John Fetterman Breaks Ranks With Democrats in Bid To End Iran War - Newsweek

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from Newsweek (newsweek.com). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
U.S. Senator John Fetterman broke with nearly every member of his party Thursday, voting against a Democratic-backed measure seeking to end President Donald Trump's military campaign in Iran.

U.S. Senator John Fetterman broke with nearly every member of his party Thursday, voting against a Democratic-backed measure seeking to end President Donald Trump's military campaign in Iran.

The Pennsylvania Democrat was the only member of his caucus to oppose the war powers resolution, which was defeated in the Senate by a vote of 48-51.

The vote put Fetterman at odds with fellow Democrats at a time when opposition to the Iran conflict has become an increasingly prominent political issue following the November midterm elections.

Three Republican senators—Susan Collins of Maine, Lisa Murkowski of Alaska and Rand Paul of Kentucky—joined almost the entire Democratic caucus in supporting the measure.

Fetterman, a vocal supporter of Israel, has consistently taken a different position from many Democrats on the conflict, making Thursday's vote another example of his willingness to break with his party on foreign policy.

The resolution would have directed Trump to end U.S. hostilities in Iran. However, the measure was largely symbolic and would likely have faced a presidential veto even if it had passed.

Newsweek has reached out to Fetterman for comment via email.

The resolution was defeated 51-48, with one senator—Democrat Chris Murphy of Connecticut, who suffered a stroke last month—not voting. It marked the first major Senate vote on the Iran conflict since Democrats made gains in the November 3 midterm elections.

The three Republicans who crossed party lines were Collins, Murkowski and Paul.

Fetterman's vote was particularly notable because he has repeatedly opposed similar efforts to restrict Trump's military authority over Iran.

In September, he was again the only Democrat to vote against a comparable resolution, which failed 49-50. He also opposed earlier efforts in July.

The latest resolution had already cleared the House in September, with seven Republicans joining Democrats in supporting restrictions on Trump's military actions.

Fetterman has been one of the most outspoken Democratic supporters of U.S. military action against Iran, repeatedly defending Trump's approach and arguing that preventing Tehran from acquiring a nuclear weapon must remain the priority.

Speaking to CNN's Dana Bash on State of the Union on March 1, Fetterman said his support for the military campaign was not unlimited, but argued that action against Iran was necessary.

"President Trump was the guy willing to do that to make sure that didn't happen," Fetterman said, referring to preventing Iran from acquiring a nuclear weapon. "If just putting out tweets and using harsh and strong language was effective, Iran wouldn't have been on the path to acquire a nuclear bomb."

Fetterman also defended the administration's decision to launch strikes, saying: "So, for me, finally, do you really want to have real peace? Do you really want to have real security in the middle region? So, let's do that. And that's why I fully support that."

In an interview with CBS News on March 11, Fetterman described the military campaign as "very effective" and said he believed it was moving toward an "appropriate outcome." "I think, overall, what's accomplished is remarkable," he added.

Fetterman also acknowledged the political consequences of his position within his party, saying: "I'm the only Democrat in the Senate" who supports the war.

He also said that the issue was "much more important than just voting what your base might demand."

Fetterman's position on Iran is part of a wider breakdown in his relationship with the Democratic Party.

Once viewed as a progressive Democrat capable of expanding the party's appeal among working-class voters, Fetterman has increasingly found himself at odds with colleagues over foreign policy, immigration and the party's approach to Israel.

His outspoken support for Israel has been a particularly significant source of tension.

Fetterman has criticized Democrats he believes are too willing to condemn Israel while failing to hold Iran and militant groups including Hamas and Hezbollah equally accountable.

His disagreements have become increasingly public, with the senator regularly appearing on conservative media outlets and criticizing members of his own party.

The divide has also fueled questions about whether Fetterman still has a political future within the Democratic Party.

The growing divide reached another flashpoint over the contest to replace Chuck Schumer as Senate Democratic leader.

Fetterman has indicated that the election of Senator Chris Van Hollen of Maryland over Schumer would be a breaking point for him.

Speaking to Fox News, Fetterman described Van Hollen as someone who had made his name being hostile toward Israel.

