How investing in property became ‘an absolute disaster’ - The Telegraph
Melissa Lawford has been part of the economics team since 2023 and spent a year in DC covering the US economy under Donald Trump. Before that, she was property correspondent for three and a half years. Email her at melissa.lawford@telegraph.co.uk or find her on X @MelissaLawford
Climbing on to the property ladder in 2016 felt like a sure-fire route to financial prosperity.
“At that time, there was a queue of nine or 10 people at every viewing in London and afterwards there were effectively auctions outside with the agent,” says Joe, now 37, who works as a consultant.
He purchased a one-bedroom flat in Greenwich, south-east London, for £280,000.
“I felt I had to do it,” he said. “I was at the limit of my affordability and I thought the opportunity would slip away if I didn’t do it. I assumed I would be able to move on quickly.”
After all, the UK housing market had made generations of homeowners eye-wateringly wealthy. Across the 20 years from 1996 to 2016, the value of a typical UK home had surged by no less than 124pc above the rate of inflation, Nationwide data shows.
But Joe did not benefit. After a decade of mortgage repayments and renovations, he sold his flat earlier this year for £270,000 – a £10,000 loss.
The UK property market has turned. High mortgage rates, squeezed affordability, glacial income growth, successive increases in stamp duty and a buy-to-let crackdown are rapidly eroding what has historically been Britain’s favourite investment.
At a headline level, official figures show national house prices rose by 1.2pc year on year in September, but this masks massive variations. The prices of flats are falling across the country. In inner London, sale prices plummeted by 7.2pc, the biggest drop since 2009. Many analysts are expecting price declines to spread across the country in the months ahead.
There is already a wider national downturn that the headline figures mask. Nationwide figures show that, after adjusting for inflation, the value of a typical UK home is now worth less than it was 24 years ago.
Real-terms house prices have shed £63,000 in the last five years, according to the building society, a loss of 19pc since the most recent market peak in 2021.
Lower house prices relative to earnings will ease affordability strains and improve access to housing, says David Miles, a professor of financial economics at Imperial College London. But the transition to a new reality of lower property wealth will bring some economic pain.
Falling house prices hurt consumer confidence and put people off selling. Fewer housing transactions mean lower stamp duty receipts for the public purse.
But it is those who scraped together enough to buy their first homes five to 10 years ago who are suffering the most.
“It is young people, maybe newly middle-class people whose parents didn’t have much money, who get punished for this,” says Joe. “People in their 30s are cash cows for banks.”
He adds: “I pay so much tax. I just don’t really understand what I’m paying in for. I don’t get anything out of the system at all.”
Many first-time homeowners are facing even bigger losses than Joe.
Tom purchased a new-build, two-bedroom flat in south London in April 2017 for £505,000. Nine years later, he is just about to sell it for £360,000.
Including the stamp duty bill he paid in 2017 (before the first-time buyer exemption was introduced), his total cash loss on the property will be more than £160,000.
Tom, not his real name, is able to move on because he had purchased the property without a mortgage with financial help from his parents. But this doesn’t make up for the fact that the money has simply disappeared.
“My father is absolutely furious. I think he’s upset with himself for letting me buy this type of property rather than a more traditional one,” says Tom.
“Most of the money came from his hard work and earnings over the last 50 years. As an investment, it has been an absolute disaster.”
The epicentre of this crisis is in London. Nationally, flat prices dropped by 2.3pc year on year in September. In inner London, they plummeted by 8.5pc.
One very big problem is high mortgage rates. Between February 2022 and October 2023, during the post-pandemic cost of living crisis, the average rate for a buyer taking out a two-year fixed-rate loan soared from 1.56pc to 5.51pc. Rates had been coming down before the war in Iran erupted at the end of February.
Guy Gittins, the chief executive of Foxtons, London’s biggest estate agent, says: “There was a lot of pent-up demand. Then literally overnight the confidence that was building in the market just drained out, almost instantly.”
Two-year rates are now at 4.72pc, roughly triple where they were four years ago. Soaring oil prices and fears of a fresh inflation wave pushed the Bank of England to raise interest rates to 4pc in November, the first rise in more than three years.
Higher mortgage rates have hammered affordability. Before the pandemic, 27pc of a buyer’s monthly income went on mortgage payments on average, according to Capital Economics. This has now jumped to 38pc.
First-time buyers, who are more inclined to be purchasing flats, are most affected because many are already stretching themselves financially.
Yet it is not just first-time buyers being stung by the slump in flat prices. Another group that traditionally made up a large share of flat purchasers was buy-to-let investors. Instead of buying, this group has been selling in the wake of a decades-long buy-to-let crackdown, which has accelerated following Labour’s introduction of the Renters’ Rights Act, tightening regulation on the sector.
Dominic Agace, the chief executive of Winkworth estate agents, says: “Landlords were such a significant part of the flat market since the 1990s. There has been a huge change, a big reorganisation of that sector. Now buy-to-let investors coming to our offices are a rare and endangered species.”
On top of all this, high-rise flats have been embroiled in the building safety crisis that erupted in the wake of the tragic Grenfell fire in 2017. Many homeowners are unable to sell until remediation works have been completed, while those in unaffected blocks have to provide vast amounts of paperwork to prove they are not caught up in the crisis. Many others are also affected by onerous leasehold terms.
Tom’s building does not have cladding problems, but the service charge on his flat has increased from £2,500 per year to £4,500 since he purchased. “The Government is pushing all of this stuff about how much they care about young people and buying new homes. But there is no regulation behind this at all,” he says.
