Luistro: Defense testimony ‘self-destructive’ on VP investments

MANILA, Philippines — House lead prosecutor Gerville Luistro described the defense’s testimony in the impeachment trial of Vice President Sara Duterte as “self-destructive” after its witness acknowledged the official’s investment in a Jollibee branch and P2.14 million in payments she received from GenCorp Industries Inc.

Luistro was referring to the testimony of Suzette Balucanag-Punay, corporate counsel of GenCorp and Metro City Chow Foods Corp.

During the trial, Punay testified that GenCorp’s records showed total disbursements of P2.1 million to Duterte from 2022 to 2025, which she described as a return of capital from an earlier investment in a Jollibee Times Square branch.

While maintaining that Duterte was not a GenCorp stockholder, Punay distinguished the Vice President’s investment in the Jollibee branch from ownership of the corporation itself.

For Luistro, however, the testimony showed that Punay did not deny the investment.

“Even explaining that she calls it loose investment, whether loose or otherwise, it is still investment,” the lead prosecutor said.

GenCorp appears among the business interests listed in Duterte’s 2024 and 2025 statements of assets, liabilities and net worth.

Luistro also pointed to Metro City Chow Foods Corp., where corporate records show Duterte holds a 20-percent shareholding and is listed as a director.

Punay confirmed Duterte’s corporate positions, including her membership in the company’s compensation committee.

Turning to the defense’s presentation of evidence, Luistro suggested that the withdrawal of witnesses could indicate that they did not want to be associated with or support the party that had requested their testimony.

She made the observation after noting that 18 of the 24 witnesses initially listed by Duterte’s defense team had already been withdrawn, a development she said could create a negative impression among the public.

“If there are witnesses who are declining, the easiest interpretation would be that they do not want to be identified as supporting the position of whichever party,” Luistro explained.

The withdrawals, she added, had dampened the high expectations surrounding the defense’s presentation of evidence against the allegations raised by the prosecution.

“The defense’s presentation of evidence did not begin explosively because it started with the withdrawal of a very important witness,” Luistro said. “We were anticipating explosive testimonies and/or evidence, but apparently, this was not even a firecracker. It might have been a watusi firecracker instead.”

Meanwhile, the House prosecution panel is prepared to question witnesses about Duterte’s dollar accounts if the Senate impeachment court allows it, according to Luistro.

Prosecutors were ready to cross-examine defense witnesses on the foreign currency deposits after Bank of the Philippine Islands (BPI) documents submitted to the impeachment court confirmed the existence of the accounts.

However, the defense opted not to present BPI senior vice president Paul Roderick Ysmael, whom prosecutors had wanted to question about the deposits.

Luistro acknowledged that the court had expressly excluded foreign currency deposits from the subpoenas because of bank confidentiality laws.

Similar restrictions also arose during the 2012 impeachment trial of former chief justice Renato Corona.

Any further testimony involving Duterte’s foreign currency accounts would ultimately depend on the impeachment court, she stressed.

“If the impeachment court allows the defense to present the witness later on regarding the foreign currency deposits, it will be up to the impeachment court. But we will definitely be very much ready to conduct our cross-examination,” said Luistro.

