Grand Theft Auto wants to make men better partners – is it a lost cause? - The Independent
Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Membership today.
Grand Theft Auto has never been a franchise that has promoted gender equality. When the last game was released in 2013, there was a mission that involved helping paparazzi upskirt a female celebrity; players were encouraged to buy and run strip clubs, and trysts with sex workers were experienced from a first-person perspective, with players either paying for the service or brutally murdering the woman in order to take their money back. At best, women were on the sidelines. At worst, they were dead.
Nevertheless, as the game returns after 13 years this week, gamers across the UK are pushing wifi servers to their limits, pre-loading Grand Theft Auto 6 onto their consoles. Many are coming down with so-called “GTA flu” to skive off work and school. Among them is The Independent’s own Louis Chilton: “Let the record state that I am NOT a loser,” he says. “What I am is a man, standing in front of my line manager, asking her to grant my annual leave request so I can play a video game.”
When Rockstar revealed GTA 6 would have a female lead called Lucia, after the trailer leaked in 2023, many dubbed it a smokescreen. “I would agree with that,” says Brad Bushman, Professor of Communication at Ohio State University. “Rockstar can say ‘Oh, we’ve been criticised in the past about how we portray female characters in our video games and we’re trying to take a step in the right direction by giving this woman more power’ – but she’s still highly sexualised... I find it troubling that she has more agency and power but looks exactly like all the other female characters. She’s not any different, from my perspective.”
When studying the GTA franchise, Bushman found in research published in 2016 that the game’s mechanics, which rewarded or encouraged violent behaviours towards women, could desensitise players to gendered violence and diminish male players’ empathy for victims. “Participants were shown two photos of an adolescent girl who’d been beaten by an adolescent boy,” he explains. “We found that the more the boys identified with the masculine characters in the game, the less empathy they felt for the woman who was beaten; that was especially true if they had high masculine beliefs.”
This hypermasculinity was measured by asking the boys questions, including whether they believed boys should be encouraged to find a means of demonstrating physical prowess, and if it’s OK for a man to use all means necessary to convince a girl to have sex. Such behaviours, Bushman says, are “very common” in GTA. Notably, although empathy decreased among male participants, this did not hold true for the girls.
“Empathy is one of the best predictors of prosocial behaviour, like helping, sharing, cooperation,” says Bushman. “It’s what makes society a better place. These games reduce empathy because players are forced to adopt the perspective and take the role of the perpetrator – not the victim they robbed, the person they killed, their spouse, or their children.”
While research is still building on whether games like those of the GTA franchise can contribute directly to real-life violence, children as young as six reportedly acted out rape and sex scenes at one primary school in Wales following the release of the previous game – which was rated as 18+ – with some instances on the playground resulting in actual injury. “Players, especially boys, use these video games as scripts for behaviour in their lives,” says Bushman. “They think they’re cool.”
Although some fans have pointed to the fact that Lucia and Jason will send texts and go on dates as a healthier interaction between the sexes, Bushman notes that in the Bonnie and Clyde-inspired crime story, in which “an easy score goes wrong” and the pair are “forced to rely on each other more than ever if they want to make it out alive”, the relationship hinges around armed robbery as much as it does, say, bowling. “They don’t have to go on dates,” the professor says. “They’re connected by crime. The player can decide what they’re going to do.”
Female gamers have been largely excited by Lucia, who’s recently been released from prison and “wants the good life her mom has dreamed of since their days in Liberty City”. On online forums, there’ve even been calls for Rockstar to incorporate the underestimation and belittling that women face in the real world into gameplay for the character to overcome and male players in Lucia’s shoes to experience from her POV.
But even with this design, empathy will still be an uphill battle. Gaming communities frequently intersect with manosphere ideologies and, as such, some GTA players have interpreted Jason as “weak” and “submissive”, while complaining about Lucia’s confidence. “Some people can’t even talk about her character without turning the conversation sexual or fetishising her ethnicity and body,” one person wrote on the Rockstar Reddit thread, where other users dubbed these men incels.
Weeks later, unauthorised, fully nude, gameplay videos of Lucia were leaked online. “Have fun boys,” wrote one user, who was spreading the footage beneath various threads. “Ugly b****”, another responded.
So, will the addition of this female protagonist aid empathy towards women among gamers? Based on the violent rhetoric, objectification, humiliation, and sexism already aimed at Lucia, it’s not looking likely.
And the next few days (weeks?) of gameplay aren’t looking so fun for some women in the real world, either. Take, say, the wife and daughter of 38-year-old Sean Little, who has drawn up a contract for his family allowing him to take over their lounge to play GTA for a week.
“We’re not allowed to ask him to do any sort of household chores,” his wife Natalie told BBC Scotland News. “We’re not allowed to make any comments of how long he's been playing it for, any comments about him being lazy because he's not moved off the couch for hours.”
Natalie confirmed that although her husband will give her some money to buy extra snacks, he won’t be making any meals. Little has also purchased paper plates so he won’t be asked to clean the dishes. “Literally he will be in here playing it, and that's all he's going to do,” Natalie said.
"I don’t care what people think,” Little responded to brewing criticism over the contract. “My family are happy, I’m happy,” he claimed. “As long as my bubble are happy, who cares what anybody else thinks?”


