Fiscal effort required to stabilize debt has increased, BTG says - Valor International

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from G1 Globo (globo.com). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
The fiscal effort required to stabilize Brazil’s public debt has increased by nearly 0.8 percentage point of GDP in recent months, and the measures currently under discussion in the country are insufficient to halt the upward trajectory of indebtedness. This is the assessment of ...

The fiscal effort required to stabilize Brazil’s public debt has increased by nearly 0.8 percentage point of GDP in recent months, and the measures currently under discussion in the country are insufficient to halt the upward trajectory of indebtedness. This is the assessment of economists at BTG Pactual, who say the government would need to achieve a primary surplus of approximately 2.5% of gross domestic product starting in 2030 to stabilize gross debt at around 90% of GDP.

“The increase is predominantly driven by external factors: with U.S. real interest rates at around 2.5%, Brazil’s equilibrium real interest rate associated with the fiscal position under Lula III [third term] rose from 6.5% to 7.5%, while the permanent primary surplus needed to stabilize debt at its current level increased from 1.5% to 2.3% of GDP,” economists Tiago Berriel, Mateus Della Giustina and Fabio Serrano said.

The study also indicates that the supplementary bill implementing the fiscal adjustment (PLP 299/2026), approved by the Senate and still awaiting consideration by the Chamber of Deputies, should improve the 2027 primary fiscal balance by approximately 0.2 percentage point of GDP but will not be enough to change the debt trajectory. Even if the bill is fully approved, gross debt would reach approximately 118% of GDP in 2034, compared with 121% in a scenario without the measures.

“The bill therefore represents a genuine improvement in the fiscal balance, but not a regime shift: the debt dynamics remain essentially unchanged,” the economists emphasized.

BTG also simulated scenarios in which real growth in public spending would be permanently limited to 2% a year, combined with additional revenue-raising measures. Even under the most optimistic revenue assumptions, gross debt would reach 106% of GDP in 2034 and would remain on an upward trajectory.

According to the economists, only scenarios that limit real spending growth to 1% a year, through changes to the indexation rules and earmarking requirements for mandatory expenditures, bring the country close to stabilizing its debt. Measures considered include adjusting benefits linked to the minimum wage only in line with inflation, changing the constitutionally mandated minimum spending levels for health care and education, and revising the rules governing increases in other mandatory expenditures.

Under the scenario combining these changes with more optimistic revenue assumptions, the primary surplus would reach 2.8% of GDP in 2034, making it possible to stabilize debt at approximately 96% of GDP. With a more moderate revenue package, indebtedness would reach 101% of GDP and would continue to increase, albeit slowly.

“It is not possible to achieve stabilization through revenue measures using the instruments currently under discussion. Structural restraint on mandatory spending is what separates the scenarios in which debt stops growing from those in which it does not,” they said.

The economists also stressed that fiscal consolidation capable of changing investors’ perceptions of debt sustainability could significantly reduce the government’s borrowing costs. In the debt-stabilization scenarios, the equilibrium real interest rate would decline to between 4.4% and 4.7%, helping reduce the fiscal effort required.

“How gradual can consolidation of this magnitude be? The endogenous reduction in interest rates, given current public-sector debt levels, increasingly depends on perceptions of the debt trajectory and, consequently, its risk premium. Thus, the room for gradual fiscal adjustment depends on the credibility of the adjustment path and the ability to achieve, in a timely manner, the primary surpluses required to stabilize debt,” they said.

The BTG economists’ report notes that the adjustment being considered does not assume an abrupt fiscal contraction, but rather a gradual slowdown in the growth of mandatory expenditures over several years. Even so, the authors acknowledge that Brazil’s recent fiscal policy track record could undermine investor confidence in the implementation of this strategy.

“Naturally, Brazil’s recent track record of fiscal adjustments may raise questions about the credibility of a gradualist strategy, reducing its impact on interest rates,” they concluded.

This article was translated from Valor Econômico using an artificial intelligence tool under the supervision of the Valor International editorial team to ensure accuracy, clarity, and adherence to our editorial standards. Read our Editorial Principles.

Original Source
https://valorinternational.globo.com/markets/news/2026/11/19/fiscal-effort-required-to-stabilize-debt-has-increased-btg-says.ghtml
Visit G1 Globo ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Economy