Fiscal package approval reinvigorates push for broad political alliance - Valor International

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from G1 Globo (globo.com). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
Wednesday (18) night’s vote in the Senate challenges the notion that Congress mobilizes only to increase spending. The agreement on the fiscal adjustment package, which will cut R$50 billion, drew broader support than the one reached four years ago, when lawmakers authorized an e...

Wednesday (18) night’s vote in the Senate challenges the notion that Congress mobilizes only to increase spending. The agreement on the fiscal adjustment package, which will cut R$50 billion, drew broader support than the one reached four years ago, when lawmakers authorized an extra R$145 billion in spending outside the spending cap then in force.

The final version of the supplementary bill implementing the fiscal adjustment passed 69 to 2. The constitutional amendment that transitioned the fiscal framework for Lula’s third term in 2023 got 63 votes in favor and 11 against. The vote marked a truce in the turbulent political climate President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva (Workers’ Party, PT) found on returning to Brasília. Senator Eduardo Braga (Brazilian Democratic Movement, MDB, Amazonas), the bill’s rapporteur, summed it up: the dispute was not about fiscal policy, taxation or the merits of the proposal, but about politics.

The fiscal package was approved 24 days after the second round of the presidential election and seven days after it was formally introduced in the Senate. Four years ago, arrangements to accommodate Auxílio Brasil, whose benefit was tripled in the final year of Jair Bolsonaro’s administration, and the planned minimum-wage increase were expected to make it easier to win authorization for extra spending. They did not. That measure passed 41 days after the second round of the 2022 election and nine days after it was formally introduced.

The Senate met the demands of governors and mayors, largely ignored calls for compensation through tax credits, and pressed ahead with restrictions on extra payments to public officials. The fiscal package won votes even from the Liberal Party (PL). Part of the explanation lies in the weakening of Bolsonarism.

Senator Renan Filho (MDB of Alagoas) made the point during the vote on an amendment that would have quadrupled the spending cuts and effectively buried the Minha Casa Minha Vida housing program, the Pé-de-Meia education savings program, Gás do Povo cooking gas vouchers, and drug subsidies of Farmácia Popular: “Ideological imprisonment does not come from honoring the will expressed at the ballot box, but from the flight of the PL’s former presidential candidate from real life.”

A video Eduardo Bolsonaro posted on social media this week captures the dead end into which his family has led Brazil’s right wing. In it, the former congressman shows a document filed with authorities in Texas, where he lives, to make sure his children do not receive a single vaccine.

The vote was a sign that the right wing, once firmly attached to Bolsonarism, is looking for a way out. The distancing is also evident in the disdain with which PL lawmakers received a proposal from the presidents of the Senate and the Chamber of Deputies, Davi Alcolumbre (Brazil Union, UB, Amapá) and Hugo Motta (Republicans of Paraíba), to pass a bill revising sentencing guidelines that would benefit the former president.

Wednesday night’s vote suggests the right is taking a path that lets state governments it elected and the agribusiness sector operate effectively. When exports were exempted from the state-level ICMS tax 30 years ago, the federal government committed to compensating states and municipalities for the lost revenue. The original bill set annual compensation at R$1 billion; the agreement doubled that. Opposition governors were among those who stood to lose the most had no deal been reached: Tarcísio de Freitas (São Paulo), Cleitinho Azevedo (Minas Gerais), and Sergio Moro (Paraná).

On tax credits, the Senate ignored most of the demands of the big holders of these credits in the financial system. The market, estimated at R$200 billion, has grown largely through sales of such credits to banks at discounts of up to 80%, much like the market for court-ordered government debt payments known as precatórios. The only concession came through an amendment by Senator Teresa Cristina (Progressives Party, PP, Mato Grosso do Sul), which mainly benefits agribusiness. It preserves the option of using PIS/Cofins tax credits to settle liabilities under the CBS, a new tax due to take effect in 2027 as part of the tax reform.

The vote also helped contain a setback introduced by an amendment from Senator Eduardo Gomes (Liberal Party, PL, Tocantins), which would have prevented the branches of government from reallocating the savings generated by curbs on excessive public-sector pay. Senator Alessandro Vieira (MDB of Sergipe), long at odds with the government, negotiated an amendment halving the deadline for approving legislation that will finally regulate public-sector pay and bar the resulting savings from being used to create new benefits.

The approval also suggests that the protests of PT members against the fiscal adjustment got more attention than they deserved. The PT was brought into line. That has always been the case and will remain so, at least while Lula is president. The restriction on tax credit compensation that was defeated in 2024 has now passed because the prospect of a new power-sharing arrangement in the federal government has emerged.

Private-sector pressure against the fiscal package did not let up between Tuesday, when votes were lacking, and Wednesday, when there were more than enough. The Senate’s approval suggests a smoother deal is taking shape over the allocation of government posts to the MDB, which led the effort, and to the Centrão, the bloc of centrist and center-right parties that plays a pivotal role in Congress.

According to a senior government interlocutor with close ties to the Centrão, Lula is expected to keep the PT in control of the Planalto Palace and, in social policy, make room not only for the PT but also for longtime allies such as the Brazilian Socialist Party (PSB), Sustainability Network (REDE), and Socialism and Liberty Party (PSOL). In Infrastructure, however, he will have to make concessions. And that is not all.

Expectations that the Chief of Staff Office and the Finance Ministry will be run by such duos as Camilo Santana/Bruno Moretti or Fernando Haddad/Dario Durigan will come under pressure from those who delivered Wednesday’s victory to Lula. Until now, Congress had largely stayed passive in the fight over government appointments. The Chamber of Deputies has yet to vote, but from here on it is clear that lawmakers will no longer sit on the sidelines.

This article was translated from Valor Econômico using an artificial intelligence tool under the supervision of the Valor International editorial team to ensure accuracy, clarity, and adherence to our editorial standards. Read our Editorial Principles.

Original Source
https://valorinternational.globo.com/commentary/maria-cristina-fernandes/commentary/fiscal-package-approval-reinvigorates-push-for-broad-political-alliance.ghtml
Visit G1 Globo ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Politics