ICC prosecutor opposes ‘reframed’ charges vs Duterte
MANILA, Philippines — The International Criminal Court (ICC) prosecutor has opposed the defense’s request to reframe the crimes against humanity charges against former president Rodrigo Duterte, saying the issues it raised had already been settled during the confirmation proceedings.
In a 10-page response, ICC acting prosecutor Mame Mandiaye Niang urged Trial Chamber III to dismiss the motion filed by Duterte’s defense questioning the form of the charges.
Defense lawyer Peter Haynes, in a motion dated Aug. 31, argued that the original document containing the charges, or DCC, “is not fit for purpose and should be struck out.”
Haynes said the charges were improperly framed by grouping the alleged crimes under three topical headings, supposedly violating Duterte’s right to be informed in detail of the nature, cause and content of the charges against him.
The defense asked Trial Chamber III to direct the ICC prosecutor to file an updated DCC before the Pre-Trial Chamber that confirmed the charges against Duterte.
Niang, however, said the defense failed to distinguish between the legal adequacy of the charges and the accused’s right to notice.
He also said many of the defense’s arguments had already been addressed during the confirmation proceedings.
“Questions as to the form of charges are a matter for confirmation proceedings, not trial. The defense fully participated in the substantive proceedings to confirm the charges, up to and including seeking leave (unsuccessfully) to appeal the Pre-Trial Chamber’s confirmation decision on the issue of the form of the charges,” Niang wrote.
Duterte is facing crimes against humanity charges involving three sets of alleged incidents: murders in Davao from 2013 to 2016, murders of high-value targets from 2016 to 2017 and murders and attempted murders linked to barangay operations from 2016 to 2018.
Niang rejected the defense’s criticisms of how the charges were structured, saying the three counts “each have a clear temporal, geographical and material scope.”
On the issue of notice, Niang maintained that the prosecution had provided the defense with sufficient information about the incidents and victims that would be covered during the trial.
“The prosecution has duly provided sufficient notice of all the relevant incidents and victims, both through the information provided in the course of confirmation proceedings but also through auxiliary pre-trial documents such as the trial brief,” he added.
Duterte’s trial is expected to begin on Nov. 30.
abtestabtest What Supreme Court's Imelda Marcos acquittal means, and what it doesn't 2 days ago The Supreme Court has overturned Imelda Marcos' seven-count graft conviction over foundations tied to the Marcos family's... Headlines Cayetano siblings return from Singapore By Ian Laqui | 10 hours ago Alan arrived at Ninoy Aquino International Airport on the evening of September 12, three days after leaving the country.... Headlines Senate: 11 votes, not 10, needed on threshold By Marc Jayson Cayabyab | 22 hours ago The Senate impeachment court will need 11 votes from the active roster of 20 senator-judges to overturn the ruling setting... Headlines PNP: VP should substantiate claims on threats By Emmanuel Tupas | 22 hours ago Vice President Sara Duterte should substantiate her allegations that she has been receiving threats to her security since... Headlines Marcos arrives in India for BRICS Summit, seeks stronger ties By Kristine Daguno-Bersamina | 1 day ago President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. arrived in New Delhi, India on Friday night to attend the 18th BRICS Summit and meet with Indian... Headlines Latest More in Headlines 2026 Bar exams enter final day; results due in January 41 more bodies found aboard burned Coron ferry, toll now at 76 Ferry fire death toll rises to 76 Romualdez taken to PGH for independent medical check abtest P31.2 billion available to fill 64,530 teaching posts – DBM 22 hours ago The Department of Education and Department of Budget and Management have clarified reports that the proposed 2027... Headlines Leptospirosis cases still high By Rhodina Villanueva | 22 hours ago There is still a high admission of leptospirosis cases at the San Lazaro Hospital, with the majority of cases already in the... Headlines Robinsons Land, MMDA enhance mobility across key Metro Manila routes 22 hours ago Robinsons Land Corp. has strengthened its support for urban mobility through its partnership with the MMDA Love Bus program,... Headlines ‘Elyu’ rides Trabaho at Negosyo wave 22 hours ago Inclement weather did not stop the entrepreneurs of La Union from trooping to SM City La Union yesterday to participate in... Headlines Recommended Palasyo: VP Sara gusto agad umupo kaya pinagbibitiw si Pangulong Marcos 22 hours ago Binuweltahan ng Malacañang si Vice President Sara Duterte matapos nitong atakihin at manawagan ng pagbibitiw ni Pangulong... HeadlinesMALACAñANG Voting treshold sa VP Sara impeachment trial dapat mas mababa sa 13 – Calleja 22 hours ago Iginiit ni Atty. Howard Calleja na dapat mas mababa sa 13 ang voting threshold ng mga senador-judge sa impeachment trial ni... HeadlinesIMPEACHMENT Ridon: ‘Unexplained wealth’ ni VP Sara, hindi piso-piso September 13, 2026 - 12:00am Hindi umano dapat palagpasin ang hindi maipaliwanag na paglobo ng yaman ni Vice President Sara Duterte, dahil hindi ito simpleng piso-piso o barya-barya lamang. HeadlinesLAW Arraignment ni VP Sara sa grave threats case, ipinagpaliban 1 day ago Ipinagpaliban nitong Biyernes ang nakatakdang arraignment ni Vice President Sara Duterte sa kasong grave threats sa Quezon... HeadlinesDOJSARAVP VP Sara kay Pangulong Marcos: Magbitiw ka na sa puwesto! 1 day ago Nanawagan kahapon si Vice President Sara Duterte kay Pang. Ferdinand Marcos Jr. na bumaba na sa puwesto. HeadlinesMARCOS JR.SARA DUTERTE next Recommended Palasyo: VP Sara gusto agad umupo kaya pinagbibitiw si Pangulong Marcos Binuweltahan ng Malacañang si Vice President Sara Duterte matapos nitong atakihin at manawagan ng pagbibitiw ni Pangulong Ferdinand Marcos Jr. 22 hours ago MALACAñANG Voting treshold sa VP Sara impeachment trial dapat mas mababa sa 13 – Calleja Iginiit ni Atty. Howard Calleja na dapat mas mababa sa 13 ang voting threshold ng mga senador-judge sa impeachment trial ni Vice President Sara Duterte, dahil hindi lahat ng 24 na miyembro ng Senado ay nakikilahok sa paglilitis. 22 hours ago IMPEACHMENT Ridon: ‘Unexplained wealth’ ni VP Sara, hindi piso-piso Hindi umano dapat palagpasin ang hindi maipaliwanag na paglobo ng yaman ni Vice President Sara Duterte, dahil hindi ito simpleng piso-piso o barya-barya lamang. 22 hours ago LAW Arraignment ni VP Sara sa grave threats case, ipinagpaliban Ipinagpaliban nitong Biyernes ang nakatakdang arraignment ni Vice President Sara Duterte sa kasong grave threats sa Quezon City Regional Trial Court (RTC) matapos hilingin ng kanyang mga abogado na ipagpaliban muna ang paglilitis habang pinag-aaralan ng korte ang kanilang mosyon. 1 day ago DOJ SARA VP VP Sara kay Pangulong Marcos: Magbitiw ka na sa puwesto! Nanawagan kahapon si Vice President Sara Duterte kay Pang. Ferdinand Marcos Jr. na bumaba na sa puwesto. 1 day ago MARCOS JR. SARA DUTERTE OK Are you sure you want to log out? Yes No X Login Philstar.com is one of the most vibrant, opinionated, discerning communities of readers on cyberspace. With your meaningful insights, help shape the stories that can shape the country. Sign up now!
