Extra expenses don't explain P4 million gap in Sara Duterte's SALN — prosecution
MANILA, Philippines — Additional expenses incurred during the acquisition process do not explain the P4 million discrepancy in the declared value of the Matina Crossing property listed in Vice President Sara Duterte's Statement of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth, prosecutor Amando Ligutan said Tuesday, November 10.
Ligutan maintained that taxes and other expenses incurred in transferring real property to one's name should not be included in its declared acquisition cost.
Commending co-counsel Jay Tolosa's performance on Monday, November 9, Ligutan said the prosecution was surprised to hear Senator-judge Imee Marcos and Davao City assessor Jaime Adalin suggest this explanation, given its non-compliance with the law.
Adalin answered in the affirmative when Marcos asked on Monday if it was possible for acquisition costs listed in an official's SALN to differ from figures in a property's deed of sale due to other expenses, such as the 12% value-added tax.
Ligutan added that Adalin's role as city assessor, made permanent in 2017 by then-Mayor Duterte, should have been a "home run" for the vice president's defense team.
City assessors identify, locate and appraise all real property within a city, including land and buildings, to establish a basis for real estate and property taxes. During cross-examination, Adalin could not confirm whether the Matina Crossing property purchased by Duterte's husband, Manases "Mans" Carpio, was the same property listed in her SALN.
In doing so, Ligutan said, Adalin was unable to prove the defense's argument.
"It's not good for a party to end up with that conclusion. If you want to prove they're the same property, that's fine. But when your witness themself says, 'They might be (the same property)' then, upon probing, says, 'They also might not be (the same property),' that's a disaster," he said.
Addressing the list of properties in Barangay 74-A, Davao City, that Adalin presented, Ligutan said "it is too late in the day" to submit such a document, as the assessor's credibility has come into question not only over the Matina Crossing property but also over an all-expense-paid trip to China with other Davao City officials in 2025.
Adalin initially claimed not to recall visiting China before confirming the trip abroad following an interjection from Senator-judge Raffy Tulfo.
"In this age of everybody taking photos of practically everything, you don't remember? It's incredible to say the least," Ligutan said of Adalin's answers.
Adalin is the first of 24 witnesses scheduled to appear during the impeachment trial hearings on November 9 to 13. Bank officials and city assessors comprise the list, from which the prosecution is not expecting a "big bang."
"This is an impeachment trial. I'm not saying that these are not important positions ... but they are under the control of the local government unit. I have to admit I was expecting more from the defense this afternoon," Ligutan explained.
Suzette Balucanag-Punay, in-house counsel for GenCorp Industries Inc. and Metro City Chow Foods Corp., two firms that have been linked to Duterte, takes the stand on Wednesday, November 11, to speak on the vice president's companies, properties and salary.
abtestabtest Defense: Sara did not get double pay By Bella Cariaso | 14 hours ago After presenting the Davao City accountant as witness before the Senate impeachment court, Vice President Sara Duterte’s... Headlines If VP quits, will impeach trial continue? By Ghio Ong | 14 hours ago It would be up to the Senate impeachment court to decide whether to continue with the trial of Vice President Sara Duterte,... Headlines LIST: Over 300 flights affected by ASEAN Summit in Manila Nov. 13–19 By Alyana Uy | 1 day ago Changes affect flights by AirAsia, Cebu Pacific and Philippine Airlines. Headlines Sara Duterte received ‘return of capital’ of 2.14 million from GenCorp. — witness By Ian Laqui | 20 hours ago Vice President Sara Duterte has received a “return of capital” from a corporation tied to her, according to the... Headlines Witness: VP got P2.14 million ‘return of capital’ from GenCorp By Neil Jayson Servallos | 14 hours ago Vice President Sara Duterte received a total of P2.14 million as “return of capital” from 2022 to 2025 from GenCorp Industries Inc., a corporation tied to her and her husband, its legal counsel said at... Headlines Latest More in Headlines ASEAN Summit: Metro Manila road closures, alternate routes, traffic advisories Philippines faces difficult mix of high inflation, sluggish growth — BSP NPC confirms data breach in 10 government agencies Marcos Jr. ratings down, Sara steady – poll abtest Philippines, Australia to sign defense deal By Michael Punongbayan | 14 hours ago The Philippines and Australia are scheduled to sign a landmark defense cooperation deal on Sunday ahead of next week’s... Headlines Sandigan junks Revilla bid to dismiss malversation rap By Daphne Galvez | 14 hours ago The Sandiganbayan has denied former senator Ramon Revilla Jr.’s petition to dismiss the malversation case against... Headlines Macalintal appeals SC ruling on BSKE reset 14 hours ago The Supreme Court (SC) may uphold the constitutionality of the law fixing the term of barangay and Sangguniang Kabataan officials... Headlines Adjusted mall hours start next week By Andrew Ronquillo | 14 hours ago Mall operators in the capital will adjust operating hours to ease holiday traffic, the Metropolitan Manila Development Authority... Headlines Philippines ready to welcome ASEAN leaders By Pia Lee-Brago | 14 hours ago The Philippines will welcome heads of state and government to Manila for the 49th Association of Southeast Asian Nations Summit and Related Summits from Nov. 15 to 17 as the 10-member bloc faces many challenges in... Headlines Recommended Periko sa China November 10, 2026 - 12:00am Tagsa ra si Bise Presidente Sara Duterte nga mosugyot og sulbad sa mga problema sa nasud. HeadlinesTRENDING Immigration and a divided Washington November 8, 2026 - 12:00am Imagine waking up after the 2026 midterms to a brand-new political reality: Democrats have flipped both the Senate and the House. President Donald Trump is still in the White House finishing out his second term,...r HeadlinesTRENDING Wa nay kapilian November 7, 2026 - 12:00am Sa kataposan, sa gusto niya o sa dili, bisan sa ka-feeling hawod, kay kumbinsido nga ang kapin sa 32 milyones ka boto nga nakuha niya niadtong 2022 maoy kinakusgang panagang sa bisan unsang pagsuway pagpalagpot niya...r HeadlinesSALNS next Recommended Periko sa China Tagsa ra si Bise Presidente Sara Duterte nga mosugyot og sulbad sa mga problema sa nasud. 2 days ago TRENDING Immigration and a divided Washington Imagine waking up after the 2026 midterms to a brand-new political reality: Democrats have flipped both the Senate and the House. President Donald Trump is still in the White House finishing out his second term, but the dynamic in Washington just completely transformed overnight. If there is one issue where you will feel this political tectonic shift instantly, it is U.S. immigration policy. 4 days ago TRENDING Wa nay kapilian Sa kataposan, sa gusto niya o sa dili, bisan sa ka-feeling hawod, kay kumbinsido nga ang kapin sa 32 milyones ka boto nga nakuha niya niadtong 2022 maoy kinakusgang panagang sa bisan unsang pagsuway pagpalagpot niya sa puwesto, mapugos na si Bise Presidente Sara Duterte pagtubag sa mga pasangil batok niya. 5 days ago SALNS OK Are you sure you want to log out? Yes No X Login Philstar.com is one of the most vibrant, opinionated, discerning communities of readers on cyberspace. With your meaningful insights, help shape the stories that can shape the country. Sign up now!
