Investors Should Beware Anthropic’s IPO - Newsweek
Investors thinking about buying on Anthropic's first trading day on Thursday should consider waiting for a better entry point, according to Ken Fisher, billionaire investor and founder of Fisher Investments. In an interview with Newsweek, he warned the AI trade peaked earlier this year and valuations in the sector may continue to decline over the short term.
Fisher believes it is too early to tell if Nvidia is a buying opportunity after recent declines in the stock, following the departure of chief executive Jensen Huang. That will depend on whether Nvidia's board is able to preserve what Fisher describes as Huang's "hugely unusual management structure" that he believes was a major driver of Nvidia's success.
Fisher was quick to slam Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent for his comments over the weekend when he suggested that Nvidia needed to look outside the company for a new chief executive.
Looking ahead, Fisher believes there are risks in the $1.5−2.0 trillion private credit market where disruptions could create a cascade effect similar to the mortgage market that sparked the great financial crisis of 2008-09, while geopolitical risks in overlooked areas could further stress markets.
Anthropic is seeking to raise up to $64.4 billion at a valuation of $1.4 trillion in the first of the major U.S. AI companies to go public. The stock will start trading on the Nasdaq on Thursday in what will be a major test of sentiment given recent market jitters over whether AI valuations have become too stretched.
"You almost always get a better deal, if you want to own the stock, long after it's gone public, than at the offering or shortly thereafter," Fisher told Newsweek. "The fact of the matter is, it's probably overpriced."
"Offerings are not brought for the benefit of the consumer; they're brought for the benefit of the issuer, or the issuer wouldn't do them," he said.
While Fisher believes that AI is a transformative technology that will have similar far-reaching consequences for the economy as the internet, signs are the AI trade peaked in the current cycle during May and June.
One indication for him is that semiconductor stocks—a proxy for the AI companies—have seen significant declines over that period.
The SOX semiconductor index, which measures the performance of 30 companies in the semiconductor industry, including Nvidia, Broadcom, and Intel, has fallen 34 percent after rocketing to an all-time in June. That new reality is reflected in Anthropic's valuation expectations which were parsed from an initially reported $2 trillion.
"Do I think AI is real? Yes. Do I think AI will do great things? Yes. Do I think it all takes longer than its proponents think it will. Yes, I do think it'll take longer," Fisher said.
"Therefore there will be disappointments. And therefore, I'm not very optimistic."
However, Fisher is quick to point out that the current hype around AI is a far cry from the dot-com bubble of the 1990s that led to a more than 77 percent crash in the Nasdaq from March 2000 to October 2002, when hordes of companies with hardly any revenue depended on selling into public markets to stay afloat.
"This time the IPO market has been a few big companies with actual revenue, actual businesses—that may be overvalued or not, that's debatable—but they're not going to go poof and disappear off the face of the earth the way so many dot coms did between 2002 and 2004," said Fisher.
Nvidia's stock has nose dived 27 percent since a New York Times report that led to the resignation of its charismatic CEO Jensen Huang. Despite Nvidia being what Fisher describes as a major holding of Fisher Investments, Fisher is reluctant to call the declines in the stock a buying opportunity.
Fisher believes that much of Nvidia's success has been down to the management structure that Huang put in place, that the board will be unable or unwilling to preserve.
"Jensen Huang traveled all around the world, being a salesman for Nvidia product, and how he pulled all that off successfully is unique. So I'm not sure that the replacement for it succeeds," Fisher said.
"If the replacement for it is not destructive to the culture of what Nvidia is, and allows Nvidia's management to go on doing what it's doing, then I think it's a buying opportunity. If the replacement says we got to bring in somebody who would manage it the way somebody might manage IBM, I think the stock is probably not."
While Colette Kress has been named as Nvidia's interim CEO, Fisher said he would be open to Huang returning, providing the right guard rails were put in place. However, in an call with investors after Nvidia published third quarter earnings on Tuesday, the chairman of Nvidia's board, Harvey Jones, said the board "does not intend to reinstate Jensen as CEO."
Fisher slammed Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent for his recent intervention when he told Fox News on Sunday that Nvidia's culture needed "a dramatic shake-up" and the board should "go outside the company" in its search for a new leader.
"I am appalled that a Treasury Secretary would say such things. It's not in his remit," said Fisher. "Normally, Treasury secretaries don't get involved with trying to tell businesses what to do."
Looking ahead to 2027, Fisher believes that risks loom in places that are not on investors' radars.
These include the private credit market where disruptions could force a regulatory intervention such as the mark-to-market rules that Fisher believes led to the financial crisis in 2008-2009, as well as geopolitical risks in relations between India, China and Pakistan as the areas north of Iran.
Contact Newsweek editor on this story: Mike Hirst.

