High interest rates limit returns on pastureland restoration, BCG says - Valor International
Only 2 million hectares of degraded pastureland out of the 23.7 million that Boston Consulting Group (BCG) identified as having restoration potential in Brazil’s Cerrado tropical savanna can generate sufficient financial returns to justify investment under current credit conditions, without the need for additional subsidies.
Project seeks greater efficiency in Cerrado coffee farmingBTG raises $1.24bn for reforestation fund, prioritizes CerradoGreen finance plan sees second loan for pasture recovery
That is equivalent to 8.4% of the area mapped by the consultancy. Cerrado is mainly located in the center of Brazil. High financing costs and heightened risks associated with agricultural activities are limiting progress in pastureland restoration. The figures are part of BCG’s study, “What Would It Take for Land Restoration to Take Off in Brazil?”
According to the consultancy, these 2 million hectares are located on large properties with established livestock operations and pastures showing intermediate levels of degradation.
“In addition to [financial] returns, it is always important to consider the risk involved in making these investments, because when costs become tighter, the equation can change,” said Matheus Munhoz, head of BCG’s agribusiness and sustainability practices.
Investments in areas requiring restoration have a payback period of eight to 10 years, depending on the size of the property, Munhoz said. Making the investment case work, in turn, depends on some form of credit incentive, whether concessional capital [with lower interest rates or a greater willingness to assume risk] or government-funded investment, as in the case of EcoInvest.
This is the first time since BCG began its historical data series in 2014 that the restoration of degraded pastures has been considered unfeasible for a large share of projects when both financial returns and investment risk are taken into account. According to BCG, the problem lies not in the profitability of the activities themselves, but in investors’ perception of risk.
BCG estimates that each percentage-point reduction in interest rates would, on average, save approximately R$7 billion in support funding.
“Perhaps the exercise is to look inward and see how the environment for these long-term investments itself can be made healthier, so that all these investment opportunities in land restoration can be realized,” Munhoz said.
BCG estimates that restoring the 23.7 million hectares could generate R$308 billion in economic activity. Of that total, only R$30 billion corresponds to projects offering sufficient financial returns to pay for themselves under current credit conditions, while the remaining R$278 billion falls short of the required profitability and would need some form of financial support to become viable.
If interest rates fell to more favorable levels, the consultancy estimates that up to two-thirds of the investments could become economically viable without additional subsidies.
However, the study points to an imbalance between large and small producers. On properties smaller than 50 hectares, only one-seventh of the areas would be able to pay for themselves, even with lower-cost credit.
