If Mumbai can shine for royals, why not citizens? Bombay High Court raps BMC

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from India Today (indiatoday.in). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
The Bombay High Court on Wednesday questioned why Mumbai's roads and public spaces are cleaned and spruced up only when VIPs visit the city, asking the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) to ensure the same standards of cleanliness for ordinary residents throughout the year.

The Bombay High Court on Wednesday questioned why Mumbai's roads and public spaces are cleaned and spruced up only when VIPs visit the city, asking the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) to ensure the same standards of cleanliness for ordinary residents throughout the year.

A bench of Justices Girish Kulkarni and Neela Gokhale pulled up the civic body over its approach to maintaining public spaces.

The judges cited the example of Ballard Estate in south Mumbai, which was cleaned and washed with water ahead of the visit of Britain's Prince William and Princess Catherine, who are on a three-day tour of India.

"Look at Ballard Estate. How shining and polished it is. You have cleaned the streets with water because some important guests have come. Why should Mumbaikars not have such roads?" the bench asked.

Prince William and Princess Catherine began their three-day India tour on Monday with a visit to Ballard Estate, where they played gully cricket with cricket legend Sachin Tendulkar and local children. The event unfolded against the backdrop of colonial-era buildings, tree-lined streets and freshly cleaned roads. The BMC had also covered certain sections of the road with white cloth ahead of the royal visit.

The judges said it was unfortunate that a constitutional court had to deal with the problem of garbage piling up on public roads and questioned why the BMC could not maintain the same level of cleanliness for residents as it did during visits by important personalities.

"When important people visit the city, the BMC spruces the streets up. Why can't this be done at all times for the people living in this city? Instead of indulging in such a two-day temporary show that our roads are neat and clean, the BMC can have a permanent show," the bench remarked.

The court stressed that cleanliness should not be restricted to areas visited by VIPs but must be ensured across every ward of the city.

It also observed that the state government and the civic body could bring about a significant transformation if they demonstrated the will to act.

The remarks came while the court was hearing a petition raising concerns over air pollution and the emission of toxic gases near the Kanjurmarg dumping ground in Mumbai's eastern suburbs.

The bench said the issue of landfill management was closely linked to the larger problem of garbage being dumped on the city's roads and beaches.

During the hearing, the bench also raised concerns over the large quantities of plastic waste found at dumping grounds and on public roads, questioning why authorities had not taken more aggressive steps to curb its use.

The judges, who visited the Kanjurmarg landfill site on Tuesday, said they were surprised that plastic continued to be widely used despite the long-standing problems associated with its disposal and treatment.

"We are confronted with this kind of toxicity for years. Why are we still not giving up plastic?" the bench observed, pointing to heaps of garbage containing plastic at the dumping ground.

The court asked the Maharashtra government whether it had a policy to tackle plastic waste and sought details of measures adopted by other states and Union Territories to impose a complete ban.

It also asked whether plastic had been prohibited in tourist destinations such as Matheran and Mahabaleshwar in Maharashtra.

Questioning the BMC on why it could not take a more stringent stand, the bench said, "Why, in so far as Mumbai is concerned, not take an aggressive step, not to succumb to any other commercial interests, but to ban in totality plastic? That would be the only way forward so that we save the planet, we save this city."

The judges also called for aggressive public awareness campaigns to discourage littering and highlight the environmental impact of plastic waste.

"Look at the amount of plastic bags strewn on roads. Even during monsoon, tonnes of plastic are thrown back from the sea," the bench said.

The court observed that preventing non-degradable plastic waste from being generated in the first place was essential, particularly as the problem worsened during the monsoon when the sea washed accumulated garbage back onto the shore.

The matter will be heard next on December 7.- EndsMust Watch

Journalist. Where ever there is news, you will find her there. Covers court, crime and is also part of the India Today Fact Check Team. But her first love remains - Photography.

Original Source
https://www.indiatoday.in/india/law-news/story/bombay-high-court-questions-bmc-vip-cleanups-seeks-mumbai-plastic-ban-3042189-2026-11-19?utm_source=rss
Visit India Today β†—
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Technology