Educators, NDP say changing Alberta's high school graduation requirements limit students' future choices - CBC

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from CBC News (cbc.ca). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
A 2020 file photo of a school hallway. Alberta’s provincial government intends to make changes for students beginning Grade 10 in September 2028. (Ryan Remiorz/The Canadian Press)Social SharingSome educators and other critics say the Alberta government’s planned changes to high s...

A 2020 file photo of a school hallway. Alberta’s provincial government intends to make changes for students beginning Grade 10 in September 2028. (Ryan Remiorz/The Canadian Press)Social SharingSome educators and other critics say the Alberta government’s planned changes to high school graduation requirements risk leaving young adults without crucial skills they would need to succeed in any vocation.

Dianne Gereluk, the dean of the Werklund School of Education at the University of Calgary, said introducing requirements that would allow a student to graduate without many Grade 12-level math, science, social studies or language arts courses is problematic.

“What we need [are] strong foundational courses so that we are able to navigate, able to express ourselves, able to live together in a world around us in a future that we don't know,” Gereluk, who is also president of the Association of Canadian Deans of Education, said on CBC Radio's Calgary Eyeopener Monday.

At issue are changes the provincial government intends to make for students beginning Grade 10 in September 2028.

The current graduation requirements include one full-year Grade 12-level class in each of language arts and social studies, and at least one full-year class in both Grade 11 math and one science.

A half-year class in physical education and a half-year class in career and life management (CALM) are also required.

Education and Childcare Minister Demetrios Nicolaides announced last week that under more flexible incoming standards, students can choose the equivalent of two full-year courses in Grade 11 or Grade 12 language arts or social studies classes for a humanities requirement, along with the equivalent of one full-year class in math or sciences at the Grade 11 level.

A student must also write at least one diploma exam for a Grade 12-level class to graduate.

The physical education and CALM requirements will expand to add shorter courses in physical education, wellness and financial literacy at the Grade 11 and Grade 12 levels.

Education and Childcare Minister Demetrios Nicolaides says he believes students could benefit from more flexibility in choosing their high school classes. (Scott Neufeld/CBC)

Although students will still need 100 credits to graduate (a full-year class is five credits; a half-year class is three), fewer of those credits will be in mandatory courses.

Nicolaides told reporters at the legislature on Monday the changes will help keep students engaged in school and prevent them from dropping out.

“We have more students that are able to pursue courses and programs that are directly aligned with their interests,” he said.

During question period in the legislature Tuesday, Premier Danielle Smith said the shift could prepare more students for careers in skilled trades and vocations.

She said her government has challenged school divisions to forge partnerships with private companies to offer students more career training, work placement and dual-credit opportunities. 

The increased emphasis on connecting students earlier with potential career paths comes as the government introduces faster teacher training programs for tradespeople and others with specialized skills.

Alberta NDP Leader Naheed Nenshi told reporters Monday that he believes the proposal risks deteriorating the quality and reputation of the province’s K-12 education system.

“Dumbing down our standards is yet another nail in the coffin of [former premier] Peter Lougheed’s dream that Alberta should have the best public education system in the world,” Nenshi said.

He said the government is mistaken if it believes a person can be successful in skilled trades without a good understanding of math or science, or the skills to write well.

On Monday, deputy NDP leader Rakhi Pancholi accused the provincial government of providing inadequate funding for education and argued it is already limiting seats in post-secondary programs and pushing admission standards higher.

Many university programs require academic credits beyond the bare minimum required to earn a high school diploma.

Gereluk said the provincial government hasn’t consulted with education deans, superintendents or principals on the planned changes, and hasn’t shared what evidence it’s relying on to conclude that fewer academic credits and more financial and wellness education better prepares students for the future.

She said she believes the new requirements could adversely affect students attending small rural schools, which have limited budgets and may struggle to offer all required classes.

“If you have more physical education classes or wellness classes or financial literacy, does that mean there's going to be less opportunity for language classes?” Gereluk said.

In an interview with CBC News, Alberta Teachers’ Association president Jason Schilling said core classes teach students skills in critical and creative thinking and communication.

“Math, science, social studies ... [and] English all prepare students with foundational knowledge that serves them well, and translate into other types of work,” he said. “When we shortchange that on students, I worry we're shortchanging them on their futures.”

Schilling said streaming students into career paths at age 14 or 15 on could leave young adults without important prerequisites for other post-secondary education or career paths if they change their minds later.

He said teachers weren't consulted about the changes. Schilling also said many high schools lack adequate gymnasium space to offer physical education to all students.

Schilling and Gereluk also noted other Canadian jurisdictions are not making these kinds of changes to their school systems.

Also in question period Tuesday, Nicolaides said the growing prevalence of addiction and mental health challenges among youths necessitates more wellness education for students. He said students on his ministerial advisory council told him they wanted improvements to the CALM class.

“They're opposed to choice ... when it comes to health care,” Nicolaides said of the Opposition. “They're opposed to choice when it comes to education. And they're opposed to choice when it means giving students an opportunity to pursue the pathway that is most interesting to them.”

Janet French covers the Alberta Legislature for CBC Edmonton. She previously spent 15 years working at newspapers, including the Edmonton Journal and Saskatoon StarPhoenix. You can reach her at janet.french@cbc.ca.

Add some “good” to your morning and evening.

Subscribe to CBC’s Your Alberta newsletter for a weekly round-up of the best news stories, video and audio content from around your province.

Original Source
https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/alberta-government-graduation-choice-academics-requirements-9.7425919
Visit CBC News ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Education