Have we reached our limit with saccharine middle-class Christmas adverts? - The Independent
Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Membership today.
I have nothing against Keira Knightley, Lucy Punch, or Kristin Scott Thomas. In fact, I would say I actively like all of these actors in the correct context, whether that be indiscriminately assassinating people in Netflix’s Black Doves or desperately trying to gentrify “SoHa” – South Harlesden – in the BBC’s Amandaland.
Yet their combined appearance in the obligatory lineup of “heartwarming” Christmas adverts for the UK’s mega brands, which have clearly commandeered the lion’s share of the entire year’s marketing budgets, feels simply too smugly middle-class to bear in 2026.
If you’ve managed to make it to this point in November without seeing these ads – and genuine congratulations if you have – a quick recap.
John Lewis – the “OG” when it comes to showing us the “real” meaning of Christmas while simultaneously peddling expensive luxury wares to the backdrop of an anguished cover song – has Scott Thomas as a glamorous (and minted) gran who transforms one of the numerous spare rooms in her massive Boomer home into a sumptuous disco party den for two rambunctious – and frankly ungrateful – grandchildren.
M&S has plumped for Lucy Punch and fellow actor James Norton as a plummy young Mr and Mrs Claus; she convinces him to shave off the beard and, suddenly unrecognisable (and – well I never! – extremely handsome), he heads into the world to experience Christmas incognito. There, he discovers that the holiday season is really all about choirs of saccharine, singing children, spending time with friends and, of course, scarfing down overpriced mini vol-au-vents while decked out in a full range of bejewelled Marks and Sparks partywear.
And then there’s Waitrose’s ad, which, at a whopping 5 minutes and 50 seconds, is practically a short film. The yummy mummy supermarket of the upper classes has created a sequel to last year’s Love Actually-style romcom featuring Knightley and comedian Joe Wilkinson, throwing in a wedding to Rivals’s uber-cad Alex Hassell that must be stopped at the last minute by a well-timed beef Wellington.
In and of themselves, there’s nothing necessarily wrong with these whimsical, if cloying, adverts – apart from the last example technically being a sequel advertisement. In any case, the concept of corporations whipping up our festive feelings in a calculated effort to encourage us to empty our pockets in the lead-up to the most highly commercialised festival of the year is nothing new.
But there’s something about them when all stacked up together, en masse, that sticks in one’s craw. As my colleague Katie Rosseinsky so perfectly put it when writing about the John Lewis ad: “In a winter where we’re all wondering how the hell we’re going to heat the homes that we can barely afford to rent or pay the mortgage on, or being told to stock up on tinned foods in case of apocalypse, this one feels utterly out of step with the nation’s mood.”
That’s the feeling they engender across the board. This year in particular, that gap between our grim reality and the aspirational Christmas being touted on TV – one in which the stakes are so low as to be non-existent, and everyone has endless cash to splash on bags stuffed with high-end appetisers, bougie homeware and chic new outfits – seems so wide it should come with a vertigo warning.
Sure, the marketing execs couldn’t have known, back when they were creating these benign slices of festive fluff, that their releases would end up coinciding with the UK entertainment industry’s own “MeToo” moment. But they probably could have sensed the national temperature might have plummeted significantly in the past 12 months: the threat of war looming, the government instructions to prep for power cuts and internet outages, the onslaught of AI data centres and the ever-worsening effects of climate change are enough to make anyone feel a bit “bah humbug” this year. Or, indeed, just plain terrified.
So if the out-of-reach middle-class excess of it all is getting to you this year, just know you’re not alone. And if the only way to get through the festive period is to shout incomprehensibly at the telly and change the channel the second you hear the grating sound of children’s voices singing Sam Fender’s “You Can’t Always Get What You Want” – well, perhaps that’s the real meaning of Christmas, after all.
