Liberal MP who chaired MAID study agrees with Tory proposal for separate votes - Toronto Star

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from Toronto Star (thestar.com). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
Marcus Powlowski says he agrees with Conservatives who have been calling for a government bill containing two key MAID amendments to be split. 

Marcus Powlowski says he agrees with Conservatives who have been calling for a government bill containing two key MAID amendments to be split. 

Liberal MP Marcus Powlowski speaks with reporters in the foyer of the House of Commons on June 17, 2026.

OTTAWA — The Liberal MP who chaired a parliamentary committee on Canada’s assistance in dying regime says he agrees with Conservatives who have been calling for a government bill containing two key amendments to be split. 

Marcus Powlowski made the comments after MPs voted Tuesday in favour of the bill, which would prevent medical assistance in dying (MAID) solely on the basis of mental illness but allow people diagnosed with some degenerative diseases to make advance requests for help in dying.

The vote passed 225 to 89, with 37 votes in favour from the Conservatives — the party that has most vocally opposed the availability of MAID to those with mental illnesses, which is scheduled to begin in March. 

Powlowski chaired a joint parliamentary committee that recommended against expanding that eligibility. He told reporters on Wednesday that he saw the Tory MPs’ vote split as reflective of their “conflicting views” when it came to the two amendments. 

The Conservatives have called for the government to split the bill, arguing the issue of advance requests belongs in its own bill and deserves far greater study than the proposal to reverse course on the mental illness expansion, which must move on a faster timeline in order to clear a final vote in the House of Commons, as well as the Senate, before March. 

Powlowski, who has expressed reservations over allowing advance requests for assisted deaths but voted in favour of the government bill, said he “would have preferred personally to have seen those two votes separated.”

Justice Minister Sean Fraser has rejected calls to deal with the two issues in separate bills.

Fraser has noted that the government heard from many experts on advance requests, and that access will ultimately depend on whether provinces develop their own policies that conform with the set of minimum standards proposed by the federal legislation.

Saskatchewan has already signalled it would do so. Alberta Premier Danielle Smith, whose government recently passed restrictions on further MAID expansions, said it would consult on the issue of advance requests, saying “there’s appetite” to take a second look.

Ben Lobb, a Conservative MP who voted for the government bill, said a parliamentary study on advance requests would inform his next vote.

“If they are unable to provide some more clarity to it, more definitions, more protections, then I’ll vote against it,” he told reporters Wednesday. 

Lobb said his decision to vote in favour of the bill on Tuesday reflected his belief that “protections” are needed when it comes to mental health. 

Conservative MP Corey Tochor, who also voted for the bill, said it was “important for me to stop the expansion” of assisted deaths to those with mental illnesses, adding he believes it would be “wrong for our society.”

“I just believe it’s horrendous on what we’re doing with MAID in Canada today,” he said. 

Other Conservative MPs said they had heard support in their home communities for advance requests. 

“My position is that Canadians largely want to see the ability to plan their own demise, if you will, or what happens if they become afflicted with something that they don’t have the ability to deal with down the road when that happens to them,” said Greg McLean. 

“I’ve had a lot of feedback on that from my constituents, and I do believe that they have that free will to make that part of their planning for certain life stages that may affect them going forward.”

Dan Albas said his vote reflected what he has heard in his B.C. riding rather than his own views. 

While he says reception to advance requests has been “mixed,” in the end “more people expressed support for it.”

Albas added that his riding is home to many seniors who have witnessed suffering firsthand. He expressed concern over the pace the government was moving with the bill, and said the parliamentary committee set to study it ought to hear directly from front-line health-care professionals. 

Prior to the vote, Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre told the House of Commons that the government created an “impossible dilemma” for his MPs by addressing mental illness and advance requests for MAID in the same legislation. 

“Unfortunately, the government has forced me and many others in this room into an impossible dilemma, those of us who want to ban MAID for mental illness and give people hope that they can have a brighter future and can come out of the bottom of the valley and get back to the mountain top,” he said in his speech. 

“We want to vote to save their lives, but we do not want to vote to introduce new dangers that could end other lives that people would believe are worth living.”

Conservative MP Andrew Lawton, who serves as the party’s justice critic, told the Star ahead of Tuesday’s vote that his party’s members had been granted a free vote on the matter, “and, just like among Canadians, there are differing opinions on various aspects of MAID.”

Lawton said he had heard “numerous different opinions” about allowing advance requests, but that Tory MPs were united in their opposition to allowing assisted deaths solely on the basis of mental illness.

He said he voted against the bill because he could not support it as written.

“That’s really difficult because I have fought for years to stop the mental health expansion and it’s really shameful that (advance requests are) being lumped in with this bill.” 

Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request.

There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again.

You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply.

Stephanie Taylor is an Ottawa-based reporter covering federal politics for the Star. Reach her via email: staylor@thestar.ca

Original Source
https://www.thestar.com/politics/federal/liberal-mp-who-chaired-maid-study-agrees-with-tory-proposal-for-separate-votes/article_04060efa-5640-4521-b302-41a5d16a749f.html
Visit Toronto Star ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Health