FIA’s crackdown on free speech in F1 - The Telegraph
Mohammed Ben Sulayem, the FIA president, has developed a reputation for being thin-skinned and getting rid of those who question him Credit: Getty Images/Ronaldo Schemidt Tom Cary Senior Sports Correspondent Show biography Tom has been Senior Sports Correspondent at the Telegraph since 2020, having previously held a variety of specialist roles including F1 Correspondent and Cycling Correspondent. Recognised multiple times by the SJA, he has covered everything from the Olympics to the America’s Cup via the Ryder Cup. Tom can be contacted at tom.cary@telegraph.co.uk and on X @tomcary_tel.
Formula One returns to Las Vegas this weekend for the first leg of a triple-header which will conclude the 2026 season. Sin City will be its usual glitzy, neon-lit self. But the media centre will be a little quieter than usual.
There are various reasons for that. The fact that both championships have been decided does not help. Nor does the run of eight grands prix in 10 weeks across four different continents leading up to this race, which means some reporters will be taking a well-earned breather (while also saving some pennies by not travelling to one of the most expensive weekends of the year).
Perhaps the most troubling fact, though, is that some journalists are simply not welcome.
News last week that the FIA, motorsport’s world governing body, has banned the Daily Mail’s Jonathan McEvoy until the end of the 2026 season, because of an article he wrote about Ferrari’s Charles Leclerc, is deeply concerning.
Telegraph Sport is not necessarily defending what McEvoy wrote. For those who missed it, he described Leclerc as a “sneaky little b------” for his alleged behaviour in the wake of the Mexico City Grand Prix earlier this month, where the Monegasque clashed on track with Ferrari team-mate Lewis Hamilton. But, to paraphrase the author Evelyn Beatrice Hall, we should all defend to the death his right to say it.
Jonathan McEvoy of the Daily Mail has been banned by the FIA for an opinion piece written about Ferrari’s Charles Leclerc Credit: Getty Images/Kym Illman The FIA argued in a letter to the Mail that the article “fell short of the standards of professionalism expected of media representatives accredited to cover the FIA Formula One World Championship”. In an additional response to a request for comment from Telegraph Sport, a spokesman clarified that the “abusive” language he used was “unacceptable”. “The use of abusive language by journalists, particularly when directed at drivers, teams, officials or fans, is unacceptable. This is especially important as the significant issue of online abuse in sport continues to escalate.” McEvoy, for his part, said his jibe had been “tongue in cheek”.
But whatever you think, it is a slippery slope for a governing body to ban a journalist for expressing their opinion.
Besides, if Ferrari have an issue with a journalist – and there is no evidence they did, with Ferrari not returning a request for comment at the time of writing – they can always deny them access to their drivers or team.
That is what Red Bull and Max Verstappen did to Sky Sports F1 in 2022 after pit-lane reporter Ted Kravitz said Hamilton had been “robbed” of an eighth world championship in 2021. Even that felt like overreach. Many feel Sky Sports F1 has been treading on eggshells ever since. But at least the broadcaster was not denied access to the paddock. Ferrari could have done likewise, or taken legal action against the Mail if they felt that strongly about it.
The FIA’s job is not to police journalists’ opinions, provided they are legal. The governing body should not be weaponising media accreditation and the right to attend races.
As Telegraph Sport can disclose, there is already far too much fearfulness in the paddock on that score. McEvoy is not the only journalist to have fallen foul of the FIA this season. One longstanding journalist, who did not wish to be named, had his pass refused at the start of this season, ending a 37-year unbroken run of races. He has not been seen in the paddock since.
The FIA claimed when asked that this was because he failed to meet its criteria for accreditation, which included providing the governing body with “third-party validated data on the readership/audience levels of his publication”. It added that he was welcome to reapply for the 2027 season with supporting data.
But plenty of outlets who were accredited this season would probably have fallen foul of its criteria.
Multiple sources within the sport, including within the FIA, suggest the real reason is that the writer has been fiercely critical of Mohammed Ben Sulayem, the FIA president, and he wants to make an example of him. The FIA denies this.
What is undeniable is that Ben Sulayem, 65, has been embroiled in a succession of controversies since taking over as FIA president in December 2021, developing a reputation for being thin-skinned and for getting rid of anyone who questions him.
The Emirati, a former rally driver, has suggested in the past that there is a British “bias” against him, which explains the negative coverage. But the allegations have racked up.
Ben Sulayem was accused of bullying and sexism by Shaila-Ann Rao, the former interim secretary general for motorsport, in a letter seen by Telegraph Sport, which she sent before her abrupt departure from the governing body in December 2022. Ben Sulayem denied all allegations, complaining of “British media bias” against him.
Ben Sulayem’s tenure as FIA president has featured several high-profile controversies Credit: AP/Luca Bruno Natalie Robyn, the FIA’s American former chief executive, also raised questions about the current administration following her departure in 2024, after only 18 months, telling the BBC that her time at the body was “challenging” and saying “professional processes were not adhered to and stakeholders were excluded from decision-making”, both of which “threaten the credibility” of the organisation.
She was speaking after the resignation of Robert Reid, Ben Sulayem’s first vice-president for sport. The Scot, a former world rally champion co-driver, resigned in April last year citing “a fundamental breakdown in governance standards within” the FIA.
Reid was referring, among other things, to changes made to the FIA’s ethics commission under Ben Sulayem, which critics claim centralise oversight into the hands of the FIA president and the senate president. The FIA defended the changes, stating they were meant to “preserve and enhance the independence” of the ethics committee, and to stop continuous media leaks of confidential material. But David Richards, chairman of the UK’s national racing authority Motorsport UK, said last year that his body was ready to take legal action against the FIA over what he described as a “gagging order” of World Motor Sport Council members.
Richards also noted that “numerous senior members of the FIA and volunteer officials have either been fired or have resigned under an opaque cloud” during Ben Sulayem’s tenure.
Most recently, it was revealed that Ben Sulayem was planning to end age limits for office-holders in motorsport’s governing body. An age limit of 70 was imposed in 2023, during Ben Sulayem’s first presidential term, which was understood to be a tactic to prevent Richards, 74, from opposing Ben Sulayem at last year’s presidential election. The FIA denied this.
Ben Sulayem ended up being re-elected unopposed last December after three individuals who wanted to oppose him – including former racing driver Laura Villars and ex-FIA steward Tim Mayer – were blocked from doing so by a quirk of the FIA’s election rules.
Laura Villars took legal action against the FIA because of ‘serious democratic failings’ within the organisation Credit: Shutterstock/Cyril Zingaro Even the BBC is not safeIn such a climate, with so many questions being asked, a free and fair press is essential. Which is why instances of longstanding F1 journalists having their passes refused is troubling.
As well as the aforementioned journalists, Telegraph Sport understands that Andrew Benson, the BBC’s F1 correspondent, who has also reported extensively on issues at the FIA, had trouble with his FIA accreditation at the beginning of this year. After years of having a permanent FIA pass, he was suddenly refused one. He had to apply instead via Formula One Management (FOM) as a broadcaster. The FIA claims this was because its annual audit showed that his work was 70 per cent on broadcast.
But sources within the sport suggest he was targeted, with the FIA selecting a couple of other journalists – including The Racer’s Chris Medland and motorsport.com’s Roberto Chinchero – who were also told they had to reapply via FOM. Chinchero was eventually able to convince the FIA that his work was predominantly written media. Again, the FIA insists any suggestion of “targeting” of journalists is incorrect. The BBC declined to comment. But given the scrutiny of the FIA’s governance, its processes, its transparency and the departures of so many staff under a cloud, it invites questions.
The FIA is supposed to control media accreditation to stop commercial interference in media matters. That is why FOM does not get involved. But you have to wonder why Stefano Domenicali, F1’s chief executive, has not intervened in these cases given the bad look for the sport. As the Mail’s head of sport Chris Dean says, we are entering “dangerous territory” here.
The sport is already on thin ice in terms of independent media coverage, with Netflix presenting a glossy, curated image of the sport to the world, over which teams have a right of veto. Drivers and teams have their own websites and social media officers, to whom they give cosy in-house interviews. F1 puts out exclusive content on its own channels, while leaning on rights holders not to rock the boat.
An in-house Haas videographer captures footage of Oliver Bearman at the US Grand Prix Credit: Getty Images/Kym Illman More than ever there is a requirement for rigorous, independent reporting and scrutiny. Especially from outlets who pay their own way, who are not beholden to the sport or actively working for it.
Although there have been instances in the past of media having their accreditation removed – photographers taking pictures in “red zones”, non-rights holders filming in the paddock, or for unprofessional behaviour such as asking drivers for selfies or autographs – they are mainly procedural. The most relevant precedent with regards to McEvoy’s case was when Lionel Froissart called Lance Stroll “autistic” on Belgian TV during the 2022 Austrian GP and got his access cancelled for the following two races. McEvoy could have been kinder in expressing his view, but it was his view and he should be free to express it.
The Telegraph has spoken to multiple F1 journalists in the last week, all of whom believe there is a worrying pattern here – particularly with regards to criticising the governing body or the sport – but who are fearful of speaking out for fear of reprisals. A number of them are freelance, meaning their paddock passes are effectively their means of livelihood.
The FIA said: “The FIA welcomes rigorous, critical journalism. Editorial independence is essential to credible motor sport coverage. However, the use of abusive language by journalists, particularly when directed at drivers, teams, officials or fans, is unacceptable. This is especially important as the significant issue of online abuse in sport continues to escalate.”
Formula One declined to provide a comment for this article.

