Gregor Chisholm: How does Addison Barger fit with the Blue Jays eyeing Seiya Suzuki and Teruaki Sato? - Toronto Star
Barger's versatility after a lost 2026 could mean the Jays pursue Jazz Chisholm Jr. or Ketel Marte.
Addison Barger has barely played for the Blue Jays since their run to the 2025 World Series, where he launched a grand slam homer in Game 1 at the Rogers Centre.
Gregor Chisholm is a Toronto-based baseball columnist for the Star. Follow him on X: @GregorChisholm or reach him via email: gchisholm@thestar.ca.
The Blue Jays pitching staff was ravaged by injuries throughout the 2026 season, but on the position player side they escaped relatively unscathed with one glaring exception: Addison Barger.
Barger entered this year with high expectations. One season prior, he had been cut from the 26-man roster at the end of spring training before getting called up and becoming a key contributor on a team that went to the World Series.
The hope was that Barger would build on the success that saw him hit 21 home runs with a well-above-average .756 on-base-plus-slugging percentage. His continued growth, combined with the free-agent signing of Kazuma Okamoto, was supposed to help make up for the departure of Bo Bichette in free agency and regression elsewhere in the lineup.
Okamoto followed through on his end of the deal by slugging 33 homers; Barger didn’t hit any. He appeared in just nine games before injuring his elbow on a throw from right field. After an initial rehab attempt, he had season-ending elbow surgery in July.
The 27-year-old Barger is still working his way back from that surgery and he’s expected to be ready in spring training. However, his role is far from certain after a year away. Thankfully for the Jays, his proven versatility gives them options.
If the Jays sign Seiya Suzuki or Teruaki Sato in free agency, they could put them in left or right field. Barger would remain in the mix for both spots while also being able to move over to third base whenever Okamoto starts at designated hitter or needs a day off.
The Jays could instead opt to target a high-end middle infielder such as free-agent Jazz Chisholm Jr. or Ketel Marte of the Arizona Diamondbacks. That would still leave Ernie Clement and Josh Smith available off the bench, meaning almost all of Barger’s playing time would come in the outfield.
“We have some versatility, we have the ability to move some guys around, which we’ve worked hard to accomplish,” Jays general manager Ross Atkins said last week when asked about his preference to add: infielder or outfielder.
“We don’t want to put ourselves into a box. I think the more natural fit right now as we stand is in the outfield, but don’t feel like it has to be there by any means.”
Barger’s skill set is similar to one of the Jays’ top free-agent targets.
Sato, much like Barger, has a lot of power and swing-and-miss in his game. Inside the Jays organization there is a belief that Sato has more upside and could hit more home runs, but there is a greater variance in his projections without big-league experience.
Barger is the better defender and more of a known commodity thanks to his 2025 season, but it’s still a short track record and his injury history creates further risk.
If the Jays sign Sato, one scenario would see the pair regularly in the lineup at the same time to maximize power. Another would see Barger traded this off-season to fill a different area of need.
It would be an odd time to move Barger, considering his value has dipped quite a bit, but that stance could change with the right offer. One team worth monitoring is the Diamondbacks, who are shopping Marte and have a need for lefty bats.
“I think the industry has gotten pretty good at understanding what that missed time means, objectively and subjectively,” Atkins said earlier this off-season when asked about injured players. “Their starting point takes a bit of a hit, but it’s not detrimental by any means.”
There is only a small handful of impact bats available and the Jays need to do whatever possible to land at least one, preferably two, to upgrade an anemic lineup that scored the fewest runs in MLB.
Some young players would be squeezed out after missing 153 games, but Barger should be able to carve out a role no matter who the Jays add this off-season. And if for some reason he can’t, he should still have enough trade value to help in other ways.
In other words, Barger’s value isn’t limited to next year. He will be a focal point of the off-season, too.
Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request.
There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again.
You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply.
Opinion articles are based on the author’s interpretations and judgments of facts, data and events. More details
Gregor Chisholm is a Toronto-based baseball columnist for the Star. Follow him on X: @GregorChisholm or reach him via email: gchisholm@thestar.ca.