How Experts Value Category-Defining Domains In Emerging Industries
Michael Gargiulo, CEO of VPN.com. We help Fortune 1000, entrepreneurs and companies protect their brand.
gettyA domain is only worth what the market powering it can support. This means that sometimes the same naming qualities that yield a modest valuation in smaller industries can create a seven-figure opportunity for a strategic property, generating awareness and attracting serious buyers.
Because of this, valuation can be difficult for various emerging sectors. A few examples include artificial intelligence (AI), financial technology (FinTech) and health technology. These categories are emerging industries featuring rapidly expanding disruptive technologies. While some category-defining domain names will assuredly become tomorrow’s durable digital assets, some will prove to be mere expensive bets that the language market later drops.
For executives, founders and decision-makers considering a major domain name purchase, the challenge lies in separating scarcity from speculation or emotional attachment while understanding the true value any potential domain offers your brand.
A strong category-defining domain name conveys a clear message about the services a company offers before a visitor ever clicks through to its website. Short and memorable .coms that are tied directly to products, services or market terminology already have an innate advantage: Some are used as brand names and have years of advertising behind them.
An exact-match domain alone, however, is rarely the sole signifier value. Buyers also need to consider the commercial size of the industry at hand, how many companies are competing to acquire the domain, the commercial intent it offers visitors, the underlying linguistics and the potential depth of the pool of interested buyers first.
For example, a great domain in a market with five plausible buyers has different economics than a name in a market where 500 funded companies could eventually want it. This is the biggest difference you will find between rarity and useful scarcity. Serious buyers pay for the second.
AI’s massive growth is a great example of this opportunity and risk, and newer companies are being built around models, agents, infrastructure, security, data and industry-specific applications with this in mind. A clean category name can give a company instant clarity in a crowded market, but fast-moving terminology can also create speculative pricing. In short, a term that looks essential this year may become obsolete as the category matures.
FinTech domains require a different lens. This is because financial businesses depend heavily on trust. A strong online identity can make a company easier to remember and appear more established, which raises the strategic value of an authoritative domain. Regulation, however, can narrow the number of companies capable of monetizing a particular category.
Health tech is another category worth consideration, where consumers exercise more caution than they would with other types of browsing activity. While clear naming can improve brand trust, specialized categories in the medical field will have trimmer pools of would-be buyers than what you’d find in tech markets.
A common beginner’s mistake in domain valuation is comparing the asking price to market evidence of value. They are not one and the same. For example, an owner may request $3 million for a domain, but this doesn’t mean there is a buyer willing to pay that. Rather, asking prices are better viewed as subjective offers that reflect expectations, futures or even emotional attachment. Typically, they are negotiation tools intended to secure the best possible final price.
A better place to look when determining valuation is in completed transactions. Much like real estate agents compare recent sale prices for similar homes in a market before determining a list price, the same is true for domain name valuations. Studying comparable sales with a similar niche, wording, extension or application can help paint a picture of the actual perceived value of any domain name being offered in the seven-figure category.
That changes the valuation question. Stop only asking, “What is this domain worth?” Executives should also ask, “What is controlling this asset worth to our company compared to operating without it?” The answer can be substantially different.
The best advice I can offer any leader in this industry is to build out a range before you negotiate. This is what today’s leading domain name brokers do before they ever place an offer or bid. Start by assessing the immediate market, the inherent demand, the domain’s SEO and brand value and its potential to impact your enterprise in the long run. Next, compare historical transactions to determine if the numbers can add up in the long term for your brand.
Along the way, consider consulting with a domain advisor. They can help you better understand how the market works so you can narrow your options and make a well-informed decision.
Emerging industries will continue creating valuable digital real estate, along with plenty of pricing noise. The winners won’t simply be the companies willing to pay the highest asking price. Instead, they’ll be the ones that know which names can strengthen their market position, what those assets are actually worth and when ownership justifies the price.
Forbes Technology Council is an invitation-only community for world-class CIOs, CTOs and technology executives. Do I qualify?