abtestabtest OCTA Research rejects bias claims over Leni-Sara surveys, cites Duterte's lead 7 hours ago OCTA Research has rejected claims that its hypothetical 2028 election surveys were rigged to favor Naga City Mayor Leni ... Headlines Sara Duterte's GenCorp declaration may be 'Freudian slip,' says lawyer By Alyana Uy | 12 hours ago If the vice president wasn't a GenCorp stockholder, why did she receive P2.14 million? Headlines Donald Trump's late arrival won't delay ASEAN summit closing — spox By Cristina Chi | 14 hours ago United States President Donald Trump's late arrival to the 49th ASEAN summit next week will not push back its closing,... Headlines Makati court issues extradition warrant on Quiboloy, co-accused in U.S. charges By Ian Laqui | 12 hours ago Makati court finds probable cause, also issues hold departure orders against 3. Headlines Latest More in Headlines ‘Extradition arrest warrant vs Quiboloy out DFA: Sea Code of Conduct up in the air Another oil price rollback seen next week ‘Comelec can set new BSKE date without new law’ abtest President Marcos to hold bilateral meet with UN chief, world leaders By Helen Flores | 40 minutes ago President Marcos will hold bilateral meetings with the leaders of Australia, Brazil, Japan and South Korea on the sidelines... Headlines COA chair named SC justice By Helen Flores | 40 minutes ago President Marcos has appointed Commission on Audit (COA) chair Gamaliel Cordoba as associate justice of the Supreme Court,... Headlines Meralco rates rise in November By Brix Lelis | 40 minutes ago Over eight million customers of Manila Electric Co. (Meralco) should brace for higher electricity bills in November as rising... Headlines Corruption crackdown, digitalization among new BIR chief’s top agenda By Aubrey Rose Inosante | 40 minutes ago Newly appointed Bureau of Internal Revenue Commissioner Rolando Ligon Jr. has vowed to continue the agency’s efforts... Headlines Recommended Bomba ni Sara November 13, 2026 - 12:00am Nipasalig si Bise Sara nga kapin sa duha ka tuig silang nangandam sa iyang depensa. Nagsugod niadto pang 2024 dihang unang nitumaw ang mga istorya sa iyang impeachment sa House of Representatives. HeadlinesSARA DUTERTE Kinsay mas kahadlokan? November 12, 2026 - 12:00am Nireklamo si Bise Presidente Sara nga nasakitan ang mga trabahante sa Office of the Vice President . Kada banat sa administrasyon ni Presidente Ferdinand Marcos Jr. batok niya. Nahadlok. Naglibog. Nanghilak. Mao...r HeadlinesSARA DUTERTE Misakay sa China November 12, 2026 - 12:00am Daghan ang mialma sa pamahayag ni Vice President Sara Duterte atubangan sa mga Overseas Filipino Workers (OFW) didto sa Hong Kong tungod kay giisip ni sa uban nga “unpatriotic”. HeadlinesCHINA Apiking depensa ni Sara November 9, 2026 - 12:00am Hinaut nga dili tinuod ang pagduda sa House panel of prosecutors nga wala kaandam og depensa si Bise Presidente Sara Duterte sa pag-abot sa iyang turno karong buntag sa pagpadayon sa impeachment trial sa Senado...r HeadlinesSARA DUTERTE next Recommended Bomba ni Sara Nipasalig si Bise Sara nga kapin sa duha ka tuig silang nangandam sa iyang depensa. Nagsugod niadto pang 2024 dihang unang nitumaw ang mga istorya sa iyang impeachment sa House of Representatives. 1 day ago SARA DUTERTE Kinsay mas kahadlokan? Nireklamo si Bise Presidente Sara nga nasakitan ang mga trabahante sa Office of the Vice President . Kada banat sa administrasyon ni Presidente Ferdinand Marcos Jr. batok niya. Nahadlok. Naglibog. Nanghilak. Mao nga nipatuman sila og mental health program. 2 days ago SARA DUTERTE Misakay sa China Daghan ang mialma sa pamahayag ni Vice President Sara Duterte atubangan sa mga Overseas Filipino Workers (OFW) didto sa Hong Kong tungod kay giisip ni sa uban nga “unpatriotic”. 2 days ago CHINA Apiking depensa ni Sara Hinaut nga dili tinuod ang pagduda sa House panel of prosecutors nga wala kaandam og depensa si Bise Presidente Sara Duterte sa pag-abot sa iyang turno karong buntag sa pagpadayon sa impeachment trial sa Senado. 5 days ago SARA DUTERTE OK Are you sure you want to log out? Yes No X Login Philstar.com is one of the most vibrant, opinionated, discerning communities of readers on cyberspace. With your meaningful insights, help shape the stories that can shape the country. Sign up now!