Asked whether there was a red line that could prompt him to leave the Democratic Party, Fetterman said: "Yeah, absolutely, it would be troubling if my caucus elects someone like Van Hollen."

He questioned why Democrats appeared more inclined to criticize Israel than Iran, Hamas or Hezbollah.

"I don't expect my party to change, but I'm always going to put our country before party and I'm going to look for and extend my hand for bipartisanship," he said.

Van Hollen, meanwhile, has suggested that Fetterman could be looking for an exit from the party following their disagreements.

Fetterman's increasingly strained relationship with Democrats has prompted questions about whether his departure would be welcomed by some members of his own party.

His potential exit has become a subject of debate following the midterm elections, which strengthened Democrats' position in Congress and could reduce their reliance on his vote.

Some Democrats and progressive commentators have expressed little concern about the possibility of losing Fetterman, arguing that his positions on Israel and other issues have increasingly placed him outside the party's mainstream.

His potential departure has also been discussed alongside the growing possibility of a Democratic primary challenge in Pennsylvania.

Ahmed Moor, a Palestinian American writer and businessman, has already launched a primary campaign against Fetterman.

Representative Chris Deluzio has said he is seriously considering running for the seat in 2028, while Representative Madeleine Dean has also indicated she is weighing a challenge.

Deluzio recently told supporters that taking on Fetterman would mean confronting not only the senator but also AIPAC, Trump and significant corporate spending.

While some Democrats have questioned whether Fetterman still belongs in their party, prominent Republicans have made clear they would welcome him.

Senator Ted Cruz of Texas said in a post on X that Fetterman was a friend and that Republicans would welcome him "with open arms" if he decided to switch parties.

Cruz subsequently praised Fetterman's willingness to stand up to members of his own party.

"John Fetterman has shown incredible courage standing up to the crazies in his party," Cruz said.

Trump has also encouraged Fetterman to switch parties, previously arguing that he would perform better as a Republican than as a Democrat.

Fetterman has so far maintained that he remains a Democrat, despite his disagreements with the party.

When asked directly on Capitol Hill in September whether he would become a Republican, he responded: "I'm not going to be a Republican!"

Fetterman's political future has become increasingly uncertain as speculation grows about a possible party switch ahead of the 2028 Senate election.

He has not confirmed whether he intends to seek reelection, but a Republican candidacy has emerged as one possible scenario.

Prediction market Kalshi recently put the odds of Fetterman leaving the Democratic Party at 31 percent before August 2027 and 30 percent before January 1, 2028.

Political science professor Grant Reeher of Syracuse University previously told Newsweek that a move to the Republican Party could present significant challenges.

"A lot of Fetterman's positions and views do not fit well with the Republican Party," he said, adding that becoming an independent could be a more likely option.

Reeher also questioned whether Fetterman could survive a Republican primary, given his voting record.

The Senate vote came as the financial cost of the conflict continued to increase.

Arthur Miller, the Pentagon's deputy comptroller for Budget and Appropriations Affairs, told the Senate Armed Services Committee on Thursday that the Iran war had cost approximately $48.3 billion as of November 13.

The estimate includes military operations, munitions and equipment replacement costs. It does not include the full cost of damage to American military facilities across the Middle East.

The figure represents an increase from the slightly more than $47 billion estimate reported in October, adding to questions about the long-term financial implications of the conflict.

Democrats have increasingly pointed to the financial burden, alongside the impact on American service members and rising consumer costs, as reasons for Congress to reconsider the administration's military strategy.

Thursday's vote does not bring the Iran conflict any closer to an immediate congressional-mandated end. The failed resolution leaves Trump without a new Senate restriction requiring him to withdraw U.S. forces from hostilities with Iran.

For Fetterman, the vote is another high-profile example of his willingness to break with his party on foreign policy.

Newsweek’s reporters and editors used Martyn, our AI assistant, to produce this story. Learn more about Martyn here. Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Samantha Beech and Edward T. Cummins

Original Source
https://www.newsweek.com/john-fetterman-iran-war-powers-resolution-democrats-12742994
Visit Newsweek ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Politics