Labour is spending your money to fix its problems - The Telegraph

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from The Telegraph (telegraph.co.uk). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
Higher taxes and employment law reforms, championed by Housing Secretary Angela Rayner, have had ‘unintended consequences’ for young people Credit: Leon Neal/Getty Images James Baxter-Derrington Investment Editor Show biography James is Investment Editor at The Telegraph. He was ...

Higher taxes and employment law reforms, championed by Housing Secretary Angela Rayner, have had ‘unintended consequences’ for young people Credit: Leon Neal/Getty Images James Baxter-Derrington Investment Editor Show biography James is Investment Editor at The Telegraph. He was previously the editor of Investment Week, where he also worked as news editor and a reporter. In 2023, he was named Journalist of the Year at the Headlinemoney Awards. He can be reached at james.baxter-derrington@telegraph.co.uk and @jamesbaxterd.

This Government has a nasty habit that it just can’t kick, and if it’s allowed to continue, it’ll take us all down with it.

The occupants of Downing Street are utterly addicted to spending your money and they do it with such gay abandon one might almost suggest they’ve forgotten whose cash it actually is.

To spend public money is a gift and a privilege that should be welcomed with commensurate respect, yet without fail, Andy Burnham’s Government doles it out with scant consideration, and – more egregious still – squanders it on fixing issues of its own making.

It must be said that myriad previous governments of all stripes could be accused of the same, but Burnham’s operation has turned it into something of an art form.

Despite its “do-nothing” Budget, or whichever term it’s currently favouring to dodge the big questions, the Government has been committing more and more of your capital to paper over the cracks in the jobs market it swung a sledgehammer at.

Last week, the Department for Work and Pensions revealed one of its solutions to the youth unemployment crisis that has surged since Labour took power, with a higher proportion of jobless 16-24-year-olds today than during the peak of Covid.

It’s called the Jobs Guarantee and it’s a rather simple concept. Following a successful trial, those aged 18-24 and on Universal Credit for more than a year will be given a guaranteed job for six months.

How can the Government guarantee a job, you ask? Easy – they’ll pay your wages. Not that you’ll be working in a government department, mind you. No, the public sector is being expanded into private companies.

When Alan Milburn said the Government “has to make it easier, cheaper and less risky for employers to create more jobs”, I doubt he meant for Whitehall to take his words to such extremes. For in this new scheme, employers have been offered a completely free and riskless method to create more jobs: the Government will take on the cost and the risk for them.

I would wager what he actually meant was removing needless restrictions and lowering the cost of employment for businesses to take on younger staff for their first roles. That’s what the businesses themselves are saying, anyway.

Over the past decade, the cost of employing an 18-year-old has risen by 40pc, almost an additional £7,000 – and that was before the Government yet again committed to increasing the minimum wage, a move cautioned against by everyone from the Left-wing think tank the Resolution Foundation to the chairman of the Confederation of British Industry.

The previous Labour administration lumped further costs on businesses through its increase to employer National Insurance, a move which arguably broke its manifesto pledge. 

There was also the hefty Employment Rights Act, championed by former and current Housing Secretary Angela Rayner, which Milburn warned had “unintended consequences” for young people.

And there are fresh barriers from Burnham’s Government to everyone who hopes to alleviate the youth unemployment crisis, including a proposed new law that would force employers to seek council permission to hire 16-year-olds for a Saturday job.

But rather than simply untangle these unnecessary burdens placed on businesses and repeal its faulty laws, Labour has doubled down.

Whether wilful or not, Labour’s ignorance of second-order effects has resulted in “unintended consequences”, to put it charitably.

It has raised taxes so high, increased regulatory burden until businesses tapped out and mandated costs to such a degree that it has created a situation in which it is simply unaffordable for many firms to countenance hiring young people.

But rather than remedying the situation, it has decided the best use of the extra taxes raised from businesses is to pay those selfsame businesses to employ the people the Government has made unaffordable to employ. Got that?

To pay the salaries of 90,000 people at today’s minimum wage for 25 hours a week for six months is an outlay of around £750m, almost four times as much money as Milburn’s review is hoping to save by 2036.

Young people today have clearly got a bum deal and things need to change if we’re going to avoid disaster for their futures and the rest of the nation’s, too. But rather than simply getting out of the way, this Government has decided its place is to pay the salaries of Lidl employees.

Spending more and more money cannot be the only solution when a problem arises. If it continues this way, that youth unemployment crisis might just become a general one.

Original Source
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/money/tax/news/labour-is-spending-your-money-to-fix-its-problems/
Visit The Telegraph ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Business