Google’s refusal to silence Russell Brand tells women all they need to know - The Independent

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from The Independent (independent.co.uk). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Membership today.

Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Membership today.

If you want to watch a video of a rapist and sexual predator taunting the victims of his crimes, then you can – because it’s right there, on YouTube.

And why is it there? Because the tech giant Google has reportedly refused to take it down.

The footage features, of course, the slippery lies of Russell Brand, who was sentenced last week to 10 years and six months in prison for raping one woman and sexually assaulting three others.

Yet still he won’t go quietly. The disgraced former comedian used his wife as a conduit to share a handwritten note from prison claiming he was “not guilty of the offences I have been jailed for”.

“Beloved brothers and sisters in Christ, God bless you for your support,” Laura Brand (née Gallacher) read out on the couple’s YouTube podcast, Sunday Service. “As you know, I am not guilty for the offences I have been jailed for, so something strange is happening.”

The rest is entirely predictable: a lot of blathering about God and a slightly sinister reference to the innocence of his fellow prisoners. Like the conspiracy theorist he is, Brand declares: “I now know that I am in no position to judge anyone. I don’t know which other men here are not guilty.”

The video has caused fierce and understandable outcry from campaigners for women’s safety, and people like Mia Latter, who claims Brand raped her when she was just 16 and is campaigning for a change to consent laws. She said she found it “shocking, upsetting” and “appalling” to hear “this Christian message alongside absolute lies”. “I just felt for those women that stood trial and everything they went through,” she told BBC Radio 4's Today programme.

For more from Vix, sign up to her Independent Women newsletter – a weekly dose of smart, sharp and unflinching stories on the issues that matter most.

The foreign secretary Ed Miliband also said it was “disgusting”, and showed a “revolting lack of remorse”. A Downing Street spokesman condemned the “appalling” message, and said the matter was being “urgently investigated”.

Part of that investigation, we now know, was asking Google, which owns YouTube, to remove the video completely. After Meta took down Brand’s profiles on its platforms, such as Instagram and Facebook, a justice minister is understood to have met Google representatives to make a similar request.

Google says it is investigating – but, days after the clip was posted, it has yet to comply.

Why has the platform refused to delete something that is a clear outrage – a video that the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) has described as “distressing for victims”, that the Prison Service of England and Wales branded “offensive”?

The video clip is certainly popular, reaching 832,000 views, last time I checked. At least Brand won’t be profiting from it financially. In 2023, YouTube prevented him from making money from adverts after "violating" its "creator responsibility policy". So it can intervene in a meaningful way when it likes.

But on this occasion, Google doesn’t seem to like. According to the BBC’s Whitehall sources, requests have apparently been denied because Brand’s prison sermon did not break its terms and conditions. Which, to my mind, shows how little Big Tech really cares about women.

I’m with the MP Jess Phillips, the former parliamentary under-secretary for safeguarding and violence against women and girls, who told the BBC this morning that online regulation simply isn’t robust enough to protect women – and doesn’t put women’s safety at the forefront. The rules, in other words, clearly aren’t good enough. They end up serving men like Russell Brand.

Phillips said the government doesn’t have the power to enforce that this video comes down, but instead relies on platforms like YouTube to do the right thing. “The man is an absolute narcissist,” said Phillips. “If Google wants less regulation, they should take this down. It is distressing to victims.”

She also cautioned that allowing Brand to use YouTube to get his message out from his prison cell has deeply worrying implications: any man with a social media following who goes to jail could follow suit. "This is an entirely new era,” she said. “YouTube isn’t subject to the same rules as other publishers – you’d never get away with playing that video on the BBC.”

The Independent has contacted Google for comment. Meanwhile, the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) said that while it “strongly believes” YouTube should remove this content, removal “ultimately depends on the platform’s own terms”.

I checked on the platform’s terms and conditions: Google says it takes down YouTube videos that violate its community guidelines, breach copyright or other legal obligations, or conflict with its terms of service. However, removal decisions “depend on the specific policy, context and severity, rather than external requests alone”.

Still, according to its own community guidelines, one of the non-negotiables is “harassing content”, with Google claiming “we don’t allow harassment, bullying, or threatening content”; another is content that contains “harmful misinformation”; including manipulated content that “risks real-world harm”. I’d say a convicted rapist taunting his victims by saying he didn’t do anything to them is pretty bullying, harmful misinformation, wouldn’t you?

It all looks a lot like lip service. If Google wants to be the good guy in this age of toxic masculinity and the manosphere; if it wants to take a stand against the proliferation of misogynistic content online – instead of looking like it’s somehow in leagues with today’s “counterculture heroes” like Brand – then it needs to actually do something. Stop the lies. Be the deus ex machina.

At The Independent, our mission is to deliver unbiased, fact-based journalism. Journalism that's free from political allegiances and the influences of shareholders and commercial interests.

But we need your help. Your support enables us to uncover crucial stories that would otherwise have gone untold, hold power to account, and amplify voices often unheard.

Whether $5 or $50, every contribution counts. It fuels our reporting, invests in investigations, and maintains our independence.

It’s a reminder that our trusted, fact-based, free-thinking journalism remains available to everyone thanks to the generosity of our readers. To show your support and help us tell more of the stories that matter, please make a donation today.

Not ready to donate? Choose 'Maybe later' to start reading.

Original Source
https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/russell-brand-laura-wife-google-youtube-remove-video-b3087689.html
Visit The Independent ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Technology