Genocide verdict puts Netanyahu on notice - The Telegraph
Benjamin Netanyahu’s coalition lost its majority in the recent general election Credit: AFP via Getty Images/Ilia Yefimovich Paul Nuki in London. Sarah Newey in Bangkok Published 19 November 2026 5:36pm GMT The finding by the world’s top court that the military junta in Myanmar is guilty of genocide will send a shiver through Israel’s legal and military establishment.
No case is directly transferable from one country to another: each is judged on its own merits.
But the legal precedents set in the case against Myanmar are certain to shape the allegations of genocide against Israel over its actions in Gaza following the massacre by Hamas on Oct 7, 2023.
Perhaps it was the Court’s forensic and coldly logical presentation of the 191-page historic judgment, but as it was read out over the course of almost three hours in a hushed courtroom in The Hague, it was impossible not to see parallels.
Unlike other war crimes and crimes against humanity, the crime of genocide hinges on being able to establish “genocidal intent”.
Without it there can be crimes of mass killing, rape and even widespread ethnic cleansing. But there can be no finding of genocide unless those directing the violence “intentionally” planned to destroy a group “in whole or in part”.
Moreover, genocidal motivation must be found to be the “single” reasonable explanation for a defendant state’s actions.
Lawyers in Israel – like most international lawyers – have long stressed how high that bar is, with some believing it was insurmountable without a written document of the “final solution” type filed away by the Nazis.
But Thursday’s judgment by the International Court of Justice (ICJ) blows that assumption out of the water.
Iwasawa Yuji (right) the president of the International Court of Justice, delivers the judgment in the Myanmar genocide case on Thursday Credit: ANP/AFP via Getty Images/Jeroen Jumelet There was no single smoking gun, the court ruled, but a plethora of other “circumstantial evidence” convinced the court by majority verdict of nine to six, that there could be no other explanation for the junta’s actions.
The attack on the Rohingya, which killed 1.2 per cent of the target population and displaced more than 700,000, could not be explained by a counter-insurgency campaign against Rohingya terrorists, as the junta claimed.
The court also rejected a fallback position that it was merely engaging in the sort of “ethnic cleansing” that had been perpetrated against the minority Muslim population in the Balkans in 1995.
Even the idea that the trauma caused by terrorist attacks had prompted an unfortunate wave of revenge “punishment” attacks was dismissed by the court as a reasonable competing reason for what unfolded.
Instead, the longstanding deprivation of rights, the hate speech, the mass killings and rapes, the targeting of children, the bulldozing of villages, the displacement of large parts of the population and the concentration of others into hard-to-reach refugee camps added up to only one reasonable explanation: genocidal intent on the part of the junta and ultimately genocide, the world’s gravest crime.
Rohingya refugees cross from Myanmar into Bangladesh, 2017 Credit: AFP via Getty Images/Fred Dufour “It’s a huge legal benchmark,” Beini Ye, a legal counsel at the Open Society Justice Initiative, told The Telegraph. “[Proving] genocidal intent … has always been a struggle, and is usually the point that is the most contested, legally speaking. The court has now set criteria on how to determine that based on circumstances and context.”
Ms Ye added that recognising sexual violence as a tool of genocide was “groundbreaking”, noting that it is the first time that the ICJ has made that explicit.
The legal precedents set by the Rohingya case with relevance to Israel were not confined to the use of circumstantial evidence to prove intent or the finding that genocidal intent and defensive counterinsurgency actions can co-exist.
The judges utilised evidence from UN investigative bodies rather than waiting for prior criminal convictions and the ruling established that an uninvolved third party – in this case, Gambia – was entitled to bring a case to the court.
The case against Israel for genocide in the occupied territories, including Gaza, has been brought by South Africa, also an uninvolved third party.
The burnt-out remains of a house in Myo Thu Gyi in western Myanmar after the country’s military launched sweeping ‘clearance operations’, 2017 Credit: STR/AFP via Getty Images Prof Nimer Sultany, a law professor at the School of Oriental and African Studies in London, who previously practised human rights law in the Palestinian territories, said on X: “The Court’s application of the law to the facts in Myanmar makes it highly likely it will reach a similar conclusion in the case of Israel, given the scale of its crimes in Gaza.
“I find it particularly significant that the court recounted previous military campaigns starting [in] 1978 by the Myanmar military in its discussion of genocidal intent. As is well known, Israel attacked Gaza several times since 2000.”
The ICJ’s rulings are final and cannot be appealed, but there are already rumblings of overreach.
Vladimir Putin, the Russian president who is also embroiled in a case at the International Court of Justice over the war in Ukraine, warned international courts not to exceed their jurisdiction on Thursday.
In a statement addressing the separate International Criminal Court (ICC) in the Hague, which deals with war crimes and crimes against humanity perpetrated by individuals, Putin warned the court “must not abuse [its] jurisdiction”.
The statement was co-signed by Donald Trump, the US president, and Xi Jinping, the Chinese leader, who were also meeting in Shenzhen, China.
Mr Trump added that the ICC was a “rogue globalist organisation” – one which he has previously vowed to demolish “brick by brick”.
Israel’s ruling coalition government led by Benjamin Netanyahu, who himself is wanted by the ICC for war crimes, has currently only a caretaker role in Israel having lost its majority in the recent general election.
However, the genocide ruling in the ICJ is unlikely to help his main opponent, Gaddi Eisenkot, the former IDF chief, who is now attempting to form a government.
Mr Eisenkot was a member of the Israeli security cabinet during the first year of the war in Gaza, including the period from October to December 2023 when hate speech in Israel was at its height and the daily death toll in Gaza was at its peak.
An analysis in the Jerusalem Post after Thursday’s verdict said parts of the ICJ ruling “have harmed Israel’s ability to mount a defence by lowering the standard of proof needed to be met to determine genocide against a country”.
“Even if portions of the group being attacked have committed acts of terrorism, the counter-attack by the other side can still constitute genocide,” it noted.
Rohingya refugees in Bangladesh react to the verdict Credit: Reuters/Mohammad Ponir Hossain Thousands of miles away in the world’s largest refugee camp, near Cox’s Bazar in Bangladesh, Rohingya refugees watching a livestream of the ICJ ruling on a big screen cheered as the judges delivered their verdict.
“We have all been waiting for this verdict for so long,” said one Rohingya survivor. “We wanted peace for our people through this judgment, and finally we have been heard by the world’s court.”
In Israel and Gaza, most experts say the ICJ is still a decade or more away from making a ruling.
