Livvy Dunne & Landry Kiffin team up for a girls' night out in NYC, NCAA Punt of the Year & a sad free throw

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from Fox News (foxnews.com). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
Screencaps, America's Best Daily Column, mixes GTA 6 talk, Livvy Dunne taking Landry Kiffin under her wing in NYC, and a reader bidet debate.

Welcome to Screencaps, "America's Best Daily Column," as named by the readers. Screencaps, which publishes seven-days-a-week, is a mix of sports, pop culture, and emails from sane readers from around the world. This column isn't for the coastal elites. Give us a week to steal your heart. Our track record is pretty good. Let's have some fun.

📩 Email: joe.kinsey@outkick.com
Send photos, stories, tips, rants—whatever you've got.

📰 Screencaps Page:
👉 Read the latest Screencaps

'GRAND THEFT AUTO VI' MANIA COMES WITH SERIOUS HEALTH RISKS, DOCTORS WARN

KIRK HERBSTREIT SERVING STEAK TO HIS DOG AT AN NYC RESTAURANT HAS CRAIG CARTON FUMING MAD

Here's Wednesday Screencaps in case you missed Don's diatribe.

• Mike in West Lafayette, IN says: Don’s email to you was one of the more entertaining and insecure things I’ve read in a while. I spent 20 years as a high school teacher and for some reason the male English teachers often operated with that same insecure/condescending tone. He’d obviously do anything to be in your position right now, but doesn’t have anything interesting to say so will never get the opportunity to write for an audience larger than a few impressionable teenagers. Keep up the great work, love the articles.

• Nate from Minocqua emails: My favorite line was, 'I am the furthest from some PC snowflake'. If he is arguing that he isn't, shouldn't he have some facts to back up that statement? As you say, go back to reading the NY Times, and voting blue no matter what tool they put a D in front of.

• Matt B. reacts: I love how English teacher Don tries to be so articulate and intellectual sounding while not knowing the spelling difference between "later" and "latter". Stay hot just like your cheating UM teams, Donny!

• John the Attorney emails: Hey Joe, thanks for sharing your "fan" mail from Mr. Rhetoric himself. lol.  While reading his email that he very clearly went to painstaking lengths to get his grammar and punctuation correct (except he missed "latter"), I couldn't help but think of some of my douche bag English teachers in high school who thought they were smarter than everyone because they used commas correctly (usually).  The best part is that the guy teaches HIGH SCHOOL.  This isn't some Oxford educated master of Greek Rhetoric principles.  This is a State university educated (not knocking that btw, just saying), self-aggrandizing a-hole who flunks kids for not indenting paragraphs.  And he clearly doesn't understand that the Pathos in your column (no quotes needed) is exactly what you aim for.  The only ones laughing in Mr. Rhetoric's AP class are the ones who need extra credit.  MMD, what a loser.

• Dave takes aim at Don: It's been a long time. I still read Screencaps every day - thanks for pumping up my mornings. I noticed some errors in Michigan Man Don's post, some that are unforgivable for an AP English teacher (notice the big, puffed-out chest laying out the creds). First, he says, "As a teacher of rhetoric and one that likes to share various columns with my AP classes,..." the proper phrase here should be "one WHO likes.." Who refers to a person; that refers to a thing. Heck, even Google underlined it as a problem when I copied it in here!

Second, he writes, "text-book example of the later and...". The proper word here is "latter", the word that refers to the second item in a pair. "Later" refers to a time beyond now.

I find it funny when people start with their bona fides then trip up when they try to correct what they claim to be an expert in.

• Travel Ball Hardo Chris B. in Houston enjoyed it: I've laughed at the hate mail that Clay posts for years, and now I get to laugh at yours too.  Some crazy people out there.

• Jim T. in San Diego 'gets' what my job is here: Well, Don is quite full of himself, isn't he? He lets us know in his first sentence that he teaches AP classes! Not just any old classes - nope, Don works with the elite! And he teaches rhetoric!

He's a regular scholar is what he is.

Sigh ...

I am gong to, within Don's own academic environment, pull a bit of rank on him here: I taught an upper-division English class at an accredited four-year university for seven years, I am widely published in both the popular and academic press, and I contributed to two reference books. (that is all for Don's benefit, not that of your normie readers.)

For someone who teaches rhetoric - i.e., the art of persuasion - he's not practicing it very well.