New-build flats already typically come with a premium that is lost on resale and their sellers are often competing with a swathe of other people in the block who are choosing to move at the same time.
Adam Jennings, at Chestertons estate agents, says: “There’s more supply in London than there has been for something like 15 years. That creates an awful lot of choice for people.
“If you are trying to sell, standing out in the market is very difficult unless you reduce your price quite substantially.”
Reductions of 5pc or 10pc on flats are common, says Jeremy Leaf, a north London estate agent. He notes a flat that was first listed at £370,000 was later reduced to £345,000 and has now gone under offer at £330,000.
London flats might be on the sharp end, but evidence of the property downturn can be found nationwide.
Adam Horton, founder of Hortons estate agents, which operates outside London, says: “Every deal at the moment seems incredibly fragile.”
One client selling a home in Leicester for around £1m has agreed a sale no less than four times over the past 18 months and each has fallen through, says Horton.
“Each of those was because of funding-related problems. They are stuck in a loop of buyers that just aren’t coming up trumps with the money.”
Another buyer purchased a bungalow in Leicester 18 months ago for £550,000 but had to relocate 18 months later. “They sold it for £500,000. Taking a £50,000 hit was what was required for them to stimulate a quicker sale.”
According to Nationwide, which measures house prices based on mortgage approvals data, values have slumped by 1.1pc since their peak in April. Capital Economics expects they will fall by another 0.4pc in the months ahead.
Simon Rubinsohn, the chief economist at the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors, says: “When you have something that is so built around leverage, what is happening with interest rates has an impact.”
While few economists are forecasting dramatic house price falls in cash terms, the outlook for real values is a different story.
Even once the inflation surge triggered by war in Iran has receded, interest rates are expected to remain materially higher than they were before the pandemic.
A key reason for the heady pace of property price growth in the years before Joe and Tom purchased their first homes was that, for 13 years after the financial crisis, UK interest rates were below 1pc. During Covid, it was 0.1pc.
Miles says: “People came to see getting a mortgage with a 2pc interest rate on it as the new normal. But the world has moved on and away from where we were and it may be that we don’t go back to those days.”
The Bank of England will eventually cut interest rates again, but it is reluctant to take them below 3pc unless there is a major economic shock, says Rubinsohn. “I think the property market is probably in for a more subdued period.”
Geoff Meen, a professor emeritus at the University of Reading, argues that there is another big structural shift that bodes badly for real home values.
“One of the key determinants of house prices is real household disposable income,” says Meen.
As inflation erodes people’s spending power, they have less to spend on mortgage payments. This limits what they can afford to buy.
Real disposable income growth this decade is the lowest on record, according to the Institute for Fiscal Studies. “That is absolutely crucial,” Meen says.
The Resolution Foundation predicts that real household disposable income will rise by just 1.4pc across this decade. This will be a tenth of the 14pc rise recorded across the 2010s.
“You’re going to have slow growth in house prices unless something really odd happens. It wouldn’t be surprising if there is no recovery in real house prices, at least in the short term,” says Meen.
In the longer term, lower real house prices will be a good thing for the UK economy, says Miles.
Soaring house prices in proportion to earnings have benefited older homeowners but have blocked many younger people from getting on to the ladder at all, unless they have help from parents who benefited from the boom.
“When you partially reverse that, as we have seen more recently, with house prices falling relative to prices, that shouldn’t be viewed as some kind of economic failure. That is making housing more affordable for people who have been squeezed out,” says Miles.
But this shift will bring some “transitional harm”, he says.
Falling house prices will initially mean fewer transactions, as sellers hold back. “That is unhelpful because it clogs up mobility in the economy,” says Miles. People find it harder to move for work.
There is also a clear correlation between lower house prices and lower levels of construction, says Meen. Developers build based on their ability to sell at a profitable level. Lower real prices therefore bode badly for the Government’s housebuilding targets.
It is also possible that there could be a kind of reverse wealth effect. When house prices are rising, homeowners feel richer and are more able to borrow against their homes, which boosts their spending power. If values are falling, they may be less confident or able to spend.
And there is an impact on the public finances. Lower house prices affect stamp duty, capital gains tax (CGT) and inheritance tax (IHT), says Stuart Adam, a senior economist at the IFS.
While the bulk of most people’s homes are exempt from IHT and main residences are also exempt from CGT, these taxes still apply to rental properties and second homes. A 1pc fall in house prices would lead to £272m in lost stamp duty by 2029-30, a £137m hit to IHT income and £74m less CGT, according to estimates based on Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) figures.
Because stamp duty rates are higher for higher priced properties, the tax is hugely dependent on sales in London and the South East.
The current downturn in these markets has already prompted the OBR to cut its forecasts for stamp duty receipts. In October, it downgraded its assumptions for property transaction tax receipts in 2026-27 by £3.2bn, or 16pc, compared to its March predictions.
Miles argues that, if real-terms prices adjust and homes become more affordable, transactions will rise as the housing market becomes accessible to more people. This could eventually bring higher stamp duty receipts further down the line.
But Joe, for one, has little interest in trying to buy a home again.
“I’m going to keep my money in Isas and stocks and shares,” he says.
“I fundamentally feel that the social contract with millennials is broken. If you don’t have family help, it is almost impossible to get to a position where you have assets, it doesn’t matter what you earn.
“I’m thinking quite hard about leaving the UK. I just don’t really see what the point is.”
