How the EU succeeded where Britain failed with Rwanda deal - The Telegraph

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from The Telegraph (telegraph.co.uk). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
James Rothwell in Berlin. Joe Barnes Diplomatic Editor. James Crisp Europe Editor. Henry Samuel in Paris. Ben Farmer Africa Correspondent Published 20 November 2026 5:00am GMT It was Boris Johnson’s white whale: the elusive deportation plan that would have shipped asylum seekers ...

James Rothwell in Berlin. Joe Barnes Diplomatic Editor. James Crisp Europe Editor. Henry Samuel in Paris. Ben Farmer Africa Correspondent Published 20 November 2026 5:00am GMT It was Boris Johnson’s white whale: the elusive deportation plan that would have shipped asylum seekers off to Rwanda and allowed Britain to take back control of its borders.

The “Rwanda model” was the stuff that dreams were made of for Mr Johnson and his Brexiteers. But British judges quickly tore the plan apart before Labour abandoned it in 2024.

Only two years later, the failed Rwanda scheme has taken on a new life in a strange place indeed – the EU.

Germany and four other EU countries announced their own version this week. Nicknamed “Rwanda-lite”, the scheme will send failed asylum seekers to deportation centres in the African nation and is expected to be in operation by next year.

It is a surprising new lease of life for the Rwanda model, which faced miles of red tape and technical issues before British judges dismantled it over human rights concerns.

Here The Telegraph examines how the EU succeeded in reviving Britain’s failed Rwanda deal and whether the UK can get involved as part of Andy Burnham’s Brexit reset project.

Under Mr Johnson’s plan, migrants arriving in Britain on small boats were to be sent straight to Rwanda before their complaints could be heard in British courts.

They would have had their asylum claims processed in Rwanda before being potentially resettled in the east African country. In other words, the British version of the scheme would have essentially transferred responsibility for the asylum seekers to the Rwandan government.

Even if an asylum seeker’s case was ruled to be genuine, they would have had to live in Rwanda and could never come to Britain. The thinking at the time was that this would strongly deter migrants from making the perilous Channel crossing.

Wary of the legal headache this approach faced, the five EU member states championing a European version of the Rwanda scheme have opted for a much narrower approach.

Under their model, only failed asylum seekers living illegally in Europe will be sent to Rwanda.

The five European nations – Germany, Austria, Greece, Denmark and the Netherlands – will screen the failed asylum seekers and deport only those deemed not at risk of being persecuted. The plan has the approval of Brussels but is not an EU-wide scheme.

EU law was changed this year to allow failed asylum seekers in Europe to be sent to hubs in third countries and be deported from there. Beforehand, they could be sent only to the last safe country they were in or their home country.

It is understood that the scheme will not target migrants from countries where their human rights would be abused if they returned, such as Afghanistan.

Germany’s government has asserted that the Rwanda-lite model is being drawn up “in line with EU, Rwandan and international law, including international human rights law”.

It added in a recent statement: “The return hub will only be used for migrants who are staying illegally in one of the five EU member states and are subject to an enforceable return or removal decision.”

The EU’s plan is similar to Britain’s abandoned scheme to send migrants to Rwanda Credit: NurPhoto/Nicolas Economou But other senior EU member states who are not taking part in the project, such as France, are concerned that it goes against the fundamental values of the EU.

As one French diplomatic source told The Telegraph: “France considers that these hubs are not effective and do not comply with the principles upon which Europe was founded.”

The same source went on to stress that, even though the scheme had been created by EU member states, there could be no use of EU funding to implement it.

On legal issues, it is worth recalling how bullish Mr Johnson’s government was about their version of the Rwanda model before it unravelled.

The Telegraph understands that British participation in the new Rwanda return hubs scheme could form part of Mr Burnham’s “Brexit reset” talks with the EU.

Friday’s summit in Brussels will call for deeper cooperation on fighting illegal immigration, particularly in the Channel. The Prime Minister also wants better access to EU criminal justice databases.

Britain lost real-time access to those systems after Brexit, in part because of Germany’s sensitivities over data protection.

“Datenschutz” is very important in Germany after its experience of both Nazi and Stasi snooping during the Second World War and the Cold War. Berlin ended a Cold War spy pact with Britain and the US after the Edward Snowden scandal in 2013.

Fears that Brexit Britain could share data with the US were influential in Brussels insisting that cooperation had to be more at arm’s length.

However, The Telegraph understands that the German government will not oppose any relaxation of EU rules aimed at tackling illegal migration and improving coordination in response to hybrid threats from Russia.

Asked whether Britain could take part in “Rwanda 2.0”, one European source replied: “Why not?”

The Telegraph understands that EU capitals would expect the UK to join the EU’s new asylum and migration pact first.

That would require Britain to take in genuine refugees from overburdened nations such as Italy and Greece, or pay €20,000 (£16,800) for each rejected person.

At the same time, if the UK joins the EU’s asylum pact, it would finally secure the legal right to send asylum seekers back to the bloc, which Britain has wanted since the early days of the Brexit negotiations.

Britain left the EU’s Dublin III Regulation, meaning it has no legal basis to return small-boat migrants to the bloc.

A pilot “one in, one out” deal with France is also coming to an end, with Paris demanding it be replaced with an EU-wide agreement.

Other bilateral deals have been hard to strike and there is a lack of political will among many capitals to agree to a bloc-wide deal.

The Rwandan government seems to be very pleased that EU member states have tried to revive aspects of Mr Johnson’s deal.

It is worth noting that, under the British version of the Rwanda model, Kigali had been set to receive a payment of £120m in addition to covering costs of relocation and accommodation.

The scrapping of the deal strained relations with Kigali, which then unsuccessfully tried to sue London for compensation.

Although the UK deal collapsed, Rwanda’s preparations and enthusiasm at the time positioned it as a leading contender for any other country seeking somewhere to send its migrants.

Hope Hostel was one of the sites in Rwanda where illegal immigrants in the UK would have been deported to Credit: PA A government source in Kigali told Agence France-Presse (AFP) earlier this week that the Gashora transit centre, some 37 miles from the capital, which had lately been used for asylum seekers from Libya and had been recently expanded, was likely to be used.

The EU countries have already said they will not use the facility set up for Britain under its aborted deal, although another government source hinted that it could be in the frame.

However, Elisée Kalyango, who manages asylum affairs for the Rwandan government, told AFP that it was still too early to announce the details.

“Among the things to figure out are their housing and how their other needs will be taken care of,” he said.

“Government learned a lot from the previous asylum deal with the UK, and all the lessons will inform us how the EU asylum seekers will be handled.”

Original Source
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2026/11/20/how-eu-revived-britains-failed-rwanda-deal/
Visit The Telegraph ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Technology