Economists propose BPC overhaul to ease pressure on pension system - Valor International
The Continuous Cash Benefit (BPC), one of Brazil’s fastest-growing social programs in recent years, has become central to the debate over fiscal adjustment. The program could be redesigned to limit its drag on the pension system while also saving the government some money.
The proposal, by economists Fabio Giambiagi, Gabriel Leal de Barros and Matheus Caliano, would create a new benefit, called “Integração” (Integration), as an entry point to the BPC. It would pay 50% of the full benefit to people reaching the minimum age of 65, rising by 10 percentage points a year to 100% at age 70.
The BPC currently pays one minimum wage in three cases: to people aged 65 or older who have never contributed to the Social Security system; to those who have not contributed enough to qualify for a pension; and to people with disabilities who can prove they lack the means to support themselves. Because the disability category has no age requirement, it would be excluded from the proposal.
The authors argue that delaying access to the full benefit would correct a structural flaw: the BPC competes with retirement benefits, since the minimum age for men is also 65. “The problem with the age-based BPC isn’t the benefit itself, which is entirely legitimate. It’s that it pays exactly the same amount to those who contribute and those who don’t, starting at the same age. What incentive does someone have to pay into the pension system for years if they can reach 65 and receive the BPC anyway?” Giambiagi says.
The proposal would not change what current beneficiaries receive and would apply only to new entrants. If approved this year and implemented next year, it would yield fiscal savings of about R$41 billion between 2027 and 2032, or roughly R$10 billion a year, compared with leaving the current rules unchanged. That estimate, however, assumes the benefit would no longer be indexed to the minimum wage and would instead be adjusted only for inflation.
“Because the eligibility age is the same as for age-based retirement, the BPC is hurting public finances twice over,” says Barros, chief economist at ARX and a co-author of the proposal. “First, the program itself has grown significantly. Second, the rules encourage workers to stop contributing to the National Social Security Institute (INSS).”
Data from the Social Security Statistical Yearbook show that the number of BPC beneficiaries rose from 1.4 million in 1990 to 6.4 million in 2024. Growth has accelerated recently, with the annual rate climbing from 2.52% in the previous decade to 7.62% between 2020 and 2024. Spending on the program has risen from 0.3% of GDP in 1997 to 1.05% this year.
Longer life expectancy among older Brazilians has also extended the period over which benefits are paid, adding to the pressure on public finances. In 1993, when the BPC replaced the Lifetime Monthly Income (RMV) program, the eligibility age was 70 and remaining life expectancy at that age was 11 years. By 2023, after two reforms lowered the minimum age to 65, it had risen to 19 years.
The economists also suggest that Integração could eventually serve as a bridge between Bolsa Família and the BPC, removing overlaps between the two policies while protecting the most vulnerable.
“The average Bolsa Família benefit is currently around 40% of the minimum wage, so we’re proposing to extend that gradual progression up to the full benefit,” Barros says. Under this second phase, a separate progression would begin at age 60 at 40% of the minimum wage and rise by two percentage points a year until it reaches the same 50% level at 65.
That change would modestly increase federal spending on benefits. For that reason, the economists recommend introducing it as a second stage, once a “more favorable fiscal environment” emerges, possibly in the next decade.
Giambiagi stresses that the proposal is highly gradual and would not stop BPC spending from rising again in the next decade. He adds that it reflects a recognition that potentially harsh measures have little chance of succeeding.
In other words, he says, it is an effort shaped by political feasibility. He explains that for years he advocated equalizing the minimum retirement age for men and women, currently 65 and 62, respectively. More recently, he has come to support narrowing the gap, combined with extending maternity leave from four to eight months and converting it into parental leave, so that fathers could also take a set period off.
Barros notes that the proposal leaves untouched two of the program’s main problem areas: litigation over benefit approvals, and growth in BPC payments to people with permanent disabilities, which is outpacing the age-based category.
“Audits by the Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) show a high likelihood of fraud in both cases. In some instances, for example, judges were found to have simply ignored or manipulated the family income criterion when granting benefits,” he says. Under the program’s rules, monthly per capita family income must be no more than one-quarter of the minimum wage, or R$405.25 in 2026.
This article was translated from Valor Econômico using an artificial intelligence tool under the supervision of the Valor International editorial team to ensure accuracy, clarity, and adherence to our editorial standards. Read our Editorial Principles.