Finance minister criticizes fiscal policy ‘denialism’ - Valor International
Finance Minister Dario Durigan on Tuesday (17) criticized “denialism” about the need for fiscal adjustment and said there was no room for “indiscriminate spending” by any of the three branches of government. During a public hearing before the Senate’s Economic Affairs Committee (CAE), he also described gradual fiscal adjustment as the “only way forward.”
“There is no magic solution here. There is no ‘Posto Ipiranga’ and no license for indiscriminate spending by Congress, the Judiciary, or the federal government,” he said, referring to the nickname given to Paulo Guedes, who was minister of Economy during president Jair Bolsonaro’s administration. “There is no magic in economics. We all have to be fiscally responsible, including the Supreme Court.”
The remarks came in the morning, amid efforts by the economic team to advance a complementary bill (PLP) that provides for fiscal adjustment measures with an estimated impact of between R$45.1 billion and R$56.1 billion in 2027. By late afternoon, however, the Senate had postponed what was supposed to be the final vote before the bill moved to the Chamber of Deputies.
The minister also stressed that President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva’s government had committed, through the Budget Guidelines Law, to posting primary surpluses between 2027 and 2030, with positive results increasing each year. For this year, the target is a surplus of 0.25% of gross domestic product (GDP), with a tolerance band of 0.25 percentage point above or below that level. Since the beginning of Lula’s third term, gross general government debt (DBGG), the main indicator of the public debt stock, has risen by more than 10 percentage points of GDP, reaching 82.95%.
Without naming him, Durigan criticized proposals by Senator Flávio Bolsonaro (Liberal Party, PL, Rio de Janeiro), a former presidential candidate and Lula’s opponent in the 2026 election, which envisaged the possibility of achieving a primary surplus of 2% of GDP in 2027. According to the minister, the measures the candidate put forward were never clearly explained.
“As the opposition candidate backpedaled, it became clear that the only way forward is gradual adjustment that respects social spending but does not deny the need to make progress in improving the public accounts,” he said.
The CAE also discussed the calculation of the benchmark rate for the Social Contribution on Goods and Services (CBS), introduced under the consumption tax reform, for 2027. The Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) set the rate at 11.3%, above financial market estimates and projections by tax experts, who had expected a rate close to 9%, as reported by Valor. According to the Finance Ministry, the new federal tax’s average effective rate will be below 8.5% in 2027.
During the hearing, Durigan acknowledged that implementation of the consumption tax reform could have a “small impact” on inflation initially. He said business owners would “learn how to price” goods and services under the new tax legislation.
“Once this pricing is properly understood—which will happen gradually over the coming months—we will see a reduction in this inflationary impact. The Finance Ministry will continue to monitor this very closely,” he said.
Durigan acknowledged the difficulties involved in moving forward with the reform’s implementation but argued that the changes must proceed.
Federal Revenue Service Secretary Robinson Barreirinhas said postponing the reform would mean withholding R$10 billion in cashback payments from low-income people in 2027. Cashback is the mechanism through which taxes are refunded to this group.
“That is money in the pockets of the poorest people. R$10 billion will be returned through cashback or will not even be charged on their cell phone, water, electricity, sewage, and gas bills,” he said. Some sectors of the economy have been calling for the reform to be postponed.
TCU President Vital do Rêgo Filho defended the methodology used to calculate the CBS rate, saying it was consistent, data-based, and free of weaknesses that could undermine the result. He said, however, that tax incentives and special tax treatment for certain sectors had helped push the benchmark rate up to 11.3% in 2027. He did not rule out revisions, saying that as the CBS takes effect and actual data on revenue collection and taxpayer behavior become available, it will be “possible to fine-tune the estimates more and more accurately.”
This article was translated from Valor Econômico using an artificial intelligence tool under the supervision of the Valor International editorial team to ensure accuracy, clarity, and adherence to our editorial standards. Read our Editorial Principles.


