecting than it should.
Ebenezer is a reasonably engaging Christmas ghost story, but one that leaves you wishing its darker imagination had been matched by a more powerful emotional payoff.- EndsALSO READ | O.M: Operation Mole review: Dhanush-Mammootty deliver, Sai Pallavi reigns supreme
Bhavna is passionate about dramas and films and loves writing about them. Currently oscillating between K-content, BTS and Bollywood, Bhavna dreams of an epic crossover between both the worlds.
