Every way football has been paralysed by Man City being in limbo - The Telegraph
The English football pyramid faces a nervous wait to find out the details of Manchester City’s punishment for breaching Premier League financial rules Credit: Getty Images/Isaac Parkin Mike McGrath. Kathryn Batte Published 20 November 2026 12:00pm GMT Football is waiting for the final outcome of Manchester City’s legal case with the Premier League. It is six weeks since City were found guilty of all but one of the 100-plus charges for financial breaches, with other clubs, football intermediaries and sponsors holding their breath until there is a resolution.
City have lodged an appeal and there has been no announcement on sanctions against the club. Here, Telegraph Sport looks at how the football pyramid is in limbo.
It is around this time of the season – the November international break – that clubs accelerate plans for the mid-season window and assess what their squads need. But this time it has been quiet in terms of early moves to get deals lined up. Last season there was an increase in January spending, with £404.1m spent – an increase of more than £9m from 2025. Could there be a decrease in spending after years of growth?
Clubs facing relegation from the Premier League usually look for a January signing to freshen up their squad. But there is uncertainty about how this season will pan out because of the sanctions City face for their guilty verdict. Relegation has been widely speculated to be a potential punishment, or a severe points deduction, which would affect the need for a lower-mid-table club to spend.
It is hard to overstate the importance of City in the football pyramid. Last January they made the biggest signing of the window when £64m went to Bournemouth for Antoine Semenyo. A few months later they also bought players from League One clubs Sheffield Wednesday (Pierce Charles, £3m) and Leicester City (Jeremy Monga, £10m). Nottingham Forest’s record transfer sale was broken when City signed Elliot Anderson for £116m.
City have lost their last three Premier League games, but making January signings has not been the focus as sanctions loom. Their transfers affect the balance sheet of other clubs over the course of several seasons, as many deals are paid in instalments. In France there were recent moves for Rayan Cherki, Jérémy Doku and then Ayyoub Bouaddi for £85.6m this summer from Lille. Clubs receiving the transfer fee can work with lenders to get the full amount up front, with repayments made when the instalments arrive. But Bloomberg has reported that these banks are holding back until the scale of the Premier League sanction is known.
Ayyoub Bouaddi signed from Lille after impressing at this summer’s World Cup with Morocco Credit: Manchester City Other playersPlayers at other clubs have been in talks to extend their contracts, primarily at City’s rivals Arsenal, where three key first-teamers are ready to commit their futures. But with uncertainty over what the market would look like should City suffer relegation, plans for rival clubs could change.
During 10 years of Pep Guardiola’s management, City recruited the best players and often their value increased as the trophies arrived. Any City players appearing on the market would inevitably attract interest from Premier League rivals, with players from elsewhere pushed down the pecking order.
Football League clubs have relied on City to provide loan options, which give them young talent for their own campaigns, while the parent club benefit from their talent gaining senior experience, which enhances player value. This season Stockport County, Leicester City, Kidderminster Harriers, Southampton, Luton Town, Exeter City, Wigan Athletic, West Ham United and Sheffield Wednesday have taken loans.
Then there is Stephen Mfuni, who is starting Premier League games with Coventry. In Europe there have been academy loans to Monaco, Lommel and Augsburg. City have provided talent for other clubs indirectly, with players such as Brahim Díaz and Pedro Porro previously on the Etihad Campus’s books, or more recently Cole Palmer. The discussions about the punishment City should receive include talk of dropping down the divisions, which affects their academy and the production line of footballers who head to other clubs.
Stephen Mfuni has started Coventry City’s two most recent Premier League matches Credit: Getty Images/Suvadeep Biswas SponsorshipThere has been talk at clubs that sponsors with deals running out are waiting to see what the outcome of the City case will be. The uncertainty for sponsors – who use the status of Premier League clubs to boost their brands – centres on who will be in the competition. Losing City – with Erling Haaland and their other high-profile players – would be a blow for the attractiveness of the league, which has had high-profile players such as Mohamed Salah and Kevin De Bruyne recently leave.
As one source suggested, there are “six billion reasons” why the Premier League needs a clean resolution. The last domestic TV rights deal was actually worth £6.7bn, but the sentiment is clear. At stake is the integrity of the competition and for the independent commission to punish any wrongdoing appropriately. Failure to do so may compromise the value of the competition to potential broadcasters who invest billions to distribute the product to the public.
A Premier League without Manchester City could prove a more difficult sell for the division’s broadcasters Credit: Reuters/Carl Recine There are also questions raised about what the competition would look like without City, who have set a high standard for rivals during Guardiola’s decade of success. At the moment, it is Arsenal who have the dominance and are five points clear of their closest rivals with a quarter of the season gone.
The message from the women’s team at City has been “business as usual” since the guilty verdict. It is understood there is no active investigation into Manchester City Women and no suggestion of any wrongdoing in their department.
That does not mean they will not be affected by any punishment handed to the men’s team. Should the independent commission impose relegation, a heavy fine or several points deductions, there could be a financial effect on the women’s team. Would City be able to continue to pay marquee striker Bunny Shaw, who signed a lucrative new contract worth about £1m per year this summer?
Khadija ‘Bunny’ Shaw tops this season’s Women’s Super League scoring charts with 12 goals from 10 matches Credit: Reuters/Craig Brough City could look for outside investment. Sunderland sold a majority stake in their women’s team to multi-club ownership Bay Collective earlier this year, which serves as a possible formula. The women’s team do have standalone sponsorship deals. In March 2023, Joie was announced as the official “family partner” of the women’s team, with the club’s stadium renamed “The Joie Stadium”. It was the first time a Women’s Super League club had secured a commercial agreement for its stadium naming rights.
There are other women’s team-specific commercial partnerships, including wealth management firm Evelyn Partners and Snuggs, the club’s official period underwear partner.
There is also the question of reputational damage. The women’s team may not be guilty of any rule breaks, but players may view them as guilty by association. Like most women’s teams, City rely on their men’s department and their fate will rest on how severely they are punished.