First, effective rhetoric depends on logical consistency. It's boring academic stuff for most of us, but a high school rhetoric teacher ought to be be familiar with it, so bear with me briefly. Our Michigan Man opens with a red herring fallacy, claiming he read your column because he was concerned about what Desmond Howard had to say. But his dismissive tone and the fact that he quickly pivots from that topic make clear that that was merely an excuse to provide him an opening for launching into an attack on you. He dismisses your arguments without ever exploring them, and then makes the column about you. So he follows up on his red herring fallacy with an extended ad hominem fallacy.

Two fallacies do not a logical argument make.

The use of quote marks around the word "writer" to delegitimize your work is amateur stuff (and both red herring and an appeal to authority fallacy). He then continues using quote marks as some sort of virtue signaling nonsense. (The great Miami Herald humor columnist Dave Barry, in his periodic "Ask Mister Language Person" persona, once suggested just using quote marks randomly to sound important. We're pretty sure he was just joking, but perhaps some high school English teachers took that to heart as actual advice.)

Finally, Michigan Man Don exhorts you to do better for, and I quote him directly here, "a bunch of aspiring sixteen year olds.."

Say what? One aspires to do something in the future. Are they aspiring journalists? Aspiring high school rhetoric teachers? Perhaps, for their own sake, aspiring Ohio residents? The only aspiring sixteen year olds are those who are not yet 16, and I would hope that even in that state up north the younger teenagers have greater life goals than merely turning 16.

But perhaps sitting in Michigan Man Don's daily AP rhetoric class is so stultifyingly boring that it beats the very ambition out of them. (And, yes, Don, that was very much an ad hominem fallacy.)

• Dan from AZ checks in: I’ve been absorbing all of the angry emails you’ve been receiving and your responses have been, frankly, quite appalling. I can’t believe how careless and divisive you’ve been replying to all of these people and refusing to consider their perspectives on these various topics. It’s made me reconsider wanting to continue reading SC going forward.

PSYCHHHHHHHHHHHH

Just kidding. Your responses have been absolutely hilarious and spot on. And everyone that keeps piling on to defend bringing their precious dogs with them everywhere just keeps further proving your point. Look, bring your dang dogs to bar patios or other establishments that willingly market themselves as dog-friendly all you want, but quit acting like there aren’t a zillion entitled dog owners these days that bring them where they obviously don’t belong. Complaining about those of us who don’t want to see your 100 lb ADHD golden retriever at places like indoor restaurants or narrow aisled grocery stores just makes you look foolish.

And not to keep beating this dead horse (next emotional support animal?), but don’t get me started on the freaks who claim that raising a dog is analogous to raising a child and refer to themselves as a "dog-mom" or "dog-dad". Maybe a rant for another time.

Don’t ever change, Joe. There’s plenty of us who are right there with you so you can keep paying those bills!

• David W. checks in: I went back and read the Screencaps again on November 14 and did a little research on who is who for the most part and I have the big picture. I get it about the rivalry with Ohio State and Michigan. Desmond Howard never should have made the remarks against Jeremiah Smith and is beneath any analyst on any major network. Any college team who wouldn’t want Jeremiah Smith on their team is brain dead. I do have a remark about gobbledygook criticism as well, reference to English Teacher Screencaps dated 11/18, just say it and get it over with and we will all be better off in the long run.

THE CRAIG CARTON SHOW–UNFILTERED, UNAPOLOGETIC AND UNMISSABLE. DOWNLOAD HIS DAILY PODCAST NOW!

• Tom B. has something to tell Snowflake Don: I enjoyed Don’s email to you. You may want to remind Don that every Washington Redskins fan thinks Desmond Howard is a massive loser and scumbag since he was a wasted first round draft choice that they will never get back. I don’t have much respect for High school teachers either.

ZERO BS. JUST DAKICH. TAKE THE DON'T @ ME PODCAST ON THE ROAD. DOWNLOAD NOW!

• Tom T. is annoyed by a commercial: I think the portrayal of men as doofus losers in TV commercials has hit a new low. There was some sort of AI medicare commercial on ESPNU during the MACtion where an old white dude with a nice house was berated by his wife AND A TALKING DOG for not taking advantage of the bennies. A talking damn dog. It made me laugh. SMH

#################

SIGN UP FOR THE DAILY OUTKICK NEWSLETTER

That should be enough this morning. There's not another column in the United States with emailers as smart as Screencaps. I'm fully expecting incredible takes on bidets, a subject that we've covered in the past. Let's finish the week strong and then coast into the Thanksgiving holiday.

Get after it.

Original Source
https://www.foxnews.com/outkick-sports/livvy-dunne-landry-kiffin-team-girls-night-nyc-ncaa-punt-year-sad-free-throw
Visit Fox News ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Education