JD Vance Dealt 2028 Blow Against Marco Rubio in Post-Midterm Poll - Newsweek
Vice President JD Vance has fallen behind Secretary of State Marco Rubio as a potential White House contender, according to a new Emerson College poll of the 2028 presidential contest, as the Republican Party continues to grapple with losses in the aftermath of the midterm elections.
Rubio held his first lead over Vance and other Republicans in the Emerson poll published on Thursday, with nearly 36 percent of Republicans naming the former Senator and Trump Cabinet member as their first choice.
Only 20 percent of respondents said they backed Vance, according to the poll of 1,000 voters conducted from November 14 to November 16, with a margin of error of plus or minus 3 percentage points.
The numbers mark a significant shift from the pollster’s July survey, when Vance led Rubio by a single point, 39 percent to 38 percent. In February, Vance held a much more substantial 32-point lead over Rubio, 52 percent to 20 percent.
The poll comes as 2028 speculation ramps up following the midterms. Although the first primary votes will not be cast for more than one year, hopefuls could begin exploring White House runs in the coming months in hopes of building an early advantage.
Polls will likely continue to change as the primary season gets underway, but these early numbers do have important implications for candidates. Donors and voters often use polls to determine if a candidate has a viable path, so the numbers could affect fundraising and whether candidates decide to get into the race or stay out.
The fluidity of the recent polling shows “how unsettled the 2028 GOP primary for president is,” Brent Buchanan, founder and CEO of the Republican polling firm Cygnal, told Newsweek.
“Republicans have been moving away from Trump Republicanism since the 2024 election,” he said. “Our data shows that in the midterm election, traditional conservative Republicans outnumbered Trump Republicans by almost 2-to-1.”
Matt Klink, a Republican strategist, told Newsweek that Republican voters “want a winner” and are looking “for a stronger brand.”
“VP Vance carries the administration's baggage without controlling its decisions, and the polling shows the cost. Two years is a long runway, but the VP needs a story that is his own,” he said.
Newsweek reached out to the offices of Vance and Rubio for comment via email and press contact form.
Rubio and Vance were the clear GOP front-runners in the new poll, but many Republican voters said they were still not sure who they would support for 2028 and some rallied behind other candidates.
Twelve percent said they were undecided, while 7 percent said they would vote for Florida Governor Ron DeSantis, who previously ran in the 2024 presidential primary.
Just under 7 percent of respondents said they would vote for Kentucky Representative Thomas Massie and President Donald Trump, who is ineligible to run for a third term.
Klink said Vance and Rubio “are the race for now.”
“DeSantis sits at 9 percent, a distant third. Rubio has said he would not run if Vance enters, so the matchup may never happen. Two years is a political lifetime,” he said.
Trump cannot run again due to term limits, and it is expected there will be an open and competitive primary in both parties for the first time since 2016. Trump administration officials have been viewed as potential candidates, as the president remains popular among the conservative base, even as his approval has waned among independents.
But no prominent individuals have announced 2028 campaigns so far.
Vance told Fox News’ Laura Ingraham on Monday that he would make a decision about a potential run next year.
"My understanding is that with the presidential campaign is there is a lot of infrastructure that you have to set up, fundraising, all that stuff, and so you cannot declare a month before the Iowa caucus that you’re going to run for president," he said. “So I haven’t made a decision. We’ll figure it out sometime next year.”
Other recent polling has been more favorable toward Vance.
Vance led by 14 points in an Echelon Insights poll, with 40 percent compared to Rubio’s 26 percent and DeSantis’ 12 percent. It surveyed 397 likely voters from November 12 to November 16.
A YouGov poll showed Vance up 7 points, with 41 percent compared to Rubio’s 34 percent and DeSantis’ 12 percent. It polled 354 registered voters from November 9 to November 11. It had an overall margin of error of plus or minus 3 percentage points.
Vance has a narrow edge in prediction markets as of Thursday morning.
On Kalshi, Vance had a 32 percent chance of winning the Republican nomination, compared to Rubio’s 19 percent and DeSantis’ 16 percent. Vance similarly had a 34 percent chance on Polymarket, with Rubio and DeSantis following at 18 percent and 15 percent.
Prediction markets allow traders to buy and sell contracts tied to political outcomes and current events, aggregating real‑money wagers into probability estimates.
Prices fluctuate as traders react to polling, fundraising, candidate developments and broader political trends. They measure trader sentiment at a given moment but do not always accurately predict the future.
Vance has become increasingly vocal in his criticisms of the Iran war in the aftermath of the midterms. The war, which sent gas prices soaring due to disruptions to the Strait of Hormuz, has been pointed to as a major vulnerability that contributed to a GOP wipeout in the midterms.
Vance wrote in a social media post after the midterms that a Republican pollster told him the war was one of the top reasons for GOP losses.
“The reason we lost is the war. The president himself said so last night,” Vance wrote. “If you'd like to argue it was worth it, that losing the Senate for the next 6 years was worth it, then do so. Argue it was a worthwhile cost to pay. Agree or disagree, that's at least honest.”
During a recent interview with Fox News, Vance criticized “neoconservatives” who he believes want the U.S. to remain in the Iran war indefinitely, but said Trump would not allow that to happen.
“We are not going to allow this to become a 10- or 15-year commitment, or, frankly, even a two-year commitment, despite the fact that a lot of neoconservatives and a lot of other people want us to stay there forever,” Vance said.
Buchanan said that most Republicans support the Iran war and that Vance is “boxing himself in to appeal to the more apolitical younger voters who oppose the Iran War.”
“That's not an insignificant group because many of them stayed home in the midterm, and it cost the GOP many seats that may have withstood a blue wave but without younger centrist to right-leaning voters couldn't survive a blue tsunami,” he said.
Still, that could be an asset in a general election, Klink said.
“Ending the war in Iran is a top-two priority for 49 percent of voters. Primary voters reward loyalty to Trump more than daylight from his policies. Rubio's national-security résumé gives him an edge with the hawkish wing of the GOP,” he said.
A widening divide over the Iran war could loom over the Republican primaries. While Vance and some other MAGA-aligned conservatives are ramping up their critiques of the conflict, others have defended the war.
Trump announced earlier in November that he has asked Vance to focus on alleged crime and corruption in Democratic-led states and cities, rather than play a more central role in negotiations to end the Iran war.
Some conservatives have expressed frustration with Vance’s criticisms. Fox News host Brian Kilmeade said on his radio show that Vance “never should have been vice president.”
Former Vice President Mike Pence told NBC News’ Meet the Press on Sunday that Vance’s assessment is “wrong.”
“We didn’t lose this midterm election because of the war,” Pence said.
Historically, candidates begin announcing their presidential runs soon after the midterms, so campaign season could kick off in the coming weeks and months. Polling will continue to be monitored as a key gauge.
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Samantha Beech and Geoffrey Rowland.