Kelly McParland: Smith covers her bets for Alberta vote - National Post
Premier Danielle Smith speaks at a press conference in Calgary on Tuesday, Sept. 1, 2026. Photo by Darren Makowichuk /PostmediaArticle contentIn the 18 weeks since Alberta Premier Danielle Smith set the date for her multi-part referendum on the province’s future the reaction in much of Canada has ranged from perplexion to… continued perplexion.
As in, why is she doing this? Has she noticed that Justin Trudeau is gone and Mark Carney is a different sort of prime minister? That the supposedly Liberal regime in Ottawa has vacuumed up Conservative policies and repackaged them as Liberal priorities?
The puzzlement doesn’t fade when it’s pointed out that the share of Albertans supporting departure has never been much above one in three and sometimes less than one in five, that the estimated price of forging a new country is somewhere between costly and ruinous, and that the result of numerous government members advocating for a “leave” vote has been a sharp boost in support for the New Democratic Party.
Columnist Jesse Kline keeps you up to date with what’s happening in Israel and the effects of antisemitism on life here in Canada. Friday mornings.
A welcome email is on its way. If you don't see it, please check your junk folder.
The next issue of Channel Israel will soon be in your inbox.
We encountered an issue signing you up. Please try again
If you were searching for a parallel in Canadian political history you might come across the ill-conceived attempt of Alberta’s own former prime minister Joe Clark to pass a deeply unpopular budget in 1979 despite heading a minority government that lacked the votes to push it through.
The conclusion of that escapade was the defeat of Clark’s Tories after just nine months in office and the resurrection of Pierre Trudeau for his fourth term in office, with 126 seats in Ontario and Quebec and zero in Saskatchewan, Alberta or British Columbia. It was a bad gamble that left onlookers wondering who could possibly have thought it would turn out well.
In the current situation, the identity of the guiding culprit is no mystery. It was Smith’s decision to cobble together 10 questions for Albertans to address, including a proposal to consider a later proposal to abolish Alberta as a province and bring it back as a country.
Her reasoning for throwing the province’s place in Canada open to question is convoluted at best, and a big source of the public’s puzzlement. While professing to be a firm believer in Canadian unity she apparently feels the best means of confirming Alberta’s deep love of country is to hold a vote on whether to leave. And rather than put forward a straight up yes or no query, she’s running a referendum on whether to drag things out even longer. Come Oct. 19 the province will have a chance to decide whether to decide.